10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Wantagh

“Excellent restaurant! Food was delicious, compliments to the chef. Our server Carlos was great! Joe the owner was attentive and accommodating! Would highly recommend!“

“First time going to this place. The owners were nice enough to let my son and the Blood Cancer United charity to not only put a table inside to gently solicit donations but they gave a percentage of sales. We decided to grab a table and WOW. The pizza, apps were amazing. Our server Sam had the absolute best personality and it was a great dining experience. Can’t wait to go back“

“To whoever loves pizza like I do. I've eaten at over 789 different pizza places so I know my pizza. Todqy this is 799.This place is most excellent. They have a great selection of food. I had a regular slice and a Sicilian slice. Both were delicious. The sauce tasted excellent. The Sicilian slice was beefy and the regular slice just the right size. Definitely will fill you up and reasonably priced. Next time I will have a dinner because I'll definitely be back for a next time. The establishment is clean and has a great vibe to it. Music was cool. Aerosmith was playing. The employees were friendly, welcoming and make you feel good to be here to have food. All in all I give the place two thumbs up. Thank you for the great pizza and keep up the fantastic job you all do here. Mike McKenna“

“I love Anthony’s food especially the chopped salad and the Desserts 🧁“

“We got catering for our office party today. They were amazing! It was so easy to order, very friendly staff. They were prompt the day of delivery and food is amazingly delicious! Everyone loved it!“

“Great food & amazing customer service!“

“Highly recommend! Elizabeth was quick to respond to my inquiry and called to answer all of my questions. They catered my grandsons 1st birthday party. Pizzas were all amazing. Large variety served with a salad. We also had the gelato which everyone loved also. They made extra pies for us and gave us gelato to keep also.“

“We went to Prince Umberto Pizzeria Restaurant in \nWantagh, Long Island NY for the first time. \nThe staff (Eddie) was welcoming and efficient. \nThe thin crust, New York style pizza was delicious, \nas was their hearty lasagna and mouth watering \neggplant rollatini. \nThe menu here has something to please everyone. \nWe're look forward to returning for more. Enjoy! \nErnest NY“

“Online ordering was a little difficult. Very friendly cashier during take out. Felt like my business was very appreciated. Will definitely return to this location.“

“Fun atmosphere. Cozy. Reasonably priced.“