49 Best Pizza Restaurants near Batavia

“You were slammed and short staffed tonight. Had to wait for awhile for our order, but everyone in the store was super friendly and moving quickly with a lot of effort to fill the orders. Got home and our order was perfect and the pizzas were absolutely fantastic. I never mind waiting when I see people giving that kind of effort. Thanks for a great dinner tonight!!!!“

“Love this place a whole lot- they're consistent, and just a quality pizza joint that doesn't skimp on cheese and toppings (I think they use whole milk mozzarella). In Batavia/Eastgate, it's the best option for a pie that I'm aware of. They take pride in the food, and offer a higher quality pizza than you'll get from a corporate chain store. Good stuff.“

“The pizzas are great and so is the service !“

“I’m born in Maryland raised down south and when I say Godfather pizza is the best that I’ve ever had in my life I really mean it words can’t describe how great and delicious this pizza is the price is really affordable and I miss coming here with my coworkers to grab some pizza ? after a hard day of duct sealing ???“

“We have not ordered Domino’s Pizza for over 20 years because we did not care for it 20 years ago, but after they revamped, we wanted to try it again and we was very impressed their Buffalo mac & cheese was great. Their pizza was great although one pizza they forgot two toppings it was still good. Eric our delivery driver was very friendly professional, and nice We highly recommend Domino’s Pizza for a pizza of choice“

“I decided to give them another try: my food was great. To the young lady with the long dark hair, I love your accent and your kindness. Keep up the great work ethics and you will definitely make it in life.“

“This Place has stepped it up, In A lot of way the past few months, New People working, always Cleaning......Great service and Food is Fantastic, depends on ur taste...Yea not everything is the Best or perfect but Ive noticed a huge change...and noticed couple comment about gloves, UR FOOD GOES IN AN OVEN OR A FRYER WHICH KILLS ALL BACTERIA...NUFF SAID AND ive noticed certain individuals washing their hands consistantly... thanks Grammas Pizza...Keep it up“

“Today’s visit was terrible. Pizza had huge bubbles that were charcoaled and bottom wasn’t baked. Service was not good either. A small place that somehow accommodated a party of 10, 8 of which were loud teens. We were moved to accommodate these guests and they didn’t behave like someone their age should. Ruined a Sunday evening meal.“

“If you guys haven’t tried this Grammas locations Alfredo sauce, you HAVE to! This is the only location that has Alfredo. It’s absolutely amazing! We actually get it in our pizza instead of pizza sauce, and OMG. Just try it! 10 out of 10 highly recommend!“

“Jet’s Pizza went above and beyond! We ordered 30 pizzas for a large event, and everything was hot, fresh, and incredibly tasty. The team handled our big order with ease—on time, perfectly prepared, and super organized.

A special shoutout to the owners, who are not only professional but also genuinely kind and welcoming. You can tell they care deeply about their customers and the quality of what they serve.

The crowd loved every bite—especially that amazing crust! We’ll definitely be back. Highly recommend Jet’s for any big event or gathering!“

“Beth, Gus, and rest of the staff I don’t know everyone’s name but they have the very best customer service, my grandson is Autistic and they always accommodate his needs, making him feel special, they make him his pizza exactly to his liking which keeps me very happy! They have great food choices and reasonable prices. You can eat outside now too if you want which is great on nice days! The only thing left needed is a pick up window would b awesome !“

“The food was delicious. 10 out of 10. Give the cashier a raise. Lily was the best.“

“ate there last night. my family got 3steak hoagies, fish hoagie and onion rings. We all liked it very much. Definitely will go back!“

“Absolutely love Grammas ! First had it at work, from the Batavia location. We ordered from the Milford location today, and as always, our pizza was fresh and delicious. We especially loved the Hawaiian Delight pizza ! Friendly service, both on the phone and when we picked up our order. 🍕😃“

“Just ordered for the first time and it won’t be the last! Boneless wings were so tasty, the chicken strips were a 10/10. Meat lovers pizza was equally delicious, they even put the topping underneath! Timing for pick up was right on point!“

“Ordered takeout in advance for pickup. The Baked Buddy was done well but the Jo Jo salad came only with lettuce and nothing else. Missing was the dressing, bacon, cheese, tomato and croutons. We had to make a return trip and ask them to make it properly. Turns out their online order system does not give you a complete Jo Jo salad unless you pick every ingredient you want from the order site. This seems contrary to how it should work which would be if you order a specific kind of salad it comes with all the right ingredients in the recipe unless you tell them not to include certain ones. I mean if I order a specialty pizza it comes with everything included unless I tell them to hold some ingredients. A salad selection should work the same way. It was disappointing but the staff were friendly and got it corrected. I hope the IT guys can do the same for the app. Not a fan!“

