New American Restaurants near Port Jefferson, NY

The Fifth Season American • $$$
34 E Broadway, Port Jefferson

Customers` Favorites

Warm Flourless Chocolate Cake
Natural Chicken Spring Rolls
Housemade Potato Gnocchi
Short Ribs with Polenta
Housemade Macaroni
Grilled Asparagus
Ahi Tuna Tartare
Caesar Salad
Duck Breast
Onion Soup

“One of my favorite restaurants! Every course offers great choices. Our daughter is vegan and there is always one or 2 options available for her, as well. The fish and meat are always accompanied by flavorful, interesting vegetables and starches. The wine options are plentiful. The decor is both attractive and comfortable with tables distanced for personal space. The staff is knowledgeable, friendly, and well established. Really nice dining experience.“

4.6 Superb268 Reviews
Old Fields Restaurant Port Jefferson New American • $$$
318 Wynn Ln, Port Jefferson

Customers` Favorites

Buttermilk Fried Calamari
Marinated Flat Iron Steak
Roasted Organic Salmon
S'Mores Brownie Sundae
The Old Fields Burger
Blue Point Oysters
French Onion Soup
Mashed Potatoes
Zucchini Chips
Fried Chicken

“Visited for dinner on a Saturday night. Started by ordering drinks, Bourb-Berry and their cider cinnamon drink. Both were extremely enjoyable and tasty, a good size drink without been overpriced. For starters we shared the buttermilk fried chicken which was very satisfying and a good portion to share between 2 people. Our main meals were their old fields burger and squid ink linguine. Both meals were great and very tasteful. Service was very good, our waiter was very friendly and visited our table often to ensure everything was up to our liking. I would highly recommend giving this restaurant a try if you are in the area.“

4.4 Superb55 Reviews
Prohibition Port Jefferson American • $$
115 Main St, Port Jefferson

Customers` Favorites

Kung Pow Cauliflower
Chicken and Waffle
Breakfast Burger
PBJ Wings

“Been coming for occasionally for the last 3 years. Absolutely love everything about the place, food is always amazing. The staff is stellar as well, always hustling and always super kind and attentive Tonight we had Heather at our server and she was absolutely killing it!! Heather was hustling like crazy and still managed everything she had going on, nothing but respect for her and everyone else! I hope that the staff gets amazing bonuses for all the hard work they put in every day here!!“

4.5 Superb66 Reviews
Nantuckets American • $$
9 Traders Cove, Port Jefferson

Customers` Favorites

Crab Crusted Salmon
Blackened Swordfish
Seafood Risotto
Seafood Paella
Grilled Oysters

“Went New Year’s Eve had an awesome meal off their special menu. Started off with a nice glass of German resiling wine, Shades of Blue, excellent! Then for appetizer had the crab cakes, loaded with crab topped with Aioli sauce, best I’ve ever had. Then had the fillet mignon with lobster tail, fillet had a good amount of gristle in the middle that I had to work around, other than that it was very good. Lobster tail was presented and seasoned very well in some sort of marinated butter, wine and garlic which I thought was top notch of flavor and tenderness. Came with the mash potatoes another good choice some of the best made. I can’t forget their delicious homemade multi grain bread which was very good. For last desert opted for the Crème Brûlée topped off with fresh made whipped cream, awesome. Let me also mention about our waitress very friendly and accommodating, great customer service.Overall had a very enjoyable and unforgettable experience at Nantucket's other than the fillet not being completely satisfied I give it the Cardillo Scale Rating Review of 4.8 out of 5. Will definitely be back again. Happy New Year ? ? ?“

4.1 Good90 Reviews
Maggie's eatery American • $$
465 NY-25A, Miller Place - 4.45 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Chicken Bowl
Chicken Milanese
Fried Fluke Gyro
Steak Sandwich
Avocado Toast
Arugula Salad
Shrimp Tacos
French Fries
Greek Salad
Salmon Bowl

“At this point we’ve had 5 different orders. And all are awesome.Greek salad (x3 because it’s that good compared to anything else nearby… even all the Greek spots).Fish and chips (best I’ve had in quite a while, it’s a must try)Shrimp taco'sSteak bowlThe burgerWould recommend each of these!“

4.9 Superb72 Reviews
Pace's Steak House Steak House
325 Smithtown Bypass, Hauppauge - 10.82 miles

Customers` Favorites

Filet Mignon and Lobster Tail
Pace's Seafood Platter
Salad with Blue Cheese
Jackson's Mac & Cheese
Pappardelle Bolognese
Lobster Tails Tempura
Double Cut Pork Chop
Petite Filet Mignon
Twin Lobster Tails
French Onion Soup

“Best steak! Insignia who?????? Paces is the way to go, first they got the best bartender in town glean and the manager Patrick the manager one of the best persons I’ve meet in a restarunt as well, both treated me with respect and like family !! Deff will be back and food amazing and drinks are to die “

4.6 Superb217 Reviews
Vincents_NYWF_Pizza Pizza Takeaway • $
384 Mark Tree Rd, Setauket- East Setauket - 3.85 miles

Customers` Favorites

Long Island Style Bacon Egg
The Manhattan Pizza
The Brooklyn Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
The Suffolk Pizza
The Nassau Pizza
The Bronx Pizza
Margarita Pie
Staten Island
The East End

“I’ve done the “One Bite” tour around Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Long Island—I’ve gone to the hole-in-the-wall word-of-mouthers, too. Vincent’s Pizza Truck is undoubtedly up there with the best of them. The plain pie is perfectly dressed; the crust, thoughtfully caramelized with the right hint of char. Expect a crisp bite with great chew and the right balance of sauce to cheese to top a pie as thin as these. Do not skip out on an opportunity to eat here. The staff is always friendly and well-spirited, really rounding out the experience as a whole.“

