8 Best Burger Restaurants near Shelter Island

The Islander Family • $$
63 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island

Customers` Favorites

Country Pot Roast
Mozzarella Sticks
Eggs Benedict

“Very good food and very nice, friendly people. We ordered the nachos and chili fries, and both were excellent!

The only small thing I would mention is that while we were still eating, someone started sweeping nearby. It wasn’t a big deal, just a friendly comment, but I felt it was a little inappropriate since we were still enjoying our meal. 😉 Overall, we had a great experience.“

4.3 Superb52 Reviews
The North Fork Shack Burgers • $
41150 County Rd 48, Southold - 5.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fish Sandwich with Tomato Arugula
Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich
Tacos and Wedge Salad
Cod Croquettes
Plantain Chips
Skirt Steak
Chowder
Burger
Fries
Wrap

“Shallot Dusted Fries ❤️ The very best ingredients and service is outstanding. Oh and also a unique experience. I was asked to model buy a photographer from Newsday eating. I said yes of course. Thank you The Shack for the hat ❤️ and making my perfect day even more special.“

4.3 Superb48 Reviews
First and South Restaurant & Bar American • $$
100 South St, Greenport - 2.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Oysters on the Half Shell
Fried Chicken Sandwich
South Street Chowder
Rockefeller Oysters
Oysters Rockefeller
Really Good Burger
Black Bean Burger
Kale Caesar Salad
Ahi Tuna Burger
Steamed Mussels

“Wonderful first time dining here!“

4.5 Superb124 Reviews
Nookies Pet Friendly • $$
1400 Silvermere Rd, Greenport - 2.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Maple Bacon French Toast
Focaccia with Ricotta
Koginut Squash
Crispy Chicken
Donuts

“Old school diner vibe. Spotless. Nice to drink out of glass instead of plastics like many restaurants there days.
Had traditional fish and chips but swapped out the fries for a salad. All great quality. Fish was fresh and greens simple but tasty. Husband tried the oyster soup and for him to say it was satisfying raised my eyebrow. Heard the desserts are great but too full to try. Don’t skip this gem.“

4.9 Superb47 Reviews
Ellen's on Front American • $$
38 Front St, Greenport - 2.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Tea Brined Fried Chicken
House Smoked Whipped Ricotta
Long Island Chowder
Marinated Olives
Ellen’S Burger
Fish and Chips
Ellen
Lenz

“Very nice atmosphere staff n owners chef are the nicest people My daughter is an employee and we were invited to dinner there n no other job that my kids have done that for the family! Beautiful place n beautiful people! The food is amazing“

4.5 Superb107 Reviews
eLTacobar Burgers • $$
62 Main St, Sag Harbor - 5.17 miles

“Great burgers 🍔 and shakes“

3.3 Good90 Reviews
Andy’s Restaurant Greenport New York American • $$
34 Front St, Greenport - 2.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Best-Ever Creamy Tomato Soup
New England Clam Chowder
Build Your Own Burger
Potato Skin Shooters
Sweet Potato Fries
Reuben Sandwich
Chicken Tenders
Fish and Chips
Fish Tacos
Pretzel

“Second time we have been there, both times food & service were great!“

4 Good87 Reviews
The Halyard Restaurant Seafood • $$$
58775 County Rd 48, Greenport - 3.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

Beer Battered Fish and Chips
North Fork Lobster Roll
Grassfed Halyard Burger
Classic Shrimp Cocktail
Shinnecock Sea Scallops
Grilled Swordfish Tacos
Summer Truffle Tartine
Oyster Ponds Oysters
Whipped Ricotta
Fluke Ceviche

“Food was good. The host was great and so was the waitress.“

3.8 Good390 Reviews

You May Also Like