18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sylvan Beach

“We arrived and were able to be immediately seated by a window overlooking Oneida Lake. this was on an early Sunday evening. There is live music and a tiki bar as well as outside seating if that is your preference. All three if our dinners were good as well as our appetizers. The service was prompt and friendly.“

“great pizza and desserts extra nice staff🤩“

“Always get great food and super friendly staff! Would highly recommend!“

“It's a neighborhood pizza joint and atmosphere, but they have some of the best pizza around. The sauce, crust toppings were great and the cheese was gooey all of high quality . their large is really large it fed me for 3 days and at a price that is cheaper then dominoes or papa John's. Definitly worth it.“

“Had Chicken bacon ranch pizza, wings and chicken Alfredo carbonara. Everything was absolutely delicious. Well done!“

“Wonderful customer service and as always the food is amazing. Love how they’ve always stayed true to their roots.“

“great pizza,cool people. when i,m in canastota,new york i always make a stop at joe,s new york pizzeria“

“Top notch pizza, love the arancini balls too“

“Best pizza & wings we've enjoyed in some time! Meaty wings were done perfectly & the pizza had fresh spinach and broccoli. Yummo 😋 And the service was quick & friendly - a great combo 😊“

“Best pizza in the area by far! Definitely a must try!“

“We were staying at The Haven in Chittenango, called a number of places for a delivery, no one would deliver. Finally called Hometown Pizza a half hour before they closed, not only did they delivery, they were fast, the food was amazing, and all employees I spoke with were friendly and polite. Thank you Nicole, and the entire crew.“

“Food has been delicious for as long as I can remember! Thank you to Jonna and her crew.“

“I had 2 slices of cheese pizza. It was really good but the pizza slices were really huge I half to be honest with you. It made me felt really loaded and stuffed.But maybe next time when we go back I will get one slice and some fries and a drink or chicken tenders and fries.“

“Always get our food delivered, always prompt and friendly. But let me praise their LAVA CAKES, those things are delicious and they should make them bigger! Pizza crust is delicious, love their loaded tots and boneless wings. Seeing and smelling their food makes me HUNGRY.“

“First time trying your place out, we went to the one in Oneida. Ordered the pizza and wing special from Facebook and it was truly amazing! Pizza had just the right amount of sauce and cheese and looked great. The wings were cooked perfectly, just like I asked. Customer service was excellent also! Thanks so much and we will definitely be back again!“

“This place is such a sweet spot to bring the family. Wonderful kind staff, always has a movie playing, and the salad bar is always fully stocked with fresh veggies. 10/10 recommend. Been coming for years and they never disappoint!!! Bring the kids, bring Grammy, bring yourself.i think the prices are pretty fair with today's prices too.“

“Tammy was so friendly and welcoming! It was our first time there and she made us feel at home. The bartender that came in after her didn’t give us the time of day. Since she couldn’t be bothered to ask us if we wanted anything, we left. Not great for business.“

“I ordered tonight and they made some errors but guess what we are all human. I watched someone yelling at the supervisor on duty and it really did make me sad. I thought the supervisor handled it well and I let him know that he did. Mistakes happen but people it’s just pizza 🍕 chill out when yelling at people.“