Restaurants in West Islip

“My husband and I come every Wednesday night for bingo. Food is great atmosphere is great and we love playing bingo Pat the DJ is awesome love all his bingo calling humor !!!!”

“The giant pretzel with the dipping sauces is amazing!! Yum very nice staff Fun place went to see Serve the Servants Great live music More parking would be 😃👍 great!!”

“Bagels are always hot and fresh.
Cream cheese is just right!
Friendly fast service. One negative the lot is small and often gets congested and Hunter Ave is too busy to safely park on, very busy intersection. Businesses on all 4 corners.”

“only complaint was how busy it was and I can totally understand why. everything was amazing steaks and italian food alike. I'm super picky about my food and I was shocked how great everything was. I live an hour away and am already planning my next visit back. my new favorite restaurant. highly recommend”

“So authentic and great service! The worry dolls were an added bonus as I was there with my daughter. Perfect birthday, love the philanthropy also! Guacamole was the best I’ve ever had.”

“the BEST breakfast spot in West Islip!!! the Nutella Oreo waffles were delicious!!! Definitely recommend it 100%, 5 stars!!! They also have locations in Amityville, East Northport, Centereach and Sayville so if closer to the other locations, go there and give these guys a visit!”

“es un lugar muy agradable familiar los niños selapasan de lo mejor felises”

“Absolutely love their cheese steaks! Service was fast and with a smile....cheese throughout sandwich as it should be...ribeye steak grilled perfectly. Well done!”

“I came here one summer afternoon not long after it rained. There was some sort of group activity inside so I grabbed a flight and sat by the picnic tables, enjoying the afternoon. There was some good food at the food truck as well. Overall I enjoyed the beer and vibes.”

“From start to finish our experience with Our little Italy was perfect. John was so great to work with for all our catering needs. The food was out of this world. So many comments on how amazing the meatballs were. Love using people from our home town. Thanks for everything!!!”

“Great food, friendly atmosphere!!”

“I rarely write reviews but this is a great little spot.i stopped in here just cus i was working in the area and so glad i did. Any time im in the area and wanna stop into a deli this is now my spot. Super friendly owners, quick service, fair prices, and good quality food. Also a nice touch that they have a variety of Asian snacks and beverages.”

“great bar maids on Monday Tuesday Friday and Saturday”

“Had the best lunch today. Food was amazing but the server was even more amazing. Donna rocked it!!! I will be going back soon!”

“I thought I was forever done with burritos, however BBG has restored my faith!! Ordered the Big Papa and it didn't disappoint. Definitely coming back to try more items.”

“As always they went above and beyond making my moms vision come true! When asked what type of wedding cake do I want— 1,000,000% ICE CREAM! Thank you for your beautiful and special touches! ♥️”

“Best heroes on Long Island”

“Cant say more about someplace else, very happy to have you all my friends!?”

“Sugar Island Bake Shop is my go to for ordering special occasion cookies for friends and family! Nicole is a wonderful small business owner who has amazing attention to detail. Her cookies are beautiful and they are absolutely delicious. I've ordered from her and I've had friends surprise me with cookies from her. Being the recipient of her packages is so heart-warming. 10/10 recommend her and her business. ❤️”

“The chicken and biscuits from Raise the Roost inside the 7-Eleven on Newtown Road and Providence are, by far, the worst I've ever had. The chicken was either overcooked and dry, with burnt outsides and —likely due to improper fryer temperatures or incorrect timer settings. The coating was thick and cakey, indicating poor preparation. Even the green beans had no seasoning or taste. I recommend not using salt if you decide to season. To top it off, the bathrooms were in horrible and smelly condition. I would've returned the food if I had time. Thumbs down! I took pictures but you cannot upload”

“Great people, good food. The chicken wings are amazing! Chicken cutlets too. Recommend stopping by and seeing Jay or Vinnie -- they rock.”

“I appreciate you fitting me into your schedule so quickly after my basement lights broke. When your expert showed up on schedule, he promptly and easily resolved the problem. I value electricians who offer dependable after-hours assistance.”

“We absolutely love everything they offer. The barbacoa tacos, especially, are amazing! One note: the Carne Guisada tacos are really good, but very messy.”

“A review recently said they didn’t have the cream cheese but i went about 2 weeks ago and they had plain and veggie. They helped me know which bagels had egg too. Funny the bagels without spread seemed a bit stale but the one made w the cream cheese was fresher and we enjoyed w the tofu veggie cream cheese”

“Takes a tough owner to make a Krispy Pizza!! I could care less if he’s not jolly. The ends justify the means. Nothing beats a hot, fresh, thin and crispy traditional slice of pizza. Beautiful undercarriage! A good snap to the fold!! Delicious sauce, and the right amount of cheese (Not too much) . Sprinkle some red pepper flake, dash of grated cheese, black pepper, granulated garlic, and a pinch of oregano. Add a cold Dr Pepper and I’m off to the races. Can’t eat just one, but order them one at a time and eat them hot and fresh out the oven, hot, thin, and crispy!!”

“Always happy to go there. Staff is always helpful and nice.”

“I love this restaurant, the best on Long Island. Their fried rice is never dry, moist, great portions with lots of pork. I have been coming here for over twenty years. They are the best. Fast service, prices are reasonable, portions big.”

“Been living in West Islip over 20 years consider myself a pizza snob lol. Tried all pizza places in town as well as Babylon. Have to say a lot of places been here and have to say. I ordered tonight put thin crust in my comments. Pizza was cooked to perfection. Arrived hot which was the best as its delivery usually hit or miss. So now on to the taste. Perfect everything a Pizza should be. Also ordered pepperoni pin wheel. Usually they just reheat what’s in the counter. This was 100 percent made fresh not burnt came with sauce as well. All I have to say is I will now continue to come here. I was impressed. Have been using Pizzaria Babylon and getting a delivery from them is always cold and wrong. This place honestly I liked the pizza a lot better as well as the pepperoni roll. Will trade the pastas and heroes soon. Keep up the good work and let’s keep these guys in business here to many crappy places have been in this spot. This place to me was just what we need there. Keep up the great work guys. If you haven’t ordered yet give them a try definitely worth it.”

“The Atlantis Diner located in Babylon is a commendable option for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. The Diner maintains a clean and reasonably spacious environment. The staff members are amiable, and the food quality is satisfactory. We enjoyed breakfast for dinner, and it was delightful.”

“The food is great never any funky taste on the food like mold or the bottom of the fridge, like some places. There very accommodating if one has food allergies. Great place. To bad I live in Mastic Beach.”

“This was the best sandwich I have had in my entire life. The Italian stallion is perfect. Thank you for taking me to heaven! And the service was delightful quick and full of character!”

“Chinese food in general is not my first “Go To “ choice for a quick meal but this place has got it together . Amazing food, tastes clean, not saturated with salt, real light and crispy rolls and consistent consistency in flavor, portions and time to complete order. With prices equal to or better than other scrappy local spots! Oh super friendly staff!!!
& they were open during a major snow event! Thank you ! Four Seasons has my Five Stars 🤩”

“I catered a brunch this weekend with Bagel Buzz. This was my second catering order with them. I spoke with Gina over the phone to place my order and alerted her to the many food allergies in my party. I trust Bagel Buzz with making sure no cross contamination takes place in making my order. My wrap platter arrived on time and beautifully arranged and was delicious. The veggie cream cheese for the bagels was rich with fresh vegetables and salads were perfect. Thank you Bagel Buzz and Gina for another awesome catering order. I'll always be back when the next party rolls around.”