7 Best American Restaurants in Baldwinsville

“I ate there while I visited my son for Thanksgiving. I had a hard time choosing because everything sounded so good. I ended up choosing the Cubby and boy was I happy that I did. It was amazing......no kidding! If I lived there It would be my go to favorite.“

“Great dinner on Thursday night with my wife. The food is aways excellant and the bar tender Shaun Preble always has excellent menu and drink suggestions.“

“Dined here last evening. The warm brie appetizer was very good and a nice change from ordinary appetizers. The steak was very tender and cooked to perfection. For dessert I had the chocolate torte which came with raspberry sauce. The combination of the chocolate and raspberry....yum! The staff were all nice, friendly, and informative. I'll definitely be back!“

“I had Pasta’s cater a luncheon for my son’s graduation from the police academy and the food was absolutely delicious…. The chicken parm was amazing. I will definitely order from them again! Thank you!“

“The food and service have always been excellent. The only misstep was removing the blackened chicken egg rolls from the menu. This was one of the best dishes in CNY. Hoping it returns soon.“

“We celebrated my husband’s birthday there last night, and knowing it would be bumping, we called and made a reservation. When my son’s game at a local indoor center ran over by almost 30 minutes, I called and told them we would be late. They accommodated us and seated us immediately upon arrival. About 10 minutes later, at 8pm, the live music started. It was wonderful music, but where we were seated was in front of the speakers and two of our party wear hearing aides. When it looked like we were going to have to cut our celebration short, our server, the wonderful Marcy, and another gentleman, worked to get us seating in the lower dining room in front. We were so grateful for the accommodations, and everyone was super nice about it. The food and drinks were outstanding, of course. The service was impeccable, and our night, which could have gone south so quickly, was made! And hopefully a younger, hipper crew moved into our table and enjoyed the wonderful music! The band was great and we really enjoyed it still from where we ended up! So cheers to the staff at AG! We will be back (and know where to ask to sit next time! Haha)!!“

“🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 5-Star Experience! A massive thank you to Average Joe's Beernasium for making our surprise Bachelorette Party truly unforgettable! From the moment we arrived, the atmosphere was electric. Food: Absolutely delicious and budget-friendly! Every bite was a delight. Drinks: Crafted to perfection—each one better than the last. Live Band: Phenomenal performance that had us dancing non-stop for three hours! It felt like we were reliving our college days. We genuinely didn't want the night to end. The combination of great food, fantastic music, and an incredible atmosphere made it a night to remember. We'll definitely be returning—for the vibes, the tunes, and especially the food. Already planning our next pizza night with takeout from here!“