Otra Casita Mexicana
$$ • Mexican, Seafood, Cocktail BarAbout Otra Casita Mexicana
Customers' Favorites
Shrimp Burrito Bowl
Chicken Tostaditas
Guacamole Mexicano
Enchiladas De Mole
Aguacate Relleno
Steak Tampiquena
Grilled Calamari
Tinga Quesadilla
Chicken Burrito
Tacos Al Pastor
Otra Casita Mexicana Reviews
175 ratings
Share your opinion about Otra Casita Mexicana
I’m Mexican and very critical of Mexican food outside of Mexico. To start, servers Carlos and Paulina were super friendly, welcoming and attentive. First item on the table? Drinks and house chips. I ordered Jamaica water like I never seen before and the taste yuuuumm. Presentation was key. Chips were super crispy almost like real toasted tortillas (maybe they were) and instead of your typical salsa or pico de gallo, they were paired with a cheese dip with a little twist...read full review
Enchiladas de mole are to die for. Following yummy churros 😋
We had my mother’s 80th birthday party at Otra Casita Mexicana. Our event was held in the back room where our 40 guests sat comfortably.
The staff was wonderful and patient with our every request. The food was delicious . They make a very tasty sangria! Also, the restaurant (including bathrooms) was nice and clean. We will be back for dinner in the future
The staff was wonderful and patient with our every request. The food was delicious . They make a very tasty sangria! Also, the restaurant (including bathrooms) was nice and clean. We will be back for dinner in the future
Hours
| Monday | 12 - 10PM |
| Tuesday | 12 - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 12 - 10PM |
| Thursday | 12 - 11PM |
| Friday | 12 - 11PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 11PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 11PM |
Otra Casita Mexicana is a cozy restaurant on Fresh Pond Road, offering traditional Mexican food made with love and high-quality ingredients. The drinks are always delicious, especially the michelada, margaritas, and piña colada. The staff is friendly and attentive, with Katherine providing excellent service and the bartender, Carlos, going above and beyond with his great cocktails. The chef’s skills shine through in dishes like the steak fajitas, which are considered the best around, and the Vegetable burrito, a tasty vegetarian option. The "casita plate" remains a popular choice for sharing or a date night. The burrito bowl and nacho platter are both of exceptional quality, with the exception of cilantro. The restaurant’s charming decor and cozy atmosphere create a welcoming environment. Visitors can enjoy the private party room in the back for special events. Overall, this Mexican restaurant offers flavorful food, strong drinks, and outstanding service, making it a must-visit spot.