Restaurants in West Islip

“Nice place! Great vibe. Clean. Perfect spot to meet up w some ol' friends for a few drinks.
Shout out & cheers to Mike (the owner) 🍻”

“Maybe the best bagel in the USA. I grew up on Long Island and this establishment is excellent 👌 I think Long Island really sucks all around when it comes to it's lack of culture and it's people (too many d bags) but if you ever wind up on this God forsaken Island do your self a favor and go to this eating establishment. 🙂🥯”

“The giant pretzel with the dipping sauces is amazing!! Yum very nice staff Fun place went to see Serve the Servants Great live music More parking would be 😃👍 great!!”

“I came here one summer afternoon not long after it rained. There was some sort of group activity inside so I grabbed a flight and sat by the picnic tables, enjoying the afternoon. There was some good food at the food truck as well. Overall I enjoyed the beer and vibes.”

“Great food, friendly atmosphere!!”

“So authentic and great service! The worry dolls were an added bonus as I was there with my daughter. Perfect birthday, love the philanthropy also! Guacamole was the best I’ve ever had.”

“only complaint was how busy it was and I can totally understand why. everything was amazing steaks and italian food alike. I'm super picky about my food and I was shocked how great everything was. I live an hour away and am already planning my next visit back. my new favorite restaurant. highly recommend”

“Had the best lunch today. Food was amazing but the server was even more amazing. Donna rocked it!!! I will be going back soon!”

“the BEST breakfast spot in West Islip!!! the Nutella Oreo waffles were delicious!!! Definitely recommend it 100%, 5 stars!!! They also have locations in Amityville, East Northport, Centereach and Sayville so if closer to the other locations, go there and give these guys a visit!”

“From start to finish our experience with Our little Italy was perfect. John was so great to work with for all our catering needs. The food was out of this world. So many comments on how amazing the meatballs were. Love using people from our home town. Thanks for everything!!!”

“great bar maids on Monday Tuesday Friday and Saturday”

“es un lugar muy agradable familiar los niños selapasan de lo mejor felises”

“Best heroes on Long Island”

“Bella Cucina has great grandma and drunken grandma pies. Their other pizzas are also good, as well as penne ala vodka and chicken parm. Nice friendly staff too!”

“Absolutely love their cheese steaks! Service was fast and with a smile....cheese throughout sandwich as it should be...ribeye steak grilled perfectly. Well done!”

“As always they went above and beyond making my moms vision come true! When asked what type of wedding cake do I want— 1,000,000% ICE CREAM! Thank you for your beautiful and special touches! ♥️”

“Pizza was absolutely amazing. The selection went from cheese, bbq chicken, Mac & Cheese, buffalo chicken and more. Service was fast and friendly. Indoor seating was nice and clean. Definitely recommend!!
Thank you La Slice”

“After moving to the area I was on the hunt for our new bagel place. After trying many places in the area we found Higbies which is now our go to. The bagels are the best around by far!”

“Cant say more about someplace else, very happy to have you all my friends!?”

“I love the this place … Great food … Great family deals … Friendly service with a smile … Cleanness on point … I would give 10 stars ⭐️to Benedetto’s pizza 🍕 … And in regards to comment below … Some people need to stop bringing their political views into a restaurant. I guess jealousy hits some people different. God bless America and God Bless Benedetto’s pizza !”

“Great people, good food. The chicken wings are amazing! Chicken cutlets too. Recommend stopping by and seeing Jay or Vinnie -- they rock.”

“We ordered custom cookies for my sisters Ralph Lauren themed baby shower! Nicole did an amazing job, the designs were absolutely beautiful and fit the theme perfectly, and the cookies were delicious. It’s rare to find cookies that are both stunning and genuinely tasty.

Communication was excellent from start to finish, making the entire process easy and stress-free. We couldn’t have been happier with the final product and received so many compliments from our guests.

I would highly recommend for any special event and will definitely be ordering again for our next celebration!”

“I'm not sure why they don't have more 5 star or 4+ star reviews?!!! Our food was delish.it was seasoned well the gauc was really tasty . The portions were very good I had a chicken quesadilla and a steak soft Taco my hubs had a burrito it was so big he couldn't finish it and he can EAT.”

“I appreciate you fitting me into your schedule so quickly after my basement lights broke. When your expert showed up on schedule, he promptly and easily resolved the problem. I value electricians who offer dependable after-hours assistance.”

“I’m writing this review because places like this genuinely deserve recognition, and I want more people to support a business that clearly cares about its customers.

For about a year now, I’ve been going to the West Islip library to study (I’m a student at Suffolk County Community College). I live in Deer Park, and the Deer Park library just doesn’t compare—it’s not a great environment. West Islip is quiet, comfortable, and actually lets me focus. On the way there, I’ve passed this deli countless times and never bothered going in.

A couple months ago, I noticed they had burgers on the sign, which made me think they probably had more variety than just typical deli sandwiches. Today, after class, I was craving a bacon, egg, and cheese and decided—on a whim at a red light—to finally stop in instead of going somewhere else.

Right away, I could tell this place was different. They had CALPICO and RAMUNE in multiple flavors, plus a variety of ramen and Asian snacks. That’s not something you usually see in a deli, and it immediately stood out to me.

But what really made this place unforgettable was the service.

It’s run by what seems like an older Korean couple, and they were some of the kindest, most welcoming people I’ve ever met in any food spot. Not the usual rushed, impatient “what do you want?” kind of interaction you sometimes get at delis. They greeted me warmly and made me feel completely comfortable—like I was being welcomed into someone’s home.

