“Updated post: 4/4/24 -I'm most happy to say that Bagel Boss has done it again! Today they made my mom a delicious Philly sandwich on a plain bagel (b/c of her egg allergy), and I had their superb signature RRS Crash fried chicken cutlet sandwich which is now my favorite! I also got 2 dozen bagels (plain, poppy & sesame) to go. They're terrific, very tasty. Looking forward to going there again soon. Thank you for excellent food and a wonderful staff! Kudos to their manager as well!Original post: 3/13/24 -Kristin helped me today, 5+☆'s (she also helped me back in January). Very friendly, kind, extremely helpful, patient, understanding (my mom has an egg Allergy & she took the time to inquire which bagels had no eggs in them).Today, after a 5 hour stress test doctor visit, my eyes were spinning, but she remained patient & understanding. Delightful customer care! Next time I'm around Bay Shore, I'll make it a point that I stop there again! Thank you!Sincerely, Keith“
“I’m not normally one to write reviews but I just HAD to give it up for Watermill Caterers! We had our ceremony and reception at Watermill in March 2024. Everything was perfect! Not a single thing went wrong! They truly listen to what you envision for your big day and execute it perfectly! Our bridal attendant Christina was completely on top of everything, I never had to lift a finger or worry about anything! Johnny our “captain” was so wonderful and down to earth! He helped make sure everything ran smoothly! Our maître d Nick kept all of the night’s events perfectly scheduled! Watermill is a well-oiled machine! You will not be disappointed booking your wedding here! Be sure to book with the sales person Robert! He was so kind and welcoming, answering any texts and questions we had! The food was incredible! Every entree got raving reviews from our guests! The building and grounds are so well- maintained that you have nothing to worry about for your pictures!“
“Me and my wife Stepheny had our wedding reception here on June 4, 2023 and we could thank Jessica and Rob anymore for allowing us to have such a beautiful experience. Our guests raved about the “fairytale-like” reception and it was all thanks to Jessica, Rob, and their team who helped to bring our ideas into reality. Their wedding package deal was insanely convenient and worth-it. Do not hesitate to book with them as they will help you and support you through-out the entire stressful process. Thank you Jessica and Rob!“
“I just got married on March12th and it was a phenomenal wedding the staff was wonderful and accommodating making sure I was eating and taken care of ! The wedding was beautiful the food was amazing and everyone had a great time I most definitely recommend everyone to have their wedding at timber point you won’t be disappointed“
“Compared to maracas or guacamole time across the street, this place is on point. Had the Birria and theu were delishish. Across the street they put Chipotle sauce in their Birria for some ungodly reason and it's terrible . Limon tasted like Dirty Taco. I will be trying more things off the “
Caterers • $
“We had our baby shower here over the weekend, and everything was perfect and delicious. Michaela was amazing and communication was spot on. One minor comment I would like to make, is that a customer should be given a look at the contract before actually leaving a deposit. That’s the only approach I would change, this way you know what you can or cannot do to the space. Other than that, we will be returning there for the amazing food they offer next door.“
“Great new Pizza spot in West Islip that I've been going to more & more compared to other Pizza spots in the area. I've only ordered the regular Cheese Pizza Pies there & it's the closest thing to something you would get at some of the well-known Pizza places in Manhattan or Brooklyn. ??“
Caterers • $$
“We ordered Breakfast for Yom Kippur. Corinne and her staff put together a meal that went beyond our requests. In this age of zero customer service, we were overjoyed with the quality of the food and the beautiful presentation! Our guests sat down to a gorgeous and satisfying meal. No fuss. No muss. Worth every penny! Thank you, Corinne.“
“I belong to the Marconi Sons & Daughters of Italy Lodge. They have a social every 1st Thursday of the month. Dinner w/wine, beer + soda. Followed by dessert + coffee. Dancing w/ a great DJ. You do not need to be a member to attend. $30 for non-members.“
“We have used Elegant Eating to cater a few of our holidays , and family engagements . Its been a few years using them. Many times when one sticks to one establishment; you can tell when they get a new cook, or any kind of new help as the order might be a little or a lot different . Its been more than 6 years using Elegant Eating; and in my opinion and my families , the quality of the service, the food etc has maintained its high standards. Especially is these times when food has sky rocketed in prices, and everybody is working harder to make ends meet, and or to keep their businesses going . Elegant Eating has found a way to maintain every aspect of their catering business. Worth a Try if your in need of a Good Caterer.“
Caterers • $$
“I had a party with 50+ people and thanks to the efforts of my Hostess with the Mostess crew, it went off flawlessly! I was provided 2 servers and a bartender and they began working immediately upon arrival. They were all professional, courteous and extremely pro-active! I didn’t have to ask them to do anything-they simply took the initiative themselves! I highly recommend this company as this was not the first time I used them and have always been happy the day after!!“
“I have been living on Long Island for 20 years and could never find pizza that was better than average. I moved to greenlawn and tried broadway pizza and never looked back. It is absolutely delicious. Delivery is so fast too and it’s piping hot when it gets here. I’m from jersey where the pizza was phenomenal so I’m a tough critic. Broadway pizza is amazing. Just order it or go there. You will be happy , I promise. One thing is I have no idea if it’s expensive or not. Pizza is not something I check prices on.“
“Last night my fiancé and I had our rehearsal dinner at the Victorian Room. From start to finish, Gina the owner was absolutely amazing ! The room is so beautifully decorated and cozy . The food was phenomenal , tasted like a home cooked meal ! The service was impeccable and professional from not only herself but her staff as well. All of the desserts were made by Gina and they were beyond delicious especially the hot donuts and rainbow cookies .. OMG! This was such a special night of celebration and we cannot thank you enough for making it so memorable for us and our family /friends. I cannot wait to plan the next party which will definitely be at the Victorian Room . We love you Gina and staff !!!!!! ❤️? xo“