33 Best American Restaurants near Weedsport

“Burgers were really good. The service was great as well. Will be back soon !!“

“You cannot beat Arnolds Resturant. The foodis the best and your treated like family.“

“I’m not from the area, was up here with my family when my wife’s Papa passed. We called them last minute to see if there was anything they could do to help us feed our family of 15 people for take out. They took care of us promptly. They made a grieving family’s night. Thank you Cynthia and Cory. This was more than we could have ever asked.

Ps... the food was absolutely delicious“

“the girls working tonight were awesome! so often it's not the case in today's society but they went above and beyond!!!! they are keepers!“

“Large portions. Kids that were working seemed very confused about money in the register and were arguing with each other about taking money from the cash register and changing it out with the bag money for change, and how busy it was. Which seemed a little crazy to do in front of people. I actually worked at this location many years ago and couldn't fathom not having a smile on my face and handling business as business. But hospitality has certainly dropped.

After that long rant, the ice cream was good and portions were good.“

“I’m getting emotional just writing this, but Springside Inn truly made our wedding dreams come true. The facility itself is STUNNING and so versatile!!! We decided to have our ceremony in The Grove (beautiful outdoor area surrounded by trees) and our reception in the ballroom, but there are so many options and different ways to use the venue that no 2 weddings are alike. The rooms we got to stay in too are also absolutely gorgeous. Antique charm but state of the art amenities. I am not exaggerating when I say the food and cake were some of the best things I’ve ever eaten in my 29 years of existence. So customizable and delicious! The chef and catering staff are so nice and talented. And last by certainly NOT least…the site coordinator, Chris, is an absolute angel. As soon as we booked the venue, she guided us EVERY step of the way with planning. She is an absolute expert on all things wedding planning and ensured the day went so smoothly. She is such a calm presence and was so attentive, helpful, reassuring, and just overall one of the nicest human beings I’ve ever met!!! I feel like I will never be able to express my gratitude for her enough. Springside Inn is an absolute dream in every shape or form and I could not recommend them enough Love, Jacqui and James Married 9/28/24“

“Timeless , family oriented .. 🤍“

“We had a great lunch there with my siblings. They were so accommodating for our group. Thank you so much!“

“We go often for wing night and it never disappoints. I’m not sure of who our waitress was tonight but she was handling the front like a pro. Always a good experience when we dine here.“

“The Krebs was a great place for Easter brunch. Lots of choices on the menu. Wait staff was professional and very attentive. Despite the fact that it was busy, our meal arrived in a good amount of time. It's a beautiful restaurant and very pleasurable experience.“

“Enjoyed our lunch at the Refinery. Good lunch menu, good prices and friendly service!“

“Underrated!! Super happy with our dinner choice tonight! Fried haddock dinner was spot on! Hands down my new favorite in town!“

“Timeless , family oriented .. 🤍“

“Had our first experience after discovery this hidden gem... one word says it all....AMAZING!!!!“

“We had our informal wedding reception at Prison City North Street location in the barrel room. We dropped off our decor the day prior and they set everything up perfectly. We chose the taco bar for dinner and late night pretzels as our food options and everything was delicious. They set up a smaller bar for us in the brew space which worked out great. Amy the event coordinator was great to work with. We would recommend Prison City North Street location for any event!“

“We recently had 2 baby showers at The Reef. I can't say enough about how great they both were. The food was great, the room upstairs was perfect! Thanks so much to Bobbie for your help, we appreciate coming early to decorate and your great communication about all the details. We highly recommend!!“

“We finally got to Lavish Lounge and it did not disappoint! The decor is vibrant - unlike anything it the area. The dish on the left was the smothered chicken and on the right was bourbon chicken. The food was great! Be sure to say hello to Andrew and Marsha“

“We went for Valentine's Day, I had a Bacon cheddar crispy chicken sandwich. Apparently it had a tangy bacon sauce on it but it was hot. I can handle some hotness. But that was not tangy...it was HOT. However, they did let me replace it with something else.“

