8 Best American Restaurants near Prospect

“Just a great mom and pop bar/grill in CNY. We stopped in because we were craving some wings that were talked about on Google Maps as we were driving around. According to past reviews about Tavern on the Gorge about thier wings, we gave it a shot. When we got there on our particular Monday, the owner Bill said that the kitchen was closed on Monday's. After letting Bill know that Google Map reviews brought us there for the wings, he turned on the fryer and made us some of the best damn wings in the CNY area!! Low and behold, another group of folks walked in and saw us eating wings and put in a HUGE order of wings as well. Needless to say, we had a second order of wings along with playing a few rounds of Quick Draw till our wings were ready. Overall, a nice little bar with a great owner. Thanks Bill!“

“John is awesome! He makes sure everything is done right. He goes above and beyond.“

“Our dinner was amazing today at forrestport dinner we had brisket dinner and fish fry many sides to choose from all very fresh and delicious also fresh rolls so good. The brisket lived up to all the great things we had heard. Also had calm chowder amazing and the famous donuts for desserts. Great service when we told them we were eating out by Dan.They packed all the items need for our family picnic. Thankyou“

“You know your prime rib be juicy when you leave a ring of it on your placemat. ? This place takes their prime rib very seriously. They were incredulous when I asked for an end cut because you’re only getting one if you time it right. Thankfully, I nailed the timing. In their defense, it shows their dedication to their craft, which is to make the most succulent prime rib in CNY!“

“They have good food but wow 16$ for a omelet I ordered a sausage bacon and ham omelet they gave me a everything omelet and when I mentioned it she acted like it was a big deal to make a new one so we took it. But it was 37$ for two omelets and two chocolate milks“

“Tho is rustic, they only use the finest fish, steak, shrimp, chicken & beef! There dishes surpass my 60 years of cooking! I don't know how Rich does it! He cooks better than I do!! The chicken wing, steak sandwiches, fish fry are all unbeatable!! My #1 desirable hidden gem & literally less than 1 mile from my home!! How lucky am I?? My favorite bar also!! Do yourself a service & check out Marcy Tavern!!“

“Awesome food!!! The Bloody Mary is a meal in itself!! Thanks Nikki!“

“Great food and cold drinks and good people to hang with!“