17 Best Cocktail Bars near Shelter Island

SALT Waterfront Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $$$
63 S Menantic Rd, Shelter Island

Customers` Favorites

Yellowfin Tuna Poke Bowl R
Lobster Cobb Salad GF
Seared Tuna Sandwich
Classic Clam Chowder
Chicken Cobb Salad
Steak over Salad
Spicy Tuna Roll
California Roll
Blue Crab Roll
Lobster Roll

“Love this place for a million reasons“

3.9 Good284 Reviews
Little Fish Seafood • $$$
50 N Sea Dr, Southold - 6.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Blackened Fish Tacos with Mango Sauce
Grilled Chicken Croissantwich
Spicy Tuna Tartare Taquitos
Avocado Toast Grand Bazaar
Fritto Misto Della Casa
'the Shack' Lobster Roll
Blackened Fish Mon Tacos
Monk Fish Tikka Masala
'not Your Mamas' Mezze
Blackened Fish Montacos

“little Fish has the best fish and chips. we found this gem on our Tour of Ireland. excellent staff and excellent food!!“

4.6 Superb138 Reviews
Brix & Rye Cocktail Bar • $$
308A Main St, Greenport - 2.7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Italian Scallion Pizza
Build Your Own Pizza

“So fun. Such a great vibe.“

4.7 Superb47 Reviews
4

Almond

Almond American • $$$
1 Ocean Rd, Bridgehampton - 9.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sautéed Amagansett Greens
Steak Frites and 2 Sides
Sticky Toffee Date Cake
Turkey Burger Deluxe
Boeuf Bourguignon
Flan Cheesecake
Shrimp Cocktail
Birthday Cake
Roast Chicken
Moules Frites

“Great French/Asian fusion find in the Hamptons. My husband and I thoroughly enjoyed it. The ambiance was great, and the service was quick.“

4.4 Superb229 Reviews
Bell & Anchor Seafood • $$$
3253 Noyack Rd, Sag Harbor - 5.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

Guava Baby Back Ribs w Baby Spinach & Pine Nuts
Old School Lobster Garganelli
Flat Iron Steak Frites
Home Port Chowder
Fish of the Day
Bouillabaisse
Caesar Salad
Almond Cake
Guava Ribs
Frito Misto

“Food and service was wonderful!“

4.5 Superb106 Reviews
The Shipyard Restaurant & Bar Cocktail Bar • $$$
102 Main St, Greenport - 2.53 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buttermilk Captain Crunch Chicken Tenders
Sang Lee Watermelon \u0026 Burrata
Crispy Skin Montauk Striped Bass
Amagansett Sweet Corn Agnolotti
Local Clams on the Half Shell
The Shipyard Smash Burger
The Shipyard Cobb Salad
Spaghetti \u0026 Clams
Buttermilk Onion Rings
Grilled Summer Squash

“Amazing !!! It’s a must try ..“

4.1 Good73 Reviews
Black Llama Cocktail Bar • $$
300 Main St Unit C, Greenport - 2.69 miles

“Matty/maddy. You are amazing. Not only have you treated everyone amazingly well in the wedding I attended. You also took the time to understand everyone and their needs. This also goes for everyone of today, but Matty you are an unjudging God send
Thank you.

Also I hope I got your name right you are amazing and do deserve the praise and more.

The food here is great and light on the pallet. Everything so far here flows one after another. When it comes to weddings, this venue is amazing. As a guess this place has been accommodating and amazing flavors for me and my wife. If we were from NY we would have had our venue be this place. 10/10“

4.6 Superb16 Reviews
Claudio's Waterfront Bar & Grill • $$
111 Main St, Greenport - 2.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Claudio's Famous New England Clam Chowder
Local Clams on the Half Shell
Lobster Mac and Cheese
Baha Shrimp Tacos
Lobster Cobb Salad
Chicken Sandwich
Shrimp Appetizer
Dockside Raw Bar
Lobster Bisque
Fish and Chips

“went to the waterfront on July 4th weekend, great time with family and friends, food was ok/average....the bartender Jimmy was outstanding, a real genuine person, great service, knew his stuff 1000000%, and as hot as it was out there, he still managed to smile and serve above and beyond.....Great job Jimmy a true asset to any company!!!!“

4.1 Good658 Reviews
9

Alpina

Alpina Wine Bar • $$
45 Front St, Greenport - 2.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

House Made Swiss Sausage
Cacio E Pepper Agnolotti
Classic Wiener Schnitzel
Chartreuse Soufflé
Charcuterie Board
Bread Basket
Duck Breast

