25 Best Pizza Restaurants near Wurtsboro

Gotta Luv It Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop Italian • $
187 Kingston Ave, Wurtsboro

Customers` Favorites

Slice of Pizza
Chicken Wings
Cheese Pizza

“I order and white pizza with broccoli. It was absolutely delicious. Thank you so much. I live in the hills will definitely be back.“

4.2 Good42 Reviews
wurtsboro Diner and Cafe American • $
60 Sullivan St, Wurtsboro

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom or Spinach Omelette with Home Fries & Toast
Goat Cheese and Mushroom Panini Phenomenal
Two Eggs with Home Fries & Toast
Reuben Hamburger with Fries
Chicken Souvalki Platter
Egg and Cheese on a Roll
Grilled Cheese and Fries
Sunnyside Eggs Benedict
Grilled Ham and Cheese
Chocolate Chip Pancakes

“Very good food. Healthy options“

4 Good79 Reviews
Cosimo's Brick Oven Pizza • $$
620 NY-211, Middletown - 9.94 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana Classic
Brick Oven Garlic Bread
Rigatoni Alla Buttera
Blackened Steak Salad
Spicy Chicken Fusilli
Chicken Scarpariello
Seafood Fra Diavolo
Dessert and Coffee
Portobello Ravioli
Calamari Marinara

“Delicious food! Great service.“

4.3 Superb190 Reviews
Pellegrino & Son's Pizzeria Pizza • $
65 Dolson Ave, Middletown - 10.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Breaded Chicken Fries Spicy Sweet and Honey Sauce
Penne Alla Vodka Pizza Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza and Garlic Knots
Steamed Vongole Clams Posillipo
Buffalo Shrimp Appetizer
New Taco Bowl Salad
Cheese Ravioli Parm
Large Pizza Half
Italian Antipasto
Margherita Pizza

“Our family was looking last minute for a place to have a family dinner to celebrate our daughter’s ninth birthday after our original reservation fell through at another place. Pelligrinos is our favorite pizza spot so I called them. It was 5:30PM on a Friday night and I asked if they could accommodate our party of nine at 7:00. They were happy to prepare a table for us! I was shocked. They brought us the most incredible plate antipasto and placed it in front of our daughter and said happy birthday! Then we have the most delicious apps, pizza and an incredible pasta special for dinner. We couldn’t have been happier! They then brought complimentary fried dough for dessert for the table! What an incredible experience! We were so grateful that they not only came to our rescue at that late hour, but they went above and beyond to make sure we had a great night. If you want a five star experience with both food and service, go to Pelligrinos!“

4.5 Superb49 Reviews
Caputo's Pizza Pizza • $
36 James St, Middletown - 9.63 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Garden Salad
Philly Cheese Steak Combo
Mozzarella Sticks
Smores Ice Cream
Chicken Parmesan
Pepperoni Pizza
Shrimp & Garlic
Shrimp Francese
Chicken Marsala
Buffalo Chicken

“Caputo’s chicken cutlet gets a 6/10—mediocre when fresh, with a buffalo chicken taste that clashed with the veggies, but oddly better when cold. Their pizza’s solid, a go-to for me, but the rice and beans were bland yet still satisfying. Reliable spot, but not without its flaws.

I always get it delivered“

4.4 Superb65 Reviews
Alfonso's Pizza • $
835 NY-211, Middletown - 10.45 miles

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Parmesan with Pasta
Pepperoni Onions and Peppers
Slice of Pizza by the Slice
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
White Pizza with Spinach
Medium Meatball Pizza
Grilled Chicken Slice
Pasta with Meatballs
Pizza with Mushroom
Mozzarella Sticks

“My first time here and it won’t be my last. I described a salad I was in the mood for and he the owners made exactly that. It was fresh and delicious. I recommend this restaurant and look forward to returning and trying different dishes.“

4.4 Superb48 Reviews
Marco's Pizza (Middletown) Pizza • $
670 NY-211, Middletown - 10 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cramberry Walnut Chicken
Plain Cheese Pizza Slice
Stuffed Meat Pizza Slice
Cranberry Walnut Salad
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Fajita Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Sausage & Peppers
Grilled Chicken
Brooklyn Pizza

“We have been going here since we moved to Middletown in 2016. Hands down the best pizza place in Middletown. Donaldo and his team are awesome!“

4.3 Superb58 Reviews
Bella Lena's Pizza • $
511 NY-17M, Middletown - 8.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hawaiian Pie

“This is by far my go to when I’m hungry . My family has eaten pizza here , we’ve gotten turkey and cheese hero’s here . Oh my goodness , their calamari and dipping sauce is to die for . They have zeppos , Sicilians , calzones. You can sit down and watch some tv while enjoying a nice cheesy saucy slice of pizza ! It’s a wonderful place that is run but a very nice family.

