49 Best Ice Cream Shops near Valley Cottage

“Just picked up our ice cream 🍦 we love it. it is so amazing and delicious“

“Stopped by today… exceptional service today. When I go to places it’s obviously for the food/dessert, but when the customer service is AWESOME, It makes my experience 10x better, & that’s exactly what it was !!“

“I was there for the first time a few weeks ago. Was so impressed! The vanilla soft serve actually had flavor. Most places I make them put a ton of toppings on just so it has some flavor. Also, the medium was so large my two nieces that normally want larges could barely finish it. So you definitely get your moneys worth. My only question is I want to bring a friend who’s allergic to eggs. I called the shop and they said they didn’t know if there was eggs in the ice cream (If it wasn’t for my friend, I would never know that many places like Carvel does use eggs to make it more creamier). So do you use eggs in your soft serve?“

“We are up from North Carolina this week and last night we were visiting our relatives who live in the Harbors. They took us to Riverside Scoops which was such a treat…Really great ice cream, lovely setting and wonderful customer service. My grandchildren loved their cones, my husband totally enjoyed his large cup with cinnamon bun and vanilla (which he couldn’t stop raving about) and I had the Smore Sundae…absolutely delicious!!! If you’re looking for a great place for ice cream on a summer evening, take a ride over to the Harbors and stop in at Riverside Scoops! You won’t be sorry 😊“

“How could you NOT recommend The Blue Pig? 10/5 stars“

“I recently ordered (and ENJOYED) a custom ice cream cake for my wife's birthday, and I can say with great certainty, that was one of the best desserts I have ever eaten. Absolutely fresh and fantastic...thank you! 🥳🎂🎉“

“Taste just like it use to ( as it should ) Never disappointed.. I always know what I’m getting myself into.. so consistent !!! 👍 👌 🙏“

“Never been before today but so happy we stopped by! Kids were thrilled with the flavor choices and I really liked there was a vegan option! We’ll definitely be stopping in again. 😃“

“They have the best lemon ice cream 🍦🍦“

“Really good, quality desserts. We got the creme brulee and citron tarte. The creme brulee tasted like creamy marshmallow. The tarte had a creamy, fresh taste. However, I wasn't a fan of the crust. Everything tasted very fresh. The staff was patient and helpful.“

“The cookie butter bomb is so good! I enjoyed it so much I’d definitely recommend this ice cream place! Very tasty!“

“Deliciosos la variedad de tacos que tienes... !!! me encantaron!!!“

“After bike ride meal. Place is packed with bikers on good weather weekends though many just getting Powerade.“

“First time there today at the Nyack store, chose my personal favorite black raspberry and it was awesome! I am kind of a connoisseur of this flavor, and this was super delicious! Staff was also very friendly and the store nice and clean.“

“Hi 👋 This is the best Italian Ice you will find anywhere, and the NICEST family owned! XOX“

“The flavors were excellent—especially the mango, which was fresh and vibrant. Each option we tried was delicious. The owner was incredibly friendly and welcoming, especially to our big group, which made the experience even better. Highly recommend!“

“The best around by far! Lots of flavors, but the simple swirl always hits the spot.“

“We used to walk there from the house over 50 years ago. Pick up a dozen Dilly Bars (I think they call them Buster bars now). I always knew the staff because we grew up together. So much more than memories !“

“First time there today at the Nyack store, chose my personal favorite black raspberry and it was awesome! I am kind of a connoisseur of this flavor, and this was super delicious! Staff was also very friendly and the store nice and clean.“

“the owner is always there. the place is spotless and it is the best tasting carvel around!“

“The best. I love the ice cream and the location is one of the most beautiful spots in Westchester.“

“Glacé 👍🏽 Milkshakes 😋 Hot Fudge Sundaes 🤗“

“A community fixture in Pearl River. I always try and make up some sort of excuse to get their frozen custard vanilla.

One cannot consider themselves a complete human being until they get soft serve (or a variant thereof) from King Kone.“

“Stopped by Milk & Cookies and had an awesome experience! Michael was incredibly patient while I tried to decide what to order and made some excellent recommendations that did not disappoint. His friendly attitude and great customer service made the visit even better.

