17 Best American Restaurants near Bellefontaine

“Hubby took me there for my Birthday dinner. The appetizer’s were delicious. The ribeye steak dinners and all the fixings were amazing and all topped with an excellent server. Sorry to say it was our first time and sad we hadn’t checked it out sooner!!! Definitely going back soon!!!“

“All the workers here are so sweet and the best pizza ever“

“great service great jukebox great ppl“

“We were originally looking for taco salads, but after seeing the taco pizza on the menu ordered it instead. OMG, this thing was da bomb! We ordered an extra large! lots left over, but wife is sharing the rest at work with friends. Best taco pizza I have had in my 62 years. It was our first visit but will not be the last. Excellent beyond all expectations.“

“Warm and friendly staff, great smoothies, loaded omelettes, and healthy / delicious wraps and salads as well. The owner puts his heart and soul into the experience.“

“Staff is so friendly, and the custard is amazing. Everybody should check this place out. There is almost never parking out front because it is downtown and the parking is shared for all the stores so that is expected but don't let that stop you from coming it, there's a huge parking lot out back. The staff is willing to explain the menu to you and how it works as it is sometimes confusing to newcomers, but anything that you get is going to be absolutely amazing. When they are busy the staff is very apologetic if it takes longer to get you order out, but 9/10 times you get your stuff right away. CHECK THIS PLACE OUT!!“

“First time being back since they first open. The staff was great got seated right away then the waiter was right there taking drink orders. I ordered wings and garlic parm fries. Wife got the burger with the pulled pork on it. everything came out hot and fresh with great taste. There was a couple downside my wings came out needing a life jacket way to much sauce. Plus for being a sit down restaurant it would of been nice to have actual silverware instead of pre packaged plastic silverware. Will definitely be back.“

“they was all very polite & it was clean.“

“Tasia, thank you for excellent service today. You are so polite and efficient. The cook made my 6 oz. Sirloin a perfect medium-rare. So flavorful and delicious. We ordered the $10 sirloin+2 sides deal. Exceptional value for a delicious meal, served with perfection. Thank you, $1.99 margaritas are strong and tasty for the cost.“

“This location appears to be one of the highest rated restaurants in the area surrounding Indian Lake, and I can agree with this high rating. The reuben sandwich was excellent and the fries were also very good; I felt that they were similar to the sort of french fries you might get at a state fair. The staff were inviting and entertaining and the atmosphere was perfect. I believe this is a great place to check out for those visiting Indian Lake.“

“Best place ever ice cream is so good and service is perfect it take made about 4 minutes to get everything but if you get food it take like 5 or 10 minutes other wise I love it

Wheelchair accessibility: They have a ramp for wheelchairs“

“A charming “mom & pop” restaurant vibe. The food was delicious. The kids had chicken strips, the men had lunch meals, I ate breakfast. There are a lot of menu options at reasonable prices!! My favorite part about it all was the homemade pie they do in house there at the restaurant. It really set them apart. We had the coconut crème pie and the peanut butter pie. My daughter had a strawberry milkshake & my son had a bowl of vanilla ice cream. Nothing but good things to say about this place. West liberty has a cool antique store and thrift store as well.“

“Lulu’s at the lake is amazing! Our family stopped in for breakfast on a Tuesday morning it wasn’t very busy. Our server was great, he was attentive got us menus soon as we sat down and took our drink order when he came back he grabbed our breakfast order. Food came quickly and it was so yummy! I got the French toast, one of my kids got the Mickey pancakes, and we got the breakfast bowl! It was all so very yummy!!! Service and food was excellent“

“The batting cages have been updated, the putt putt course looks immaculate. Our food & the ice cream were KILLER. Definitely worth stopping by here before or after a day on the water or just driving through. Always supporting local when possible. 😊“

“***** they have the best pizza *****“

“I’ve always love supporting our local spots around our community and this one for sure for its Friday Fish Special, Sunday steak dinners, and Monday Taco lunches, along with many other great menu items, and the atmosphere itself, laid back chill and a place for anyone to come hang out inside in the cool ac, or out back to enjoy the natural temps! Great place for a bike ride as well! 5 Star Dive Bar!“

“We drove up here from south of Dayton Ohio just to have lunch on the lake. This place had a great vibe. Food was good. Nothing fancy, typical bar food but good. We had a great time sitting outside watching the boats come and go. Waitress was awesome.“