“Fell in love with their setup. Old school carvel vibes. Ice cream tasted like my childhood. Very clean. The employees were very friendly and had no problem letting my young son use their personal restroom. We'll definitely visit again soon.“
“Such a pleasure to welcome a sweet new friend to the neighborhood! Already visited multiple times and have thoroughly enjoyed a variety of custom homemade flavors. The best of what a suburban neighborhood can offer…friendly and welcoming staff with tasty and memorable treats!“
“Lovely servers but a BIG problem. Clientele are usin these people for free samples and buying Nothing! They take the sample cups and keep going back and forth with their tiny USED sample cup going from each flavor to the next. The owner should stop samples or have the servers offer it.Yogurt was excellent. Stop the samples!“
“Today's review (10/15/23) is mostly about the service here. Dude running the place by himself had quite a lot of plates to juggle; baking cookies, making milkshakes, ringing up customers etc. My advice if you're looking to explore Mamaroneck: park on one of the side streets by the library - don't bother with Mamaroneck Ave.Milk 'n Cookies also always smells so good! You can either smell the soap they just washed the floors with, or the cookies being baked - nice touch. Prices here are a little extreme. Around $5 per cookie, and $11 for a milkshake. Not bad!“
“Great food. The Plain Tart yogurt is second to none. You can't find that kind of quality tart yogurt anywhere else. I literally came from work in the Bronx straight to Mamaroneck to pick up a Quart of the Plain Tart. They make it in-house, and its consistently a top quality product. I would highly recommend Esy Kafe.“