“Very under staffed but good pizza and games“

“Just ate here an there were these two very kind an very fast and hard working 15 year old boys who gave me a good pizza!! this was on Wednesday!!! 10/10 great“

“The manager (forgive me if I’m wrong) Chris, has been in the business for quite some time and goes above and beyond for his customers. I want to recognize such a great manager who takes pride in what he does. Thanks for making this place enjoyable! The pizza is by far the best in town!“

“2nd best pizza I've ever had. Crust, meats and cook time of the pie are spot on. One little mom & pops in North Carolina is my favorite. But this is excellent. Kettle chips are great as well. We are from out of town, but we'll be back.“

“First, long time drivebyer, first time diners. This is multi fold. 1) I recommend Padrino 100%. A surprise destination for Monday as “marinara night”. 2) Grace is one of the nicest, personable, and best servers I can say I’ve had in recent memory. After telling her that we had never been and how we typically order food when we go out, she walked us through every page of the menu and asked pertinent questions like “hey do you guys want apps tonight?” After we talked we thought maybe we should try a pasta, hoagie, and a pizza. She provided suggestions for each of those sections and we took her up from her list. I saw an employee of the _____, not sure if it was month, day, week, or what, or if she’s had it before, but she definitely deserves it! Which brings us to… 3) FOOD! Not only that, but PRICE!!! I will preface this as if nobody picked up on our “try some of a lot of things” and then have leftovers for the next day approach which has been illustrated above, but I’d say what we got was SUBSTANTIAL for what we spent. Heck, screw the dollars, let’s talk about flavor! Pasta: Vodka Tortellini, and she recommended we each get a garlic knot to finish off the sauce. I can’t give a fair shake to the knots because I just couldn’t eat anymore, but boy did they look and smell delicious. But the pasta? Shoo Sammie: Padrino Club. Sure it sounded and probably gets viewed as basic, which it was way more than basic thanks to their garlic aioli to top it off. And go with Grace, swap for the Parmesan fries! I’m not usually one for fries anymore but golly…. Parm fries for the win (I’ll say they’re at fault for me not making it to a knot) And finally Pizza: again our quests of trying a lot we were told we could split a large between specialities and we did. The choices: Chef’s Forte and Drunken Goat. I can safely say I’d expect any of their pizzas to be delicious based off trying these two. The veggies part on the Forte were SO big and noticeable and delicious and cooked to perfection. Will we be back? 100%“

“Jackson was our waiter. He was very pleasant and did a great job. Friendly service and the food was delicious.“

“delicious pizza done perfectly even with special instructions“

“They are usually great. When they do mess up they will make it right. Great management and amazing service most of the time. I've been a regular for 6 months, at least 2 or 3 times a week. I was short $ one day and they credited me my whole order. Couldn't have came at a more helpful time.“

“It’s nice to have something new to our area.. we have been picking up but due to working on the heat in our house today we had it delivered. I don’t know her name but she was super friendly and my dogs even tho they aren’t mean barking at her didn’t bother her. Thanks for the good food and super friendly customer service!!! Lance I’m gonna need to have a chat with you after tonight.“

“This is an awesome place to hang out. The beer is great. The food is terrible. Eat before you go.“

“I go to the Ohio Pike Domino's for the great carry out deals they send to the Domino's Rewards members. I can't make a large pizza at home for the price they charge on the cart out specials. The pizzas are better than Sam's club or Costco pizzas since you can top them like you want, for about the same price.“

“They always get my order correct & everything always tastes delicious! Jessica is my favorite delivery person, she is always so sweet & makes sure to give me paper plates & silverware when she delivers to my job! I always appreciate you guys always going above & beyond for me & my coworkers!“

“Order the new Papadias and the crust over done and dry. They need to brushed with butter maybe to help the ends of the crust from drying out. I think the ones I got were over done.“

“I’ve been here countless times over the years. This is the best pizza on the eastside. It’s very New York style, which I love.I’m surprised people said they had a poor experience with the staff, they have been nothing but nice to me.You will continue to have my business for years to come!“

“We have an amazing time every time we eat at Milford LaRosa’s! The night manager and all of the staff are amazing and always go above and beyond! Highly recommend!“

“The restaurant was very clean, staff was extremely friendly and cheerful and the food was great. There were many families inside yet the noise level was very minimal and all the children were well controlled by their parents. It was a very nice dinner visit on my way back home to Louisville.“

“It's 9:30 your crew is killing it. This combination of people work great together. Don't spilt them up. When it's busy the communication between them is incredible. They had 8-10 customers when I came in to the store and really had the energy turned up. Fun to watch.“

