Caffeinated New Yorker
$ • Coffee Shops, Cafe, TapasAbout Caffeinated New Yorker
Customers' Favorites
Mini Bagel Crisp
Guacamole Toast
Scone
Caffeinated New Yorker Reviews
88 ratings
Share your opinion about Caffeinated New Yorker
I always go in for the MATCHA, high quality, well prepared, nice and creamy, they didn’t have it today but the barista made me a CHAI to try instead. Now, I have another favorite drink on their menu. Will definitely come back. 🫶🏽
I went here when they first opened up and I had mixed feelings about it. I experienced not great customer service but their baked items were superior. So my family and I decided to grab coffee here today and my gawd... THE GLOW UP! We originally had wanted to grab and go but we decided to stay for lunch and everything was perfect. The staff was extremely friendly and sweet and on top of stuff, the food was delicious. My husband got the cuban and I ordered the pesto chicken...read full review
Asked the barista do light sweeten on my tiramisu latte and it was so perfect, it comes with tiramisu foam but also can taste the espresso in it. Im glad that Staten Island finally has some good signature coffee that can still actually taste like coffee! Definitely will come back again to try out their foods!
Hours
| Monday | 8AM - 4PM |
| Tuesday | 8AM - 4PM |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 8AM - 4PM |
| Friday | 8AM - 5PM |
| Saturday | 9AM - 5PM |
| Sunday | 9AM - 4PM |
Caffeinated New Yorker is an excellent place with a spacious and welcoming American vibe. The cafe is located in a brick building with a coffee cup sign at the front door. Inside, the decor feels homely and a little campy, with a bookcase, a little winery, and many art pieces on the walls. A comfortable back room features red curtains, a fireplace with wood, a couch, and chairs, creating a feel reminiscent of an 80s or 90s sitcom. The menu is fancy, offering items like the delicious SI Burger with sea salt hand cut fries, affogatos, and cortados. While some items like the chips were a little hard, the burger was very delicious. Service was excellent. The whole place is worth a visit for its unique, cool, and homely atmosphere.