15 Best Ice Cream Shops in Yonkers

“Lost Borough Ice Cream is a small, eclectic shop with a fun atmosphere, offering a variety of unique flavors made in-house. Flavors like Sakura, key lime pie, and Dominican Vanilla + Coconut are fan favorites, with some rotating seasonally. The shop is clean, with friendly staff, and has a great river walk location with benches nearby. While prices may be a bit steep, the delicious ice cream and charming ambiance make it a worthwhile visit. Be sure to try their staple flavors like Yonkers Blackout, and keep an eye out for special treats like banana bread pudding.“

“Carvel is a spacious restaurant known for its wide selection of cakes. It offers a deal on 'Cartwheel' sandwiches, buy 1 pack of 6 and get the 2nd at half off from Mondays through Thursdays. The service is commendable, with staff providing kind attention to customers even during busy periods, such as on Mother's Day. The restaurant is consistently clean, and while orders are usually accurate, there have been isolated instances of mix-ups, such as serving vanilla soft serve instead of strawberry. To avoid this, customers are advised to check their orders before leaving the store.“

“Paleteria La Michoacana is a beloved ice cream shop with a long-standing history in the community. The large selection of unique and diverse flavors, including Mamey, Guanabana, and Chamoy, makes it stand out. With two locations in Yorkers and Mount Vernon, customers praise the great ice cream and customer service. A favorite childhood spot for many, the variety of flavors ensures there is something for everyone. While some customers have nostalgic memories of the place, others appreciate the consistency and quality of the ice cream. Overall, Paleteria La Michoacana is highly recommended for those looking for a delicious and refreshing treat.“

“La Imperial Mexican Ice's is a friendly establishment offering handmade ice cream, shakes, and Mexican treats like paletas, nieves, and chicharrones preparados. Their ice cream is made from real fruit and can be enjoyed in their outdoor seating area. A variety of options and fresh ingredients make this a recommended visit.“

“Brought my kids to there first carvel. They loved it. I grew up on it.“

“Le Macaron French Pastries offers a delightful experience with outstanding employees and great products. In addition to a variety of macarons, they also have gourmet chocolates like bon-bons that are beautifully crafted and delicious. The Paris-themed decor provides a charming ambiance to enjoy coffee and sweets. Despite slightly higher prices, the creativity and flavor variety make it worth a visit.“

“Ralph's Famous Italian Ices offers a wide variety of flavors, including sugar-free options, and serves sundaes and shakes. The friendly staff, often teenagers, work efficiently in the summertime rush. Customers can enjoy their treats at picnic tables outside the strip mall location. Popular flavors include pistachio creme and cotton candy, although some visitors have reported occasional mix-ups with their orders.“

“The staff is very friendly, polite, and helpful. They’ve handmade several custom cakes for me and every one was equally as beautiful as it was delicious! 10/10 recommend :)“

“Uncle Louie G's is a beloved establishment that transports customers back to their childhood with its great flavors. While it's cash-only, the friendly and helpful service makes up for it. The staff is knowledgeable and happy to offer suggestions on what to try. With both indoor and outdoor seating, the ambiance is cozy and inviting. Despite some occasional service lapses, the overall experience is consistently positive, with many customers returning frequently.“

“Shake Shack Cross County offers a delightful dining experience with their wow-worthy burgers and delectable vanilla shakes. The attentive staff, led by a patient and diligent server, ensures a valuable experience. However, the restaurant's seating options may detract from the overall enjoyment, with some customers finding the chairs uncomfortably uncomfortable.“

“Carvel offers friendly service and a unique welcome experience. Their soft serve ice cream is reliably great and fairly priced, with a large variety of types to choose from. The store also offers packaged items to take home. While some customers have had issues with specific orders, the staff is generally polite and efficient. Note that seating is limited and parking can be a challenge.“

“CookiesNcream offers a delicious variety of cookies, with flavors like cookies and cream, nutella, brownie, peanut butter, and chocolate chip. Customers praise the vanilla ice cream with caramel drizzle and enjoy warming up the cookies. The Sugar Cookie stands out as a favorite, with perfect texture and just the right amount of sweetness.“