18 Best Caterers near West Islip

iDelizia Deli • $
793 Udall Rd, West Islip
5 Superb4 Reviews
Classico Pizzeria Pizza • $$
5 Udall Rd, West Islip

Customers` Favorites

Hot Honey & Pepperoni Slice
Meatball Parmigiana Hero
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
Tricolor Grandma Slice
Eggplant Rollatini
Spinach Artichoke
Penne Vodka Slice
Chicken Francese
Chicken Classico
Meat Lover Slice

“My grandsons favorite place. Lives the bacon pizza the best ? ( This week Lol). However I too truly like the place. Great good great people. Worth a try for sure. Enjoy.

Kid-friendliness: They talk to the kids and makes them feel more than just a kid at that point. I completely agree that a place such as this anywhere should talk to the kids more. They feel more grow. Up. Makes the entire dinner that much better.“

4.2 Good34 Reviews
Watermill Caterers Caterers • $$
711 Smithtown Bypass, Smithtown - 12.14 miles

“Very classy, great service“

4.7 Superb142 Reviews
Essex Club Caterers • $
100 Pennsylvania Ave, Brentwood - 6.5 miles

“The Essex Club is a beautiful venue with amazing staff! We just played a wedding ceremony there and every detail was attended to with great care.“

4.9 Superb50 Reviews
Victorian Room Caterers • $$
36 W Main St, Bay Shore - 3.19 miles

“Had my daughters bridal shower a few weeks ago and Gina was like a best friend thru it all. Besides the food and venue itself, the staff and all it has to offer is beyond expectations. A lovely start to a new beginning.....10 plus stars“

4.7 Superb63 Reviews
Riviera Waterfront Mansion Caterers • $$$
200 E Shore Dr, Massapequa - 7.44 miles

“The Riviera and their staff provided us with the most amazing wedding. The staff was so accommodating and made sure that my wife and I always had exactly what we needed at all times. They even went the extra mile to make sure our 2 year old ring bearer had his own kids meal and separate cup of ice cream. The site is stunning and all of our guests told us it was one of the best weddings they’ve ever been to. The biggest compliment was the food. The kitchen on site is first class and provided the most delicious food - from the cocktail hour to the Viennese hour. Not to mention the amazing bartenders.

Overall, we recommend the Riviera for any couple looking to have the best wedding.“

4.7 Superb47 Reviews
The Boardroom Cafe and Catering Company Cafe • $
100 Motor Parkway Cafe, Suite LL1, Hauppauge - 7.28 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Jalapeno Mac
Macaroni Salad
Muffin

“Love the food and staff and pay attention to all needs and they make you feel like home 10/10 would come again“

4.9 Superb32 Reviews
Marconi Manor Caterers • $$
333 Moffitt Blvd, Islip - 5.4 miles

“Everyone was great to work with, the place looked beautiful, the food was really good, the bartender made good drinks, the anniversary cake we ordered was fabulous, plenty of parking, easy to get to, reasonable rates, highly recommend!“

4.8 Superb26 Reviews
Felico's Catering Caterers • $$
85 Allen Blvd, Farmingdale - 5.99 miles

“Felico’s Catering did it again. I had a grad party this past Saturday. Everyone loved the food. They’re still talking about how delicious it was! I did both hot and cold. Joann was great to work with. They delivered on time and set up effortlessly. I also had Ledy’s to help and she was amazing! Can’t wait to have another party!!!“

5 Superb17 Reviews
Stew Leonard's Caterers • $$
261 Airport Plaza Blvd Space 5, Farmingdale - 6.23 miles

“This store has been our favorite family store for years, ever since my firstborn was a toddler (and now he’s over 10!). This place is like a mini amusement park for kids. There are buttons to press, characters to wave to, music, animatronics: it keeps them entertained while I try to get some shopping done.

We especially love their seasonal events. Around Halloween, they always have cute themed setups and candy stops for the kids, which makes every visit feel like a little adventure. And let’s not forget the ice cream: honestly, that’s our main reason for coming sometimes! The vanilla is a classic, and the rewards program lets you collect points for free coffee or a sweet treat, which is a total mom-win after a long day.