“Had such a great night. Sat at the bar and was treated so nicely by the bartender. Great drinks - my boyfriend thought it was best Manhattan he has ever had! Food is delicious, atmosphere is great for a date night. Had the racelette, pork schnitzel and the special osso bucco. All beyond delicious!!“

4.5 Superb91 Reviews
10

Sen

Sen Japanese • $$$
23 Main St, Sag Harbor - 5.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Salmon Cream Cheese and Crab Rangoon Rolls
Futso Rolls and Garuda Rolls
Spy Avocado Cucumber Roll
Avocado Roll and Inari
Spicy Edamame to Go
Crunchy Rice Tuna
Double Pork Ramen
Ikura Salmon Roe
Shishito Peppers
California Roll

“The food was fantastic and the atmosphere was very romantic!“

4 Good86 Reviews
Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House American
1 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton - 9.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

Broccoli Rabe Lemon and Chili
Jumbo Chocolate Chip Cookie
Mozzarella Tomato and Basil
Black Truffle Pizza
Warm Chocolate Cake
Slow Baked Salmon
Tuna Tartare
Kale Salad

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I had my birthday dinner at Topping Rose House, and it was an amazing experience—just like every other time we’ve been there. The food and drinks were absolutely delicious, and the service was outstanding. Our waitress was so kind and patient, even with our little toddler being a bit wild! Gerry was incredibly welcoming and made us feel right at home. They even brought out a dessert with a candle for me, which was such a sweet touch. Overall, a wonderful experience—I’d recommend this place 100%!“

3.8 Good68 Reviews
12

Isola

Isola Italian • $$$
15 Grand Ave, Shelter Island Heights - 1.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Olives and Flatbread
Chicken Parmigiana
Oysters Rockefeller
Pasta Bolognese

“Kayla and I had an amazing dinner Steak night. Kayla's steak was out of this world delicious. I had the Swordfish which was tasty and delicious. Thank you Brad for treating us like family. We will be back again soon.“

4.2 Good55 Reviews
PORT Waterfront Bar & Grill Seafood • $$
104 3rd St, Greenport - 2.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Daily Selection of Local Oysters R
Lobster Roll and Side Salad
Burrata and Tomato Salad
Lobster Roll with Fries
Lobster Mac and Cheese
Yellowfin Tuna Poke
Lobster Cobb Salad
Oysters and Sushi
Warm Lobster Roll
Port Baked Clams

“Great food and service. Thanks to Courtney and Kaitlyn for a wonderful dining experience. See you in the spring“

3.9 Good102 Reviews
Crazy Pizza East Hampton Pizza • $$$
47 Montauk Hwy, East Hampton - 10.33 miles

“Absolutely loved Crazy Pizza in East Hampton. The atmosphere is lively without feeling overdone, the service was warm and attentive, and the food was genuinely excellent.

Importantly, this is not the place for people expecting traditional, heavy pizza. These are lighter, roughly 500-calorie pizzas with some of the thinnest crust I’ve ever had. Personally, I love that because it feels clean and doesn’t leave you feeling weighed down. But it’s worth knowing going in that this is not deep dish or a traditional NY-style thick crust.

That said, if you like ultra-thin, crisp, flavorful pizza with great ingredients, it really delivers. It has that rare mix of being fun, polished, and still relaxed enough for a casual night out. Great spot for dinner with friends, date night, or bringing people from out of town who want something that feels very East Hampton but not stuffy.

Definitely one of the better dining experiences I’ve had out east. Will absolutely be back.“

3.4 Good28 Reviews
15

Anker

Anker Seafood • $$$
47 Front St, Greenport - 2.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Oysters on the Half Shell
New England Clam Chowder
Fish Merguez Sausage
Side of Home Fries
Mussels Marinara
Watermelon Salad
Fish and Chips
Seafood Tower
Hambúrgueres
Tuna Tartare

“I have been going to Anker for years now to enjoy great space,view,service,food & cocktails. Has never disappointed & makes the 1 hour drive each way worth it,kudos & Anker aways!“

3.8 Good104 Reviews
LT Burger Sag Harbor Burgers • $$
62 Main St, Sag Harbor - 5.17 miles

“Great burgers 🍔 and shakes“

3.2 Average111 Reviews
Claudio's Tavern & Grill Bar • $$$
111 Main Street, Greenport - 2.53 miles

“very nice experience! we were a group of 8 who had a reservation for 4 pm but were early in Greenport so we decided to see if they could accomodate us earlier. And they did! thing that stood out was the great service! Our server Nicole was very upbeat, friendly and efficient. So were the others, the hostess, etc. who made it seem they were happy to work there. Food was OK and we were a bit disappointed because the band that was supposed to play canceled so there was no live music. But the service made it a very gratifying experience. looking forward to next time.“

3.3 Good127 Reviews