10 Best Bakeries near Weedsport

“We're out of towners who stopped randomly bc the shop looked beautiful. Best stop of the trip! Owners were lovely and navigated the Halloween rush beautifully. Grabbed some beans and hot honey for home and they were fabulous as well!“

“we found this place by chance yesterday and we will be back there again.. the food was good the service was excellent and the conversation with the owners.. was even better.. then I was watching the news 8 hrs later and I see Brandon Roth from cw6 was there it was Brandon best bet for great food... and we agree“

“I order a cake for my daughter in law's baby shower at Phoebe's. It was beautiful and absolutely delicious. All of my guests raved about how moist the cake was and how the frosting was amazing. Thank you so much 😊 I am extremely happy with the entire experience.“

“I emailed the cake decorator a picture for inspiration for My son’s first birthday cake off of Pinterest- while they don’t make any guarantees it will look like the picture they did an AMAZING JOB. I was so surprised and now we know where we’re going for every birthday cake for the next 20ish years.“

“Nice little quaint shop. Bought a raspberry pie and a peach pie. The raspberry was fantastic. The peach was not, it appears to not be fully cooked and seem to lack sugar. I was disappointed as the prior reviews raved about the peach pie. And peach pie although hard to find is my favorite. A“

“Stopped yesterday was very impressed with the bread, I’ll definitely be back.“

“Carolyn Creations is a great place for ordering cakes and cookies for any occasion. Her baked goods are always delicious and freshly made to order. I have ordered birthday cakes from her for many years and have never been disappointed. Her prices are so reasonable!!“

“great baked goods and other goodies for everyone.“

“Applewood bacon, egg and Cheese on ciabatta. Great coffee and the freshest donuts! Love the glazed!!“