Parking: There’s a few parking spaces right in front and you can also park on the side . I’ve never had an issue parking and I’ve dined in a few times and I have also taken out too .“

4.7 Superb18 Reviews
Colandrea Pizza King Pizza • $
360 Route 211 East, Middletown - 9.77 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Margherita with Spinach
Homemade Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Parmesan Hero
Pepperoni Pin Wheel
Plain Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza Assorted
Small Calzone
Seafood Combo
Garlic Bread

“best all around“

4.2 Good87 Reviews
Main St Pizza Pizza • $
5202 Main St, South Fallsburg - 11.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese & White Pizza Pie
Vanilla Soft Ice Cream
Regular Pizza Pie
Cheese Pretzels
Slice of Pizza
Ice Cream Cone
Regular Fries
Mountain Roll
Cheese Bites
Sushi Salad

“Satisfy your pizza cravings at Main Street Pizza! This cozy spot offers tasty and fresh pies that will delight you any time of the day. Friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere add to the charm. Don't hesitate to stop by and indulge in your favorite slice!(Currently located in Landau's Supermarket, It's around the corner. due to renovation in the Pizza store)“

4.5 Superb17 Reviews
Pizza E Birra Pizza • $$
287 NY-211, Middletown - 9.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Calamari Fra Diavolo
Create Your Own Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Rucola E Pomodorini
The Hangover Burger
Mussels Fri Diavolo
French Onion Soup
The Alessia Pizza
Burrata Sandwich

“we were on our honeymoon with my wife and some relatives took us to this place to try the typical Neapolitan pizza and other local specialties..
Having also been in the restaurant business and a pizza chef for many years, I can say that it is not easy to find a pizzeria in America and above all such good pizza, truly heartfelt congratulations..
The staff is very kind and friendly, it feels like family.
Highly recommended for anyone who wants to have a great experience in an American pizzeria.

Parking: Parcheggio ampio e gratuito“

4.1 Good80 Reviews
Tuscany pizzeria Pizza • $
13 Greenfield Rd, Woodridge - 9.97 miles

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti Marinara 9x13
Sweet Potato Fries 9x13
Large All Fish Platter
Fresh Mozzarella Slice
Gluten Free Pizza Pie
Philadelphia Roll
Spicy Fries 9x13
Broccoli Pizza
Cucumber Roll
Avocado Salad

“My family visited this place twice while vacationing in the area. The food tasted good. There were no long lines. Preparation didn't take too long. Not crowed (but we came during "slow" hours both times). The only negative thing I can say the tables were dirty and nobody came to clean them and we ended up wiping them with napkins.“

4.8 Superb6 Reviews
Pizza Mania Pizza • $
9 Main St, Otisville - 7.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Well Done Cheese Pizza

“Not only is the food amazing but the owners are incredible! Super family friendly atmosphere at a great price. We have been going since before our daughter was born and now she loves our Friday tradition. She lights up the second she realizes we are there. Thank you Pizza Mania for always being consistently amazing!“

4.2 Good18 Reviews
Frank's Pizza & Italian Restaurant Pizza • $
470 NY-211, Middletown - 10.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Broccoli Chicken Pizza Avocado Spinach Pizza
Stuffed Baked Ziti Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Pizza by the Slice
Gluten Free Pizza
Grilled Chicken
Grandma Pizza
Lobster Bisque
Garlic Knots

“absolutely lovely heart shapped pizza for Valentine's day 😍“

3.9 Good83 Reviews
Joey's Pizza (Middletown) Pizza • $
88 Dunning Rd Suite 11, Middletown - 10.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch
Large Grandma Pie
Margherita Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
Slice of Pizza
Gourmet Pizza
Eggplant Pizza
Garlic Knots
Cheese Pizza
Chicken Wings

“Today was first time we ordered and the food was AMAZING! Very fresh and seasoned perfectly. Cannot wait to order again. Boneless wings, chicken tenders, zucchini fries, bolognese and meatball parmigiana and veggie roll.“

3.9 Good81 Reviews
John's Of Arthur Ave Pizza • $
19 W Main St, Middletown - 9.72 miles

Customers` Favorites

Slice of Family Size BBQ Chicken Pizza
Grill Chicken Salad Balsamic Dressing
Eggplant and Pesto Pizza
Cheese Pizza Personal 12
Garlic Knots Pizza
Fast Cheese Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Caesar Salad
Gramma Pizza

“Great place! I like their pizza, and the variety they offer, but their sandwiches are also sublime. (Try their pickled onions!) I recently had their buffalo chicken dip, which came with "pita chips" that actually wound up being slices of fresh pita bread- so good! They never disappoint.“

3.9 Good56 Reviews
Dominick's Pizzeria Pizza • $
104 Center St, Ellenville - 10.75 miles

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Parmigiana with Pasta Marinara
Veal Parmigiana with Pasta Marinara
Chicken Francese with Pasta
Funnel Fries or Funnel Cake
Broccoli Garlic Calzone
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Marsala
Waffles

“Delicious food, and great people! I’ve been coming here since I was a teenager, and I’ve never been disappointed! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

