10 Best American Restaurants near Preston Potter Hollow

Browse menus, reviews and photos of American Restaurants near Preston Potter Hollow.

Showing 10 of 10 restaurants

  • Two Guys Local Bites - Preston Hollow 2939 NY-145, Preston-Potter Hollow American · $

    1 Two Guys Local Bites - Preston Hollow

    4.7 Superb 97 Reviews

    2939 NY-145, Preston-Potter Hollow

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Chili Cheese Fries
    • Chicken Wings

    “glad we stopped in today, the hot honey chicken bacon sandwich was amazing. the place is also spotless clean. another little gem to add to my list of great places to eat.”

  • The Perch Hotel 7604 NY-23, East Windham American · $$

    2 The Perch Hotel

    4.9 Superb 76 Reviews

    7604 NY-23, East Windham · 7.81 miles

    “Super cool spot! Amazing views, nice rooms, recently updated. It’s a gem of a place. Would definitely go back.”

  • The Yellow Deli 7771 NY-81, Oak Hill American · $

    3 The Yellow Deli

    4.8 Superb 90 Reviews

    7771 NY-81, Oak Hill · 4.38 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Pastrami and Cheddar Sandwiches
    • Cheesy Potato Soup of the Day
    • Beef Barley Soup
    • The Egg Sandwich

    “I've been to other locations but this one was the best when it comes to atmosphere. I requested to sit by the stream. Listening to the stream and nature while sipping on coffee was memorable. I had ALWAYS loved their food so complaints. I just wished the waiter was checking in. It was hard to get his attention. Ex. He would give water and dissappear or give the bill and dissappear for a long time. I had the egg sandwich and Joe with beef chili soup.”

  • Union + Post 5098 NY-23, Windham American

    4 Union + Post

    3.9 Good 75 Reviews

    5098 NY-23, Windham · 8.76 miles

    • Take-Out

    “The food was amazing. The wings, rib eye, ricotta appetizer 😍 the service was just as good. The Tesla charger outside was a huge plus. Lindsey our waitress was so helpful and I can’t wait to go back next time I visit. 10/10.”

  • Shell Inn 4520 NY-85, Rensselaerville Pizza · $

    5 Shell Inn

    4.8 Superb 47 Reviews

    4520 NY-85, Rensselaerville · 9.29 miles

    Customers’ favorites

    • Spinach Artichoke Dip
    • Spaghetti & Meatballs
    • Cordon Bleu Bites
    • Chicken Parmesan

    “⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ From everything I’ve heard, the Shell Inn has a wonderful reputation in the community. People consistently talk about the warm, welcoming atmosphere, attentive staff, and the care they put into their service. It seems like a place where quality and professionalism are top priorities, and where visitors can feel comfortable and valued. It’s encouraging to see a business that focuses on creating a positive experience for its patrons and supporting its employees. Definitely a place I’d love to visit based on what I’ve heard!”

  • Milk Run 3498 NY-145, East Durham American · $

    6 Milk Run

    4.5 Superb 27 Reviews

    3498 NY-145, East Durham · 5.61 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “Nice people - good service, awesome breakfast sandwiches, pumps open 24 hours. 👍”

  • The Clubhouse at Windham Mountain Club 36 South St, Windham Pubs · $$

    7 The Clubhouse at Windham Mountain Club

    4.1 Good 14 Reviews

    36 South St, Windham · 9.11 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Hot Dog 8

    “The course was absolutely stunning and was in great shape will be back for more.”

  • Chicken Run Family Restaurant and Steak House 5639 NY-23, Windham Family · $$

    8 Chicken Run Family Restaurant and Steak House

    4.2 Good 124 Reviews

    5639 NY-23, Windham · 9.33 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Fried Chicken Honey Dipped
    • Corn Bread on the Side
    • The Chicken Run Combo
    • Complimentary Popcorn

    “We had a very good overall experience. The food was solid, and the steak I ordered was absolutely outstanding—definitely the highlight of the meal. Others in our group didn’t enjoy their dishes quite as much, so I would especially recommend going for the steak selection and asking the servers for guidance—they are extremely knowledgeable and very kind. They also offer a great selection of beers and well-made cocktails. I always appreciate being asked about my liquor preference for cocktails, and they handled that detail perfectly. Prices are very fair.”

  • WINDHAM DINER 5339 NY-23, Windham Diner · $

    9 WINDHAM DINER

    4.1 Good 125 Reviews

    5339 NY-23, Windham · 8.9 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Western Omelette and Home Fries
    • Chicken Marsala
    • Scrambled Eggs
    • French Toast

    “Dont let the name mislead you. They do serve diner food but it is, imo, the best diner food I have ever had. I prepare my own meals. I dont like to go to restaurants because most dont prepare food I am satisfied with, taste or freshnessof ingredients. This place sets the bar higher for the other local restaurants. The food is very good, and Ive tried almost everything. The prices are reasonable. This is my favorite place to eat beside my own cooking. The owners, the staff all very nice people. Makes me feel like Im visiting family not a diner”

  • Tap House Grille 5359 NY-23, Windham Bar & Grill · $$

    10 Tap House Grille

    3.9 Good 110 Reviews

    5359 NY-23, Windham · 8.92 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Cheeseburger with French Fries
    • Soft Shell Crab Cake Sandwich
    • Market Salad with Ahi Tuna
    • Burger and Onion Rings

    “We were going somewhere else until we saw the movement through the window, we decided to stop and to our surprise, live music started, by a phenomenal duo of women. The fast food, despite the limited menu after 8 am, was enough for us. We had the best wine of the trip, the Mark West Pinot noir, from California, I highly recommend it. Parking: Easy parking on the street”

American Restaurants Nearby

You May Also Like

  • Waffle House Launches Nationwide Delivery for the First Time

    Waffle House Launches Nationwide Delivery for the First Time

    Waffle House is finally delivering. The iconic 24/7 diner chain has partnered with DoorDash to bring its comfort food to customers' doorsteps across all 2,000-plus locations for the first time in its 70-year history. Customers can now order through Waffle House's website or mobile app, with DoorDash drivers handling fulfillment.