While I don’t do my main grocery haul here (they don’t carry everything), it’s an easy, enjoyable shopping trip, low-stress and family-friendly. Their sushi is surprisingly decent and made fresh on-site. They also have a hot food bar, some items are hit or miss for my taste, but the soups are consistently good.

We’ve also enjoyed the lobster rolls and the fun weekend BBQ setup outside in the summer - burgers and hot dogs fresh off the grill, which adds to the experience.

The staff is always friendly, and the whole store just has a warm, welcoming vibe. If you’re a parent on Long Island, this is definitely a spot to check out (especially if your kids are cranky and you need coffee and entertainment in one place!).“

4.3 Superb150 Reviews
Corinne's Concepts In Catering Caterers • $$
845 E Jericho Turnpike, Huntington Station - 9.7 miles

“I just used Corinne’s Concepts in Catering for our Rosh Hashana dinner. My very picky family raved about the food! Corinne was a pleasure to work with and was very accommodating as was her staff.“

5 Superb12 Reviews
South Main Street Deli Caterers • $
718 Main St Deli, Farmingdale - 7.21 miles

“Friendly! Fast service! Food is great and delivery is always spot on!“

4.5 Superb17 Reviews
Nikkie's Devine Desserts Bakery • $
Recommended
463 Staples St, Farmingdale - 7.08 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake

“My cake was not only beautiful but tasty 😋“

4.7 Superb29 Reviews
Elegant Eating Caterers • $$$
739 Smithtown Bypass, Smithtown - 12.36 miles

“Elegant Eating catered our Thanksgiving this year. The food came with easy to follow directions heating, etc. and was delicious. We are very satisfied customers. Highly recommend… Thank you Neil and Myra Sincerely, Diana & Mike Gallo“

5 Superb6 Reviews
Limon Mexican Grill Mexican • $
1157 Deer Pk Ave, North Babylon - 2.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Burrito Bowl One with Chicken and One with Steak Burrito
Crispy Tortilla Strips
Nachos with Cheese
Pickled Red Onion
Red Chopped Onion
Mozzarella Sticks
Limon NY Burrito
Grilled Chicken
Nachos Bowl
Taco Salad

“Used to get here every night after the gym, top quality, with great portions and friendly staff. This place was my go to favorite

But i don’t know what happened someone crashed through the front and they haven’t given an update on anywhere which is kind of strange.“

4.1 Good46 Reviews
Roast Sandwich House Sandwich Shop • $
827 Walt Whitman Rd, Melville - 8.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Seasonal Crispy Chicken Hero
Sweet Potato Tater Tots
Angry Turkey Melt
Sweet Potato Tots
Chicken Sandwich
Brussels Sprouts
Grilled Chicken
Alla Vodka
Roast
Wrap

“The Grilled Chicken Panini came out good and hot. The chicken was moist and tasty, and I waited no more than 10 minutes for my order. I will order ahead next time.

I did not like the Eggplant Burrata Caprese because the eggplant was dry.

The lavender lemonade was refreshing on ice.

The cashier was friendly, too.“

3.9 Good72 Reviews
Hostess With The Mostess Catering & Events Caterers • $$
504 Fire Island Ave, Babylon - 1.54 miles

“We hired Hostess with the Mostess for our engagement party. I cannot recommend this company enough. We ordered a cheese board that was beautiful and an amazing seafood tower. Every single person was talking about how polite, knowledgeable, and professional the griller and shucker were. We will definitely be using this company for every event.“

3.4 Good18 Reviews
Fireside Caterers of Huntington Deli • $
120 W Jericho Turnpike, Huntington Station - 10.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sandwich
Salads

“i have stopped in this place a few times and always get the hot chicken dishes with mash potatoes and mix vegatibles.Never have I been disappointed and they serve large portions.Lunch is usually $13 and due chage 3% if you use Credit card. so usually about $14 out the door.The chicken soup is good ( pricey) and the fresh made pot pies are good on the cold days.“

3.8 Good31 Reviews