50 Best Ice Cream Shops near Tuckahoe

“The salted caramel yogurt is amazing! and the owner Chris is a stand up guy! I especially love the outdoor play area for kids that way they can be entertained while you enjoy your delicious yogurt ��“

“Obviously ice cream is ice cream but the guy is genuinly amazing. He works super fast and is completely generous with what he gives to you, he is a very hardworking person because every time I walk past this place all I see is him doing is cleaning or taking peoples orderes while the other guy sits there doing nothing.“

“Delicious Italian ice and very friendly young men behind the counter. Great to have Rita’s back in the area!“

“I’m honestly obsessed with these cookies. They are incredibly delicious and so appetizing. What I love the most is that I’m usually not into sweets at all, but these are just perfect.

They’re not overly sweet — just the right balance. The almond flavor is so rich and comforting, and the cherry adds this slight sour touch that makes everything come together beautifully. It’s such an amazing combination.

I genuinely fell in love with these cookies from the first bite. Absolutely incredible. Thank you for creating something this good — truly impressive!“

“Brown butter cookie dough is a must.“

“The gelato, service, and atmosphere are excellent.“

“Food was delicious!! highly recommend!!“

“me and my wife have been to lost borough a handful of times now and we have relatively the same order everytime that we just can’t really go wrong with. i love how the dominican vanilla taste like actual vanilla extract it gives it that homemade vibe, the bustello coffee taste exactly like coffee for my coffee lovers out their, and they even have a tres leches henesy flavor and a coquito flavor for those who wanna sweat rummy twist & my wife loves to get their cookies EVERYTIMES“

“Friendly clean atmosphere. A great place to take our grandkids too“

“I recently ordered (and ENJOYED) a custom ice cream cake for my wife's birthday, and I can say with great certainty, that was one of the best desserts I have ever eaten. Absolutely fresh and fantastic...thank you! 🥳🎂🎉“

“The froyo here is so distinct. It legit taste like frozen yogurt. This isn't like your typical froyo location that's high in sugar and filled with fillers. Something about this is oddly refreshing and invigorating. You definitely get the feeling of consuming yogurt here. Also, all froyo is made fresh to order by machines in the front. They have plenty of options for topping and the staff are friendly. They gave me plenty of toppings for my dollar. Money well spent, highly recommend.“

“Crepe House is one of my favorite places to eat. The food is always fresh, delicious, and made with great quality ingredients. The crepes are amazing, and the service is always friendly and welcoming.

A special shoutout to Omar, who always provides excellent customer service and makes every visit a great experience.“

“Very nice cookies that taste splendid! However the staff could be a little more enthusiastic (referring to the ones that have worked there for a while, I get it can be tiring to put on a smiley face for each customer that walks in, but you are getting paid to do it and it makes their experience 10x better!). So, there are many new employees who are very welcoming and kind!“

“Got the lemon pepper wings and fries and it did not disappoint! Wings were crispy juicy and the lemon pepper was a rub, not a sauce. It was seasoned just right, not too much, not too little. Fries were golden and hit the spot too. The service was quick, everything hot and fresh. Definitely coming back!“

“I absolutely love the cookies from this shop 😍
My favorite will always be one of the classics: the brownie cookie 🤤
The service is also excellent; the staff is very friendly, attentive, and welcoming.“

“This 16 Handles location is always a great experience! The store is spotless, and the friendly staff create such a warm, welcoming environment-especially with kids. I really appreciate how clearly everything is labeled, from which toppings are kosher to what allergens are present, making it easy to eat here with confidence. Highly recommend!“

“We happened by last Friday and I asked for a recommendation. I tried the cookies and caramel and it was the best ice cream I've had in a long time! I have thought about it multiple times since returning home from our trip! It's so good!☺️👏“

“Taste just like it use to ( as it should ) Never disappointed.. I always know what I’m getting myself into.. so consistent !!! 👍 👌 🙏“

“The ice-creams are delicious. They have many egg-free/vegan options as well. And the staff members are very friendly. My son dropped his ice-cream on the floor, but they refused to charge us even after us insisting.“

“Best ice cream I ever had, my freezer is loaded, and I never eat ice cream before, it is better than gelato, try the coffee one, and others. Amazing. Love this LONGFORD ice cream. Z. G.“

“The cookie butter bomb is so good! I enjoyed it so much I’d definitely recommend this ice cream place! Very tasty!“

“Deliciosos la variedad de tacos que tienes... !!! me encantaron!!!“

“I always purchased churros for my brother from here and I had to try the milkshakes! I've had 2 this week and they were delicious!! (S'mores and Brownie Milkshake) There's so many flavor combos to choose from. The young lady who works there is always friendly and the place is spotless. She's a master at that milkshake machine. I blinked and it was ready. Definitely a hidden gem here in Larchmont. My co workers at Larchmont Public Library are definitely going to give this place a try after being super jealous of me walking in w my mixed enerJy shake. ????