“I had the pleasure of dining at Pavlos’ last week for my birthday. I was treated to breakfast by a coworker. The meal was second to none. I really enjoy the way In which my food was cooked, presented, and consistently checked on by my server. I’d recommend paying a visit to Pavlos’ to anyone who enjoys a good meal at a decent price. The fact that It’s a cash only business, Is worth the visit to the ATM. To the staff at Pavlos’…great job! ?“

“Best wings I’ve ever had, anywhere on Earth.“

“They can quote my breakfast order when I walk in, and my coffee is heading to the table by the time I sit down. The service is awesome, and friendly, the food is great, and it's fun to watch them cook at the open grill.“

“Best place for music! Great atmosphere and people.“

“bummed to get a BLT with no "T"... called to bring it to their attention and the person on the phone said, "oh... are you sure you didn't say "no tomato"?" Yep, I was sure... even told her my order number so she could see. Her response? "Oh, ok"... no apology, no offer to fix it -- just ok not the end of the world, obviously... but such a bummer“

“First time eating there tonight. Definitely will not be the last. I could not find one thing negative to say about the meal or the staff. The tomato oil they serve with the bread is heavenly. And it only got better from there!!!“

“Our absolute favorite place for dinner, for a million years!???. Love everything on the menu, love all the people who work there and make it work, Bernie’s creativity in the kitchen, the atmosphere, the friendly folks who frequent the bar…….. what else do you want to know?“

“Stopped today to enjoy an outdoor meal on a nice day. Was not sure what to expect food-wise. Pleasantly surprised ! The burgers are fabulous, the "pudder" burger was made to order,cooked to perfection, and the toppings were extremely fresh. While my wife had ice cream for dessert, I had another pudder burger ! My new fav place for a burgers“

“Heard this place has lots of cool stuff on the walls. Wow does it. A life size king tut, giant gorilla, Funhouse mirrors, and to top it off it even has a used electric chair. Grab a drink and walk around so much to see. The bartender was great. Similar to the Spirit Room in Rochester but different.“

“Recently had the Korean BBQ tacos. They were very good. Fries were also spot on. Also went through an order of fried pickles very quickly. Osso Buco is also excellent, as is the Cuban sandwich.

Great service. Great atmosphere. Still a great place to eat.“

“Wings are great and the beer is cold! 🍗🍻“

“Update: As I said we went back and the place was packed! We chose to sit in the bar area at the big half circle table. The service was excellent despite the long and understandable wait based on how many people were there.

The poor waitress seemed to be doing the bar half all alone, but she killed it! Wish I could mention her by name.

We'll be going back and I'll keep my eye open for an improvement in the salt shaker situation so I can add that 5th star. They are just too nasty looking for me to not hold my ground on the impact of the review.

First visit:
Pizza was awesome, Garlic knots were 4 star this time compared to the last time and my son devoured his side of meatballs without sauce. He said they were the best ever. Chicken tenders and fries were excellent and the barbecue sauce is a good one. Highly recommend this reopened version of Curley's, very much like old times.

The food was excellent. Pizza is top notch. Chicken tenders and fries were great. The Salmon was VERY good.

Warning: Chicken riggies were VERY, VERY spicy.

They don't have chocolate milk for kids which was actually nice because then the kids ate their food, but if you need that to be here, it's not.

On the atmosphere. We will 100% be going back. I LOVE the old Curley's feel and really am glads it is open again. However, the salt and pepper shakers are unacceptable and for that I took off a star. If they get new salt and pepper shakers I'll gladly up this to 5 star.“

“food was amazing Great place take the family and friends waitress was amazing thank you I will be coming back“

“We decided to drive 45 minutes to try something new, and Clover’s did not disappoint—it was well worth the trip! From the moment we walked through the door, the staff greeted us with joy and genuine warmth. Vickie, our waitress, was absolutely fantastic—attentive, friendly, and made us feel right at home. The atmosphere was welcoming, and the food? Phenomenal! By far, one of the best diners around. Even if the cook happens to be a Cowboys fan, we can forgive that because everything was spot-on. We’ll definitely be back!“

“amazing staff,great service and food“