3.9 Good31 Reviews
Grand Slam Pizza • $
2107 NY-302, Circleville - 6.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
Sausage and Peppers
Jalepeno Poppers
Cheesesteak Works
Chicken Marsala
Comes with Salad
Philly Cheese
Anchovy Slice
Chicken Club
Pizza

“My family has been eating regularly at grand slam for about 15 years. The quality has never dropped and remains our favorite pizza and wing stops in the area!! The pizza and Stromboli are amazing and the wings are even better. The staff are all extremely kind and the prices are great!“

3.9 Good20 Reviews
Pizza Star Italian • $
400 NY-211, Middletown - 9.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

California Pizza Philly Cheesesteak
Chicken Broccoli Alfredo
Pepperoni Pizza Roll
House Special Pizza
Salad Dressing
Red Velvet Cake
Cheese Pizza
Sausage Parm
Garlic Knots
Chicken Parm

“My husband and I went there today for lunch and omg sooo good we got pizza we got cake we got it alll lol all of it was delicious“

4.5 Superb55 Reviews
THE DALE Bar • $$
4 Old Post Hill Rd, Mountain Dale - 8.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ratatouille Mediterranean Veggie Skillet
Roasted Rainbow Carrots
Cast Iron Chicken Thigh
Custom Classic Pizza
The Dale House Salad
Wild Mushroom Pizza
Smoked Trout Plate
Smoked Trout Salad
Big Brocc Energy
Pepperoni Pizza

“I am insanely happy to have been introduced to this establishment over the weekend. Small spot with excellent food, excellent service and ALL of the vibes. High end food in a laid back, fun setting, you can't go wrong here.“

4.4 Superb82 Reviews
Mountain View Italian • $$
241 Stone School House Rd, Bloomingburg - 4.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Charlie Drooling over the Philly Cheesesteak
Children's Spaghetti and Meatballs
Chicken Piccata over Pasta
Burger and Cheese Fries
Steak and Baked Potato
Chicken Marsala Pizza
Chicken Cordon Blue
Chicken Parmigiana
French Onion Soup
Pizza with Olive

“Went there for my wife's birthday dinner it was 4 of us my wife and my friends wife had prime rib I had chicken Sorrento and my friend had a huge steak and fries plus a calamari app plus we had 4 drinks and the wife took home a piece of cake for later all of us took food home portions were huge food was great service was great our waitress was Alicia she was awsome and we git the bill and it was only $155 total will definitely be going there again 😀“

4.4 Superb80 Reviews
Pecorino's Pizzeria Italian • $
253 Tower Dr, Middletown - 9.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mediterranean Salad with Grilled Chicken
Lasagna & Broccoli Rabe with Ziti
Sausage Peppers & Onions Pizza
Sausage and Chicken Parm Pizza
Shrimp & Spinach Pasta
Turkey & Cheese Sub
Circle of Life Pizza
Meat Lover's Pizza
Pecorino’S Pizza
Seafood Fradiavolo

“Compared to neighboring places, this beats them hands down. If you plan to eat and it beats other pizzeria options, it’s my number one place to go for pizza and more. The ingredients are fresh and the food tastes absolutely awesome.“

4.5 Superb49 Reviews
Little Caesars Pizza Pizza • $
148-150 Wickham Ave, Middletown - 9.49 miles

Customers` Favorites

Little Ceased Cheese Breadsticks
Buffalo Caesars Wings
Pepperoni Cheese Bread
Italian Cheese Bread
Classic Pepperoni
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings

“I mean it’s little Caesar’s
You know the expectations
But this place is respectful clean and love coming here when I go up state and need some pizza
Show some love if your a local
And
Out of respect give this place a 8.5/10 not cause I hate it
Just cause it’s little Caesars and I gotta be honest with the people“

3.7 Good31 Reviews
Nick's Pizza Pizza • $
61 State St, Otisville - 7.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Parmigiana
Everything Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
W Pepperoni

“I recently ordered a large pizza pie, and I must say—it was absolutely phenomenal! Let me begin by emphasizing how fantastic the food is. Anyone claiming otherwise must either be mistaken or not genuine. Family-owned businesses face enough challenges without unwarranted negativity or attempts to tarnish their reputation.

The service here is consistently warm and welcoming, which is a testament to the care and dedication that comes from a family-run establishment. You can truly taste the love and effort in every bite. The prices are incredibly reasonable, and every time my family and I place an order, the delivery is impressively fast.

I’ve only ever had outstanding experiences with this place—prompt service, delicious food, and excellent value. Thank you once again for another exceptional pie!“

3.7 Good40 Reviews
Villa Gaudio of Bullville Inc Pizza • $
2856 NY-17K, Middletown - 6.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Cutlet Hero with Lettuce Tomato & Mayo
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
Chicken Noodle Soup
Fried Calamari
Fresh Garlic
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots
Meatballs
Sausage
Salad

“Great atmosphere, best pizza in town. Great customer service.“

3.7 Good46 Reviews

Wurtsboro’s Other Flavors

You May Also Like