Bagels Restaurants in Staten Island, NY

“We ordered breakfast for five online on Christmas Eve and everyone loved what they got!“

“great“

“Whether it's their mini bagels, an egg sandwich, iced coffee, or pastries baked in-house - everything is delicious. Bagels & Buns is the type of local business we should all be supporting in the community; during these hard times especially. Service with a smile at all times and all employees do their best to accommodate all customers. See ya there Sunday mornings!“

“Food is awesome. Staff is like family.“

“Bagels by the Bay is fantastic. The food was delicious and super fresh, and the service was outstanding. The staff went above and beyond to ensure that I was satisfied. They were even kind enough to let me use their charger when my phone was dead. Great customer service is a big deal. Highly recommend!“

“Probably the best bagel I’ve had. Their cream cheese was on point, que quality of the dough was amazing and they were so fast preparing them as well.
We got an egg bagel with baggie cream cheese and eggs, and a cinnamon and raisin bagel with egg and cheese. Both really good. Perfect amount of everything and the perfect texture. On top of that, they are really nice and personable. 100% recommended!“

“I stopped in about 20 minutes before closing and they were still so welcoming and helpful! I have a gluten and dairy sensitivity, and they were super accommodating—recommending different baked goods for me to try. The owner was so sweet and you can really tell how much he cares about the quality of what he sells.

I got a ½ dozen GF bagels and a blueberry muffin and wow…both were amazing! He even gave me a few slices of their GF rye toast to take home and try before buying a loaf. Safe to say I’ll definitely be coming back for more—it tasted great and held up so well.

Also, the slices are way bigger than the GF bread you usually find at grocery stores or even other bakeries. I’m so glad I found this place—I’ll for sure be a regular!“

“Surprisingly, the room is bigger. Friendly staff. And the location is smack in the middle of where we need to go. Breakfast was included, and the staff asked what room we were staying in and welcomed us to a nice selection. As said on their site, if you used their parking service, it'll cost you 60. The garage next door offers 31 overnight. We loved the place and expect to come back“

“This place is awesome. Take it from someone who grew up in Brooklyn around the corner from Bell Bialy and Hot bagels. Heartland 2 are just as good and made the same old authentic way. 👍“

“I am a fan of Farm to Bagel...I have Celiac and the GF options are amazing! However, in my last 2 visits, including today, they made my food on the gluten grill. I had to point it out to them to remake it. Which they did, no problem...but what if someone who didn't know ate the food? I sent my sister from Boston there, she'd have no idea! That'd be a fine ride back home! Please, Farm to Bagel, do a better.job educating the staff!!! We GF-ers depend on you!“

“Love getting my bagels at Bagels R Us! Best Bagels!!“

“Just wanted to say as a native Staten Islander, and having moved to Florida every time I come here and visit I always come and get bagels at Mikey Bagels. We bring them back to Florida as they are the best. I just left the bagel store the staff and owner were wonderful. There bagels are delicious. I will always make this a staple when I stop here to visit to take back home.“

“Four stars because I just wish this lot would get rid of all this money beggars. They hang out in front and come in the store. The. You lose one and you gain another. They harass the customers to no end. Where is the landlord of this property??“

“The bagels are always fresh and coldcuts as well Nice clean bagel store . I wish they had more hours so I can go more often .“

“They have great tasting, hot, soft bagels!! I ordered a bacon, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel...Ahhh, let me tell you, I felt like I was biting into a piece of heaven. Yes, it may sound over the top, but when I'm here visiting Stateline Island, the first thing I want in the morning is exactly what I just told you. We don't get it that good upstate where I live!! You all are lucky!!! Enjoy!!!“

“11/20/25 Amazing Zabihah options on the Island that are generally very hard to find. Impressed with the selection and custom availability to change things for your order. Very friendly staff and helpful staff. Clean and nice area to sit. Rye bread option for the philly cheese stake with cheddar cheese was clutch! Looking forward to try more items on the menu. I hope they incorporate more reduced sugar free and reduced sugar options along with wheat-less breads w/o gluten.“

“They need to make more room in there maybe get rid of the iles and shelves n put a seating aka waiting area with a table n Nice to sit down and have a big screen TV and play QUICK DRAW!! Also more important it would be nice if they had a ticket order number machine so they can yell out a number when a order is ready and one person at a time can go to the register and pay instead of everyone hanging around on top of each other like animals lol...best bagels ever . Get rid of the shelves n stock and focus on the take out gold mine ..“

“If you’re looking for a top-notch deli, this place is a must-visit! The sandwiches are packed with fresh ingredients and the bread is always perfectly toasted. I tried the pastrami on rye and was blown away by the flavor—definitely some of the best I’ve had. The staff is friendly, and the service is quick, even during rush hour. This is my new go-to spot for a delicious, no-fuss meal. Highly recommend!“

“I preordered bagel breakfast for my team at work and picked up the order the next morning. Coffee was great and fresh, the bagels were beautifully arranged and neatly cut on the catering platter. Nice staff, owner helped me to carry everything to the car. Highly recommend!“

“This place has good food. The good food that I have eaten here has included chocolate chip muffin toasted on grill with butter; breakfast burrito with bacon, avocado, jalapenos, and hot sauce; spicy italian sandwich on a roll; and a rueben sandwich. This place has good coffee. The coffee flavor I like is called German Chocolate, but sometimes I mix it with other flavors. Sometimes I add a bit of cream. I eat the food and drink the coffee. It is open very early in the morning. Sometimes I buy milk or bananas here too. These food items have been satisfactory. I get napkins with my order for free.“

