Vine Street Café

Name: Vine Street Café
Address: 41 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, New York, 11964, US
Telephone: (631) 749-3210
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.2

$$$ • American, Italian, Asian Fusion

Hours:
41 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island
(631) 749-3210

Menu Order Online Reserve

About Vine Street Café

Vine Street Café offers exceptional service and very good to excellent food, making it a popular choice among both locals and visitors. The roasted beet salad remains a favorite, while the duck has gained recognition as a must-try dish, with some claiming it to be the best they've ever had. The food is consistently outstanding, with several reviews praising its delicious and farm-fresh quality. Fried chicken and linguini fra diavolo continue to be recommended options as well. The café is described as a calm and quiet restaurant, where every part of the meal and the ingredients in the dish are on point. The small specialty cocktail list includes perfectly made classics like gin martinis and Manhattans. Late-night dining at the café is a great experience, with a welcoming staff and reliably excellent food. The fresh baked baguette with butter is a signature dish, and the filet mignon and bolognese are delicious options for a relaxing meal. The outdoor area is well positioned, providing a lively atmosphere, and many guests appreciate the spacious seating under tents, which can feel like dining indoors. The attentive servers ensure that guests are well taken care of from the moment they arrive. Although some reviews mention that prices could be a bit more reasonable, the food and ambiance at Vine Street Café are always exceptional. It remains a favorite spot for celebrations and casual dining alike, with many regulars praising its consistent excellence over the years.