The cookies were fresh, the ice cream was delicious, and everything tasted amazing. If you're looking for a great dessert spot with outstanding service, I highly recommend checking them out. I'll definitely be back the next time I'm in town!“

“Great neighborhood deli with fair prices and good food. Dianet and Sandro nail the classic breakfast sandwiches, and their house-made lemonade and iced teas are excellent. It's a nice, locally owned shop that gets the job done right. The bathrooms are also always sanitary and clean, which speaks volumes about how the entire place is operated. 5-stars all around. 👌“

“Wish you could order food from grub hub or DoorDash“

“They were SO nice in here. And I’m so happy we stopped in. The flavors are off the charts good and everything was fresh. It was late when we walked in and she still served us. I’ve been meaning to come check this place out. Definitely coming back here.“

“Great service!! Exceptional taste. Immaculate store.“

“Held 2 birthday parties at home with Smallcakes. Each party was a hit. Tina, Lexi & Regina arrived on time with everyhing-- even folding tables, chairs + balloons. The kids colored their own frosting, used a piping bag and decorated with tons of toppings.
When the 6 year olds needed a break, their team cleaned up and turned everything over for lunch, they even included a custom birthday cake. Such a fun party, the adults enjoyed spending time with their kids while Smallcakes did all the work. 10/10!“

“Ice cream was very delicious and I plan to visit again“

“Rita’s on the 59 is delicious and the inside is very clean. The staff was very friendly and works quickly. They do have the option for cholov yisroel ice cream in addition to the standard frozen custard. Id highly recommend giving this place a try. I’ll definitely be coming back“

“Baskin‑Robbins was a delight to visit. The ice cream was rich, fresh, and full of flavor, and the staff was friendly and quick to help. The shop felt clean and welcoming, making it easy to enjoy the treat. A great stop for anyone craving something sweet.“

“I had to come here and write a review because of how happy I am with their services. This Baskin Robbin’s made me a custom cake for my bridal shower, and it couldn’t have looked or tasted better!! Everyone was raving about it! 10/10 would absolutely recommend. The first picture is the inspiration and the second is what they made me.“

“Try their smoothies for the first time today. So yummy!! nice consistency and good flavor. Very fast service too“

“Try the sweet potato fries. The large can feed 3“

“I went there several times & the ice cream waffle cones r amazing. I’ve bought at least 8-10 friends who also love Bruster’s & have brought their friends. Great new addition to Westwood.“

“My family and I enjoy coming to this frozen yogurt spot. There’s a good variety of flavors and toppings to choose from. The space is roomy, although it could use some improvement in terms of décor and overall upkeep.

The service is pretty basic—most of the time it’s students working there, and they mainly just handle the checkout without much interaction.

On my last visit, I added walnuts like I usually do, but they didn’t taste fresh this time.

Prices are on the higher side“

“Good service. Friendly staff. Carvel is an Amercian Icon. Cooled me down from overheating.“

“Great Shake Shack! I stopped here for dinner not too long ago, and I have no complaints. Plenty of parking out front, and tons of seating inside. The kiosk ordering was quick and efficient, and the food came our very quick. Not to mention, the employees were spectacular! One of the workers was even coming around to every table offering sauce packets and napkins. I tried the big shack, which was delicious, and my shake and fries were also amazing. The inside is clean and modern, with a bunch of seating, as I mentioned before. There is also outdoor seating. The thing I love about all Shake Shacks is that they always have a free water dispenser and cups. This is super convenient so that you don't have to pay extra for a drink. A great place to stop for a quick and delicious meal.“

“This place shares it's space with Dunkin Donuts.Not much variety in favors but they do change it up when they add new flavors.Tried their totally wrapped milkshake and it was delicious.Friendly and speed service despite their being a queue which is not that often.“

“love this place!“

“This is absolutely the best Carvel. Dana & Sal are awesome proprietors.“

“Delicious 😋 varieties of different icee flavors“

“This Carvel has single handily changed my view on life. You may be thinking ice cream is a simple pleasure many indulge in meaninglessly. This is NOT true for me, every bite is an experience in its own, every moment one to be cherised. On a particular dark, gloomy night I defeatedly walked into Carvel, my head hung low in shame. Was I, the biggest icecream enthusiastic in the world really about to settle for Carvel? I walked up to the counter and my pessimistic attitude was flipped upside down, and so was my world. The beaming worker smiled at me and his smile flashed such a warm radiance I was worried all the Icecream would melt! He was kind when serving me and the icecream made my gloom into joy. I looked at the recipt and saw the workers name was Dean. My experience on this night was an insightful one in which I learned never to judge a book by its cover, and hope can be found in the most unexpected places. 5 stars would recommend!!!“

“delicius burger even better than burger King and McDonald's!!!🤤🙏🏿 #TrumpWon“

“This place is amazing and the best Mexican spot to eat around this area. The tacos are so fresh and yummy as well as the chips and guac everything is so fresh and definitely gave me a great experience . Brian was amazing and super helpful will definitely be back not just for the food but for the experience“

“This ice cream shop is one of my favorites. I love their unique flavor combinations.

This time, we chose the Strawberry Blonde, which comes with graham cracker pie crust, strawberries, caramel, and whipped topping. We ordered a medium size, and it was perfect for sharing with my husband.
We got it in a cup, but they also offer cone options.

The staff was very friendly and efficient when taking our order.“

“I usually love this place my go to for ice cream , tonight is first night not happy 2 orders wrong and when I pay 8 for ice cream and ask for peanut butter and hot fudge well put a decent amount on , well will see next time . Still my go to as of now“