4.9 Superb31 Reviews

8
Noco

Noco American • $$$
429 N Country Rd, St James - 7.07 miles

Customers` Favorites

Nuttela Cake with Nuttela Gelato
House-Made Ravioli Florentine
Crescent Farms Duck Breast
Shrimp & Crab Spaghettini
Lemon Ricotta Cheesecake
Wild Boar Meatloaf
Day Boat Scallops
Spanish Octopus
Chocolate Cake
Noco Salad

“NOCO never disappoints for so many reasons! The staff are incredible and very attentive. The atmosphere is cozy and comfortable. And of course the food is of the best quality as well as the presentation. I only found this gem recently and will be my new favorite.“

4.6 Superb74 Reviews
Tony’s on the boulevard Italian •
175 Sound Beach Blvd, Sound Beach - 5.36 miles

Customers` Favorites

Meatball Parmigiana Sub
Eggplant Parmigiana
Broccoli Pizza
Pie

“My husband and I just recently moved to the area of Sound Beach! After my husband picked up Tony’s for dinner one night I knew we had to go back!!! An incredible, family owned business, and Their Veal parm was out of this world! We will most definitely be regulars at this amazing place and recommending to ALL!!!!!!“

4.6 Superb57 Reviews
Gabino's Diner Mexican • $
Farmingville - 8.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Enchiladas Mexicana de Carne
Bacon Cheese Burger Deluxe
Chilaquiles Con Arrachera
Chicken Avocado Soup
Vegetarian Burrito
Carne Asada Taco
Burrito Nortero
Tortilla Soup
Carnita Taco
Chorizo Taco

“Amazing low-key Mexican diner. Great limited short order menu. The roja sauce with the complimentary chips was great. I ordered chicken enchiladas which came ina green sauce topped with chopped steak and a fried egg. The horchata was delicious. Muy bueno.“

4.5 Superb40 Reviews
Flanagan's Pub Irish Pub • $$
451 Hawkins Ave, Lake Ronkonkoma - 8.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan Flat Bread
Oysters on the Half Shell
Burrata Chicken Sandwich
Traditional Fish & Chips
Corned Beef and Cabbage
Bourbon Tempura Shrimp
French Onion Soup
Mozzarella Sticks
Flanagan's Nachos
Fish and Chips

“I was actually at Flanigan‘s a week ago. Our food was delicious, the wine was very good, but the best part of the experience was the waitress, Sarah. She never stopped smiling, even though she was running around like crazy came over several times to make sure everything was fine. She is a very special server.“

4.4 Superb95 Reviews
Aji 53 Services Japanese • $$
1 Miller Pl, Smithtown - 8.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sushi & Sashimi Lunch Platter
Dragon Roll & Boston Roll
Christmas Roll
Kani Salad
Miso Soup

“Aji 53 was amazing all around from the moment we walked into the door until we left. The hostess, waitress, ambiance, food and presentation were impeccable! Everyone in my group had sushi, and I had the salmon teriyaki. Endings raved about their meals and cocktails. We'll definitely be back!“

4.4 Superb64 Reviews
eatMOSAIC New American
418 N Country Rd, St James - 7.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Trio of Desserts
Duck Breast
House Bread
Gazpacho
Steak
Soup

“I've never been to a restaurant like mosaic before. Very nice experience. The service was impeccable, never been to a five course tasting before. The food was unbelievable , the chef was the best. The atmosphere was ok, not matching the 5 star experience in the other categories. Overall a very nice evening.Dietary restrictions: Very unique. They call and ask if there is any restrictions.“

4.4 Superb50 Reviews
Voila the Bistro French • $$$
244 Lake Ave, St James - 6.68 miles

Customers` Favorites

Creme Brulee
Duck Breast

“My husband and I, along with another couple, ate at Voila the Bistro on Sat. evening 2/24. We had a wonderful dinner - great food, excellent service. We had a round table towards the back of the room - quiet. The highlight of the meal was the soufflé and I recommend leaving room for dessert. We'll definitely return to Voila sometime soon - I highly recommend going to this restaurant for a lovely night out!!“

4.4 Superb26 Reviews
The Grille in the Ville Bar & Grill • $
756 Horseblock Road, Farmingville - 8.2 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Mozzarella Wedges
Classic Caesar Salad
Wings

“Was very happy with our experience having our daughter’s first birthday in their beautiful party room! The food was delicious, service great, and such a nice atmosphere. Coordinating the party with Jenn was an easy and pleasant experience! Thanks for a great time!“

4.3 Superb35 Reviews
Husk and Vine Kitchen and Cocktails American • $$$
655 Middle Country Rd, St James - 7.43 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tempura Bang Bang Shrimp Street Noodle Bowl
Mediterranian Olive Hummus Appitizer
Asian Style Kobe Beef Meatballs
Bang Bang Shrimp and Noodle
Asian Style Kobe Meatballs
Vegetable Flatbread
Charcuterie Board
The Wagyu Burger
Brussels Sprouts
Style Pretzels

“This is a woman owned business and she supports other local women owned businesses. The large, but cozy room in the back of the restaurant makes it a great place to have events. Thanks to the chef, who cooked 3 different types of pasta. In addition, the buffet style food was delicious. The waitresses were attentive, knowledgeable, and professional. The pictures were worth the visit.Parking: Large free parking lot is available in the back of the restaurant“

4.3 Superb83 Reviews
Loading...
map Map