“Wonderful owners and staff ! We all go here every day- it’s our “go to” store- a local family small business. Love this place.“

“In Staten Island I only saw the Citi Bagel where the Morning and Evening both shift staff are very friendly and wearing the masks Durning making the food so I feel very comfortable to have have my food from Citi Bagels and I am not agree to the remarks of some one who says that staff do not wearing the mask when they serve the food please keep visiting the Citi Bagel to promote that kind of good businesses thanks“

“This deli is one of my favorites. The owners and workers here are super friendly. The food they serve here is delicious. I love getting a roll with cream cheese. The only bad thing is the parking situation. If a spot isn't open, they have metered parking. So make sure you have a couple quarters handy. And there is another deli right next door. This deli is located right after you get off the train station for those who take PT. They sell ice outside too.They sell cigarettes and protein cookies. The coldest soft drinks from orange juice to energy drinks. To simple odds and ends behind the register. This deli has it all.“

“Just down the road from a packed Not Just Bagels is Bagel Hut. Its a no-nonsense bagel store and deli. They had coffee on a fresh drip, bagels moving like lightning and coming out hot. While it didn't have fancier options like NJB or Bagel Box, it has everything you need for a good sandwich, cold cuts, some hot food, etc. I do not drink coffee but I saw they had a good setup. I had egg, chorizo, and provolone on a sesame. It was fresh and tasted good. Prices are low, appropriate for a mom and pop bagel shop.“

“Nice corner bagel store...very friendly staff...excellent egg and hero sandwiches.“

“I only stopped in for a quart of half & half for my morning coffee because with all the holiday shopping, I forgot to get my half & half & I had run out. The store had a large variety of hot & cold foods situated in a display case. All the food looked great. Some of the staff there were cooking in the back & preparing sandwiches & take out foods for the customers in the store. I had to wait just a couple of minutes to be rung up because the guys working, were really working. There is no sitting area, no table & chairs. The thing that annoyed me was the price of the half & half. $5 for a quart of Tuscan half & half. I paid the $5 cause I knew I would probably spend more then that in gas while driving around looking for another store that would sell it for pennies less on Thanksgiving night, lol. Anyway, like I said the food looked good, with a nice variety of cold cuts in the display also. It's good to know there is a 24/7 place that you can go to in the middle of the night for something important. I hope everyone had a.....
Happy Thanksgiving 🍂“

“I come here daily for my egg and cheese on a croissant. They make their croissants fresh there and they taste real good. They’re even better than some of the bakeries I went to. The gentleman who makes the sandwiches is a nice guy. The cashier is also very friendly and courteous.“

“People are writing some misleading things about page deli. There has never been a manager who smokes outside. There has never been any instance of food poisoning etc. place is busy during breakfast. They have the best layout, coffee area, variety of snacks and amazing bagels.“

“Overall, it was a good place to grab a bagel with something if you are in a rush. But I feel they can improve on bagels. They are good but not as good as bagel boy. They have potential they just need to try harder. Bagels are not as soft when you bite into them they are a little chewy. But maybe it's just my preference so I will give them the benefit of the doubt. Also they don't have a big variety of Bagels.“

“I was in a conversation last week about the BEST bagels we ever had. I've had A LOT of bagels over 56 years. Annadale Bagels provided me with my BEST BAGEL EVER.It was an egg bagel made to perfection. Perfection. It was delicious. This is my absolute GO TO place on Staten IslandHighly recommended! Hopefully you'll meet Manny. If you do, please tell him HI!“

“BEST SANDWICHES ! Delicious and fresh ingredients!“

“Best deli on staten island. The location next to the train station is super continent, the workers are so nice and very professional. My go too deli for every day needs. Just watch out for the high schoolers getting out of feral. Luckily this place even solves that problem!“

“Shop Smart is an amazing neighborhood store. The staff is friendly, the place is always clean, and the food is consistently fresh. Their hot Italian bread and homemade fresh mozzarella are honestly some of the best you’ll find anywhere. They also do incredible catering — everything arrives fresh, well-prepared, and delicious. It’s great having a place you can rely on for both everyday shopping and big family events. Highly recommend!“

“Amazing bagels and sweet employees!!“

“Best coffee ever delicious tuna everything is great“

“If you are on Staten Island visit Bagels on The Boulevard.... so delicious 😋“

“Excellent bagels, great portions for reasonable prices. Ample seating inside with some groceries available for purchase. Friendly staff, too!“

“Really wonderful to see a local Staten Island deli/eatery with so many gluten free options! This is quite rare in Staten Island. And it’s a casual and family-run place with great affordable pricing as well. Celiac & GF folks, tune in!“

“Bagel Depot is hands down the best spot on the island for bagels. Not only are their bagels the best tasting around, perfectly fresh with that classic chewy inside and crisp outside, but they’re also the cheapest you’ll find anywhere. You really can’t beat the value.

What makes it even better is how fast they move. They always have multiple people working the counter, so even if there’s a line, you’re in and out in no time. Great prices, amazing bagels, and quick service. Bagel Depot sets the standard. Highly recommend!“