Cupcakes near Setauket East Setauket, NY

Rolling Pin Bakery • $
1387 NY-25A, Setauket- East Setauket

Customers` Favorites

Wedding Cake
Birthday Cake
Cake Samples

“We got married on 11/21/2025 at Three Village Inn Stony Brook and Rolling Pin Bakery was the bakery in our package and I couldn’t have been happier.
Communication was so easy. From setting up cake testing to placing the order. 10/10. The cake was beautiful and delicious!“

4.5 Superb71 Reviews
Alpine Pastry Shop Bakery • $$
59 NY-111, Smithtown - 6.8 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cannoli Pastries German Black Forrest Cake w Brandied Cherries
Whipped Cream Birthday Cake with Blueberries Fresh
German Black Forest Cake w Brandied Cherries
Specialty Occasion Ordered Custom Cake
Butter Cream Birthday Cake
Rainbow Cookies 1 2 Pound
Cassata Cake Cannoli 7 O
Italian Butter Cookies
Chocolate 7 Layer Cake
German Chocolate Cake

“Alpine truly can do it all“

4.1 Good162 Reviews
Sweet Treats Bakeshop Bakery • $$
Windward Ct N, Port Jefferson - 2.92 miles

“Valerie was extremely thoughtful and took the time to listen to my request for my sons themed party! Not only did they look amazing they all tasted delicious!!! Cookies, cake and smash cake!! So thankful!!!“

4.5 Superb17 Reviews
Christina's Creative Cupcakes Bakery • $$$
#112, Coram - 5.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cupcake

“Beautiful and delicious! Everyone loved these gorgeous cupcakes.“

4 Good8 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $$
2350 Middle Country Rd, Centereach - 4.96 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cake Batter

“I haven’t been to a Cold Stone in years. I happened to be in the area and decided to take my family. Due to the reviews I almost decided against it. I’m so happy my desire for a delicious Birthday Cake Remix superseded my hesitation. The staff were amazing. The young man that assisted me not only remembered our entire 5 sundae order, he made each of them with a smile. The customers ahead of us and behind us all received similar service. Every establishment has their off nights, staffing issues, bad moods etc. However, despite the poor reviews this place has received, I urge you to go if you’re reluctant to. My kids keep asking when we can go back. I wish I lived closer, but we do live close enough to return on a semi regular basis… which we will be doing.“

3.1 Average65 Reviews