9 Best Pizza Restaurants near Silver Springs

Silver Springs Pizza Depot Pizza • $
130 N Main St, Silver Springs

“Great pizza, will order again.“

4.4 Superb19 Reviews
Wolf Creek Deli Pizza • $
104 N Main St, Castile - 2.65 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mac\u0026 Cheese w 2 Chicken Tenders
Large Cheese and Pepperoni Pizzas
Mac& Cheese w 2 Chicken Tenders
Large Chicken Finger Pizza
Butter and Cocktail Sauce
Cheese Pepperoni and Ham
Small Roast Beef Sub
Fried Shrimp Dinner
12 Cheeseburger Sub
Large Assorted Sub

“I arrived less than 5 minutes before closing and the staff member who took my order was very polite in asking if take out was okay, since they were closing soon. I ordered a turkey bacon cheddar melt on marbled rye and it was excellent. The homemade chips were amazing. The price was quite reasonable, too.“

4.7 Superb59 Reviews
3

Mel's

Mel's Pizza • $
19 N State St, Nunda - 9.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Blue
Loaded Fries
Sheet Pizza
Meat Lovers
Sub Salad
Wings And
Sauce

“I am in Nunda just about every weekend and is a sad time when I can't get there once. Have had several different categories of food and all have been awesome. Owner is super friendly and knows alot of people by name. Is a good place to stop if your in the area.“

4.4 Superb39 Reviews
Stefano's Pizzeria (New York Style) Pizza • $
12 N Main St, Warsaw - 6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Finger Salad
Bacon Cheeseburger
Mozzarella Sticks
Pizza and Wings
Pepperoni Pizza
NY Style Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Chicken Wings
Chicken Parm

“100 percent satisfied. Thank you!“

4.3 Superb39 Reviews
Daryl's Pizzeria Pizza • $
163 S Main St, Perry - 5.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Sausage and Mushroom Pie
Yummies Ice Cream Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Wings
Cheese and Pepperoni
Country Sweet Pizza
Peanut Butter Pie
Turkey Club Wrap

“Eaten there a couple times. If distance (750 miles) weren't a roadblock, we would eat there often especially cod on Fridays.“

4.3 Superb48 Reviews
Country Kitchen Restaurant Pizza • $
34 S Main St, Perry - 5.76 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fish & Chips with Coleslaw
Hamburger with Cheese
Vegetable Omelette
French Toast
Cheeseburger
Homefries

“Every time I’ve been there it’s been great. Friendly and helpful staff.“

4.2 Good27 Reviews
Doughboys Pizzeria Pizza • $
28 N State St, Nunda - 9.13 miles

“We had ordered from here last night and it was our first time and we just had moved in the area and they were so welcoming and friendly!! Gave us some brownies with our pizza with a little bag that said welcome! The pizza was real good too!! 10/10 for sure!!!“

3.8 Good16 Reviews
Charcoal Corral American • $
7037 Chapman Ave, Perry - 4.34 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Strawberry Shortcake Sundae
Large Fish Fry with Salt Potatoes
Chocolate Vanilla Swirl Custard
Chilli Dog and a Bowl of Chilli
Ice Cream Cone in a Dish
Campfire Deluxe Sundae
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Bacon Cheese Burger
Personal White Pizza
Prime Rib Sandwich

“This is an amazing little all-in-one restaurant that features North American, Southern as well as pizza and an ice cream shop all in one. They have daily and weekly specials. The food is fresh and they deliver as fast as they can given the volume of people they get. Well worth the money. Adding pictures of the menu as of September 2025 for those that have been questioning price differences check out my pictures!!“

4.6 Superb173 Reviews
Parkside Diner Family • $
6240 NY-19A, Castile - 4.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheeseburger Omelet
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Breakfast Sandwich
Hearty Hash Omelet
Park Side Fish Fry
Hollandaise Sauce
Cheese Omelette
Western Omelet
Steak and Eggs
Eggs Benedict

“I was in today to have lunch with my young grandsons, Michelle are waitress was wonderful! Food was great! Prices very reasonable!! Highly recommend!!“

4.6 Superb142 Reviews

You May Also Like