When I grabbed a room-temperature drink, they immediately told me they had cold ones, walked me over to the fridge, and helped me pick a flavor. They even took the warm one from my hand to put it back for me. It was such a simple moment, but it showed how much they genuinely care.

For context, I study culinary arts and I’m currently trying to get into the food industry, so I pay attention to service and how businesses are run. This is exactly how it should be done. You can tell they care about their customers and take pride in their business.

The food was great too. I got a bacon, egg, and cheese with hot sauce and ketchup, and the hot sauce was different from the usual—in a really good way. It wasn’t just thrown together; it felt like they actually cared about making it right.

I walked in feeling kind of down—it was just one of those Mondays—but I left in a completely different mood. Hours later, I’m still thinking about how kind they were.

I’m not even exaggerating when I say this—I would take a bullet for these people. That’s how genuinely good they were to me. If they were hiring, I would work for them in a heartbeat and stay there as long as the place exists. I truly want nothing but success for them.

The total came out to about $17, but that included two imported drinks, so it makes sense. And honestly, I don’t regret it at all. I’d gladly spend my money here again.

This is officially my new go-to spot every time I go to the library. I’d rather come here than go to Dunkin’, 7-Eleven, or anywhere else.

I love this place. I mean that seriously. Even if I’m not getting a full meal, I’d go out of my way just to grab a drink or a bag of chips to support them.

If you’re anywhere near West Islip, do yourself a favor and check this place out. Businesses like this deserve to succeed.”

“The chicken and biscuits from Raise the Roost inside the 7-Eleven on Newtown Road and Providence are, by far, the worst I've ever had. The chicken was either overcooked and dry, with burnt outsides and —likely due to improper fryer temperatures or incorrect timer settings. The coating was thick and cakey, indicating poor preparation. Even the green beans had no seasoning or taste. I recommend not using salt if you decide to season. To top it off, the bathrooms were in horrible and smelly condition. I would've returned the food if I had time. Thumbs down! I took pictures but you cannot upload”

“Always happy to go there. Staff is always helpful and nice.”

“We absolutely love everything they offer. The barbacoa tacos, especially, are amazing! One note: the Carne Guisada tacos are really good, but very messy.”

“The Atlantis Diner located in Babylon is a commendable option for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. The Diner maintains a clean and reasonably spacious environment. The staff members are amiable, and the food quality is satisfactory. We enjoyed breakfast for dinner, and it was delightful.”

“I last reviewed Long River 5 years ago. In that time, though, they have upgraded their service and have added a sushi bar that is really phenomenal. The sushi is fresh and the pieces are large. They have a good selection. I have been there 3 times in the last few months and they are getting better each time. It is clean, the service is very professional, prices are fair and the food is very good.”

“So I came to this cafe and picked up my lunch as I was traveling and left my bag, it’s sad and me being careless enough to not realize when driving back to the city when I called and HunterToppie, as he spelled his name helped me save my bag until the next day and I appreciate their honesty with these things as much as their work.Good regardless is good and everything is smooth and clean with the operations. Staff is friendly and nice and I’d visit this every time I’m in this area.Thanks again for your honesty, kindness and service.”

“This was the best sandwich I have had in my entire life. The Italian stallion is perfect. Thank you for taking me to heaven! And the service was delightful quick and full of character!”

“The food is great never any funky taste on the food like mold or the bottom of the fridge, like some places. There very accommodating if one has food allergies. Great place. To bad I live in Mastic Beach.”

“The SPK deli has a fantastic selection of foods. Katya is adorable, she's an amazing Baker and cook. She can cook anything so delicious soups sandwiches great hot lunches. Pete is a great guy who works there .also. totally pleasant atmosphere. You go there once and you will go back again.”

“On March 10th 2024, Myself and My Father went to your restaurant and we got two slices of pizza for $10 and meanwhile once we had finished our slices of pizzas and once we got home from your restaurant we started to get serious sick that led to be we got food poison and trust me I would never go to your restaurant ever again after last night”

“Excellent quality take-out! This place has been our go-to for ten years. Always hot, clean, not heavily salted or overly sauced or oiled like so many horrible take-outs in the area. Well priced and fast delivery. Won't go anywhere else!”

“I love this restaurant, the best on Long Island. Their fried rice is never dry, moist, great portions with lots of pork. I have been coming here for over twenty years. They are the best. Fast service, prices are reasonable, portions big.”

“Takes a tough owner to make a Krispy Pizza!! I could care less if he’s not jolly. The ends justify the means. Nothing beats a hot, fresh, thin and crispy traditional slice of pizza. Beautiful undercarriage! A good snap to the fold!! Delicious sauce, and the right amount of cheese (Not too much) . Sprinkle some red pepper flake, dash of grated cheese, black pepper, granulated garlic, and a pinch of oregano. Add a cold Dr Pepper and I’m off to the races. Can’t eat just one, but order them one at a time and eat them hot and fresh out the oven, hot, thin, and crispy!!”

“I catered a brunch this weekend with Bagel Buzz. This was my second catering order with them. I spoke with Gina over the phone to place my order and alerted her to the many food allergies in my party. I trust Bagel Buzz with making sure no cross contamination takes place in making my order. My wrap platter arrived on time and beautifully arranged and was delicious. The veggie cream cheese for the bagels was rich with fresh vegetables and salads were perfect. Thank you Bagel Buzz and Gina for another awesome catering order. I'll always be back when the next party rolls around.”

“I stop every morning on my way to work. Esmeralda is fantastic. Her happy disposition, manners and true care for her customers is an example of someone who should be considered a valuable employee. Her customer service is top notch.”