Kid-friendliness: It's a safe environment for kids to hangout and grab a milkshake or Boba tea. Always clean with tables and chairs inside or outside (summer always)“

“The ice cream is really good especially the ice cream nachos!!!“

“The new ressee ice cream thing (forgot the name) it’s like a sundae/blizzard combo sorta, you eat with spoon… it’s shown as brown ice cream (not vanilla) which it is, just vanilla soft serve with peanut butter syrup.. I thought that it was peanut butter ice cream (which would have been better) it was still pretty good though but pretty expensive for a small cup of averaged ice cream.. $8 an some change ?‍♀️?‍♀️“

“Really good rolled ice cream. It's really creamy and delicious. Many flavors to choose from. The staff are very nice and helpful. It didn't take too long, I would say, maybe ten minutes. I loved it and have gotten it a few times and will be getting it again.“

“we first visited on liberal peachwave location as of 2013 and finally visited on 2019 until it closes.“

“Absolutely delicious! The flavors I chose today on a waffle cone: Pistachio & Piña Colada. The shop also has a small & nice sitting area in the front, with 2 swing benches, umbrellas, 1 iron bistro table & chairs.“

“Absolutely loved Iscream! The milkshake was rich, creamy, and made with high-quality ingredients—you can taste the difference right away. Perfect texture, great flavor selection, and not overly sweet. The staff was friendly and welcoming, and the shop had a fun vibe. Everything felt fresh and made with care. Easily one of the best spots for dessert in the Bronx. I’ll definitely be coming back to try more flavors!“

“First time there today at the Nyack store, chose my personal favorite black raspberry and it was awesome! I am kind of a connoisseur of this flavor, and this was super delicious! Staff was also very friendly and the store nice and clean.“

“Great variety, excellent service. Half cannoli/half lily with nuts - DELICIOUS!“

“Best carvel ice cream shop 🍦 in the area. I was just there today. I have been going there since I was a kid. Ice cream is always good and fresh and they offer a big selection. The staff is always so nice and helpful too.“

“The best around by far! Lots of flavors, but the simple swirl always hits the spot.“

“I've always loved Carvel. This location everybody is pretty cool. Always great times when I go there. My only problem with Carvel is that they STILL DON'T HAVE rewards points. Everybody wants rewards points, COME ON ALREADY CARVEL!! WE WANT REWARDS!!“

“I've been seeing the really good food posted on Social Media and finally made the 5 minute trek. I have to say the calzones and pizza were excellent! The calzones are enormous. Where looking forward to trying something different next time, and next time will be soon! ��“

“This place I just saw on the Map with 5 Stars so I went to see for my self, they have freezes full of different types of ready to go Ice cream, Cones, cups and sandwiches. But I asked for a banana split which it was delicious. They can scoop different flavors or they have the soft ice-cream machine as well. The Lady was very friendly and nice. She looked like she enjoyed decorating the desert. I will go back again and they deserve 10 Stars.“

“The service is exceptional - when choosing ice cream cakes, always willing to provide advice and take the time to personalize and make each one special. The ice cream cakes are freshly made here and by far the best. Ice cream and shakes are also great at this location. Finally, the equipment is well maintained and sanitary. Carvel does one thing - ice cream - and at Webster Ave it is done right!“

“The cookie butter bomb is so good! I enjoyed it so much I’d definitely recommend this ice cream place! Very tasty!“

“we LOVE this place!! the frozen yougart is delicious and not sour, Toppings can't be beat and the atmosphere is very child friendly.“

“Great, took little cousins and it was fun as well as delicious. Pricey but good“

“Ice Cream Deliciousness!!!!“

“Matcha Cafe Maiko is a cozy cafe in Fort Lee that’s all about matcha and Japanese-style desserts, part of a broader chain known for its matcha treats and soft-serve desserts.

The shop’s vibe is laid-back and inviting, making it a nice stop for a quick refreshing drink or sweet treat. Service was quick and efficient, even when it got a little busy, and the staff were friendly throughout our visit.

We tried their matcha drink, which was refreshing and had a decent matcha flavor, but wasn't as strong as we expected. The sweets here pair really well with the matcha, leaning toward a balance of creaminess and earthiness without being overly sweet.

Overall, Matcha Cafe Maiko is a solid choice if you’re craving something matcha-centric.“

“First time there today at the Nyack store, chose my personal favorite black raspberry and it was awesome! I am kind of a connoisseur of this flavor, and this was super delicious! Staff was also very friendly and the store nice and clean.“

“Held 2 birthday parties at home with Smallcakes. Each party was a hit. Tina, Lexi & Regina arrived on time with everyhing-- even folding tables, chairs + balloons. The kids colored their own frosting, used a piping bag and decorated with tons of toppings.
When the 6 year olds needed a break, their team cleaned up and turned everything over for lunch, they even included a custom birthday cake. Such a fun party, the adults enjoyed spending time with their kids while Smallcakes did all the work. 10/10!“

“A wide variety of Ice cream especially the Caribbean flavors“

“amazing place. Want to tae my friends here! awesome!!!!!“

“Food is usually solid. Service is slow at times, but the weirdest part is that a milkshake is not added in the combos. Even if you wanted to up-charge , it seems stupid not to have that as an option, it is literallt the staple of American food to have a burger and shake, and the store is literally called Burger AND shske... You would get more clientele if you didn't up-charge for what many think is kinda ridiculous. Just semantics that you wouldn't try to upgrade combos if asked. And why is the Veggie burger not served with the Zucchini fries? Regular fries defeats the purpose of it being the healthy vegan option. Honestly, the business just needs to rethink their menus. That's why the place is empty most times. You could get something way more affordable that is still supporting a small business elsewhere.“

“I always enjoy seeing Anna in the morning to grab some delicious cappuccino and cornetti 🥐 great place“

“Both their breakfast and lunch sandwiches are incredible. Classic tri-state deli staples and Latin inspired dishes, and they all hit. Also incredibly well priced which is hard to find today. Best of all, the staff are some of the friendliest, kindest people you’ll ever meet. Can’t recommend enough.“