Olisi's NY Pizza

$ • Pizza

2352 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda
(716) 837-6767


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Olisi's NY Pizza

The best thin crust NY style in the Amherst area. They're more expensive than the rest, so if I'm ordering anything other than a thin NY style with one or two toppings, I go elsewhere. The pricing is higher than the competition and if anywhere else made a decent NY style for less, I'd order there. I still ×ince when ordering.

Good spot for NY style thin pizza. Had a large order over the weekend and they grouped everything best they could to make some combo deals. Really nice of them to do. Only thing is the pizza adds up quick if you want a few toppings. They also send coupons out in mailers around the area. So you usually have a coupon on hand. I've ordered subs and wings here before and they are delicious as well. Thin crust isn't always my jam, and it can be a little greasy but if you're in the...read full review
I didn't grow up here and I'll be honest... I can't stand Buffalo style pizza. I don't mean to offend anyone - I just don't get it! That's said, I'm always on the lookout for local places that have a good thin-crust with non-cup and char pepperoni. And Olisi's has it!!!!!!! I was thrilled by the first look at it, and even more thrilled upon biting in! Finally - a pizza in WNY that you need to fold!!! The sauce wasn't overly savory and the amount on the pizza was absolutely perfect....read full review

More Reviews(132)


Monday 10AM - 10PM
Tuesday 10AM - 10PM
Wednesday 10AM - 10PM
Thursday 10AM - 10PM
Friday 10AM - 11PM
Saturday 10AM - 11PM
Sunday 10AM - 10PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.