“Not only is our pizzas cooks perfectly, I gave them a 20% tip in cash and you would’ve thought the world stopped. The general manager came out to the parking lot and told me I’m welcome anytime so not only your pizza good but their customer service is absolutely out of this world.“

“Love their pizza. I much rather wait 10mins. while I'm already out for than wait an hour for someone to bring it to my house.“

“Awesome staff! Always great sandwiches/food ! This establishment doesn’t get the credit it should!“

“Had a long drive after a soccer game and had hungry kids. We arrived just minutes before closing and Thomas was happy to make us a pizza and feed my kiddos. Not many restaurants or should I say restaurant employees would be so kind and willing to wait on us. Thank you Thomas and New Richmond Papa Johns. We will be back with a promise to get there earlier.“

“Jackie was the only one working when I arrived and had my order fresh and ready to go. Was very polite and did not forget my sauces. Food was perfect and I know for a fact that Jackie made it considering she was the only one working. Thanks to Jackie I was able to get my food! 😁“

“Their pizza is amazing! Also love the loaded fries! Best Hawaiian pizza ever!“

“Over the summer, I was ordered Pizza Hut weekly. I have NEVER been disappointed with the service or food. Service is always incredibly amazing (especially since Covid hit) The FOOD, OH MY GOSH....always SO FLIPPING FRESH! Always warm and delightful. We get the Dinner Box a lot and it is a great price for what you get! $10 and the kids are fed. Last night I was really impressed when my pizza showed up! The delivery guy was incredible nice, noticed the Happy Birthday decor in home and sang a little tune to my birthday boy! He also handed me a coupon for FREE PIZZA (NO Purchase necessary) because they were running late! I didn't notice that either so yep....Pizza hut is my new pizza place!“

“I ordered a custom pizza with half pepperoni and half margarita. They have different sauces on them and I thought it was awesome that someone from the restaurant called to make sure I knew that those sauces might bleed into each other when they go through the oven. Clearly that's not something that they can control but they just wanted to make sure I was aware because they're two different flavors. The fact that they went out of their way to let me know meant a lot. Some places won't even let you customize a pizza with two different sauces on each half because of this. I used to work at a pizza place so I knew what I was getting into when I ordered it. And I'm glad they allowed me to have it the way I wanted it. It was absolutely amazing! That thin crust is so refreshing. It's kind of dangerous because you don't fill up and feel miserable as you're eating it like you do with most thicker crusts. You can eat a lot more of their pizza because of how light it feels. But gosh it's good! Actually I'm kind of craving it now that I'm talking about it. Haha.“

“Nice, friendly place. Nice people“

“I recently indulged in a Hawaiian pizza from Papa John's, and it was an absolute delight from the first bite to the last. The combination of sweet pineapple, savory ham, and tangy sauce on a perfectly baked crust created a symphony of flavors that left me craving more. The quality of the ingredients was evident, with fresh toppings that elevated the overall experience. The crust had just the right amount of crispiness, providing the perfect canvas for the delicious toppings. Additionally, the efficient and friendly service made the entire ordering process on their app was a breeze. Papa John's continues to impress with their consistently delicious pizzas, and I highly recommend their Hawaiian pizza to anyone looking for a taste of paradise. Five stars without a doubt!“

“i came in on aug the 29th in an absolute state i had a splitting headache and on top of that i was having problems with their website and had to order in store

a handsome young gentleman with curly hair helped me and because of him you’ve won a customer for life

donatos i thank you sincerely for this delicious pizza adventure and the ice cold soda“

“They have lots of different kinds of food that is simply amazing. The pizza is absolutely superb. I have gotten many kinds of pizza from them and they have all been amazing. I've also gotten a few different kinds of incredibly good Hoagies. The steak Hoagie with pizza sauce is absolutely amazing. The chicken wings are really good as well. There's not much to say about the restaurant since you can't eat in. It looks decent to me. I definitely recommend you trying some of their amazing food.“

“Had a not so great experience with an order and after completing the online survey the manager, Sara reached out and made it right. This was self initiated on her part. Appreciate the effort and will continue to patronize this location based on that experience. Enjoyed pizza from there tonight with our family.“

“The custom calzone I ordered was delicious. The environment is wonderful, and the servers were nice. As much as I loved the food I received, I felt incredibly limited due to my seafood allergy. They do not have any separate fryer or grill for items to avoid cross contamination. This was a shame because I live very close by and would love to try more items on their menu some day. However, when businesses can't separate oil or the grill, then it means that customers who have a seafood allergy can't enjoy the restaurant at its fullest.“

“If you guys haven’t tried this Grammas locations Alfredo sauce, you HAVE to! This is the only location that has Alfredo. It’s absolutely amazing! We actually get it in our pizza instead of pizza sauce, and OMG. Just try it! 10 out of 10 highly recommend!“