Tuck Shop
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$$ •
75 N Menantic Rd, Shelter Island
(631) 749-5939
Tuck Shop Reviews
Popped in for dessert after dinner . Great place. Lots of flavors to choose from and girls are so nice and let you sample as many as u like. We got a few different flavors and must say they were all great . Def recommend .
Its open on july 10, 2020. I got 2scoops of ice cream(vanilla and pistachio) and a shake(something coffee flavor, espresso chip?forgot the name). Ice cream and shake were very delicious and employees were very nice. I could try some flavors. Theres plenty of seats outside.
Ratings
Menu
People in Shelter Island Also Viewed
Fabulous ice cream, worth the long line. Got the ferry sundae which was superb. Only complaint is getting the unpleasant “stare” when they turn the screen for the tip on the credit card, not appropriate for a local ice cream place. They should just have a tip jar. Here’s your 20% (really?) but I won’t be back.