50 Best Bakeries near Bexley

“I actually fell upon this bakery on Etsy and didn't realize they were only 20 mins from me. I ordered a box with 7 goodies every single one was phenomenal. Can't wait to go in person!“

“Kitties is my favorite coffee shop in Columbus. Great quality coffee, nice outdoor seating and the best cinnamon rolls in town. My daughter loves their milk steamers. Right next to Gramercy bookstore which makes for a perfect afternoon.“

“This is the second birthday cake I've received via Fate Cake and they were both amazing. delicious cake and icing along with lovely decorations. couldn't ask for more.“

“amazing service and amazing treats.“

“For the past week Ive been seeing the cookie ad, tonight I gave in! Hopped in the car and got cupcakes and cookies! Got the stuffed french toast cupcake...YUMMY! So far have tried the cinnamon roll cookie and I will definitely be back for more! Better than Crumbl!!!“

“My husband picked up a variety of mini cheesecakes yesterday for my son's birthday dessert request and they were all delicious! Thank you for the yummy treat 🩷“

“delicious bubble tea 🧋 great desserts, waffles, and ramen“

“Finally my son bought sourdough bread today. That is I want. I am so happy to find a nice backery . I really like it so much“

“Every item we bought was amazing! We spent $90 on our first trip because we wanted to try everything and not a single thing disappointed.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5/5 – Crumbl Grove City truly saved the night!

I can’t thank the team at Crumbl Cookie in Grove City enough! I had placed a large, last-minute order after another company cancelled on me unexpectedly, and Crumbl absolutely came through. Not only were they incredibly kind and accommodating, but they prepared and delivered fresh, warm, delicious cookies right on time.

They turned a stressful situation into a great experience, and everyone at my event loved the cookies. The customer service was amazing, the communication was fast, and the quality was perfect.

Highly recommend this location; they really go above and beyond. Thank you, Crumbl Grove City, for saving the night! 🍪💕“

“The gluten free brownies are amazing!! The best I’ve had! And fantastic customer service! This is a great business, can’t wait to order more!“

“I have nothing bad to say about anything I tried! This was my first time here and I will definitely be back! I got the brown sugar pop tart, blondie, coffee cake muffin, brown sugar rice crispy treat, and an oatmeal cream pie! The blondie was my absolute favorite! It was sprinkled with coarse salt on top which made the seert flavor that much more pronounced! Nice and crumbly and soft! The oatmeal cream pie was fabulous! Reminded me of my childhood! The icing in the coffee cake muffin follows me into my dreams! It was soooo rich but not overpowering! The rice crispy treat was the least sweet I think, which was perfect because I ate it last definitely appreciated the flavor as opposed to the sweetness! Can't wait to try more items!“

“I purchased the regular and cinnamon biscuit mixes and they were both super easy to make and tasted amazing!! I will definitely be buying more!“

“Not only are the cookies fantastic, the customer service is as well. I ordered cookies from the Worthington location to be delivered for a birthday. Due to a snag in the ordering system, the order was canceled. I sent an email and in return received a phone call from Katie, the store’s shift leader. She called not once but 3 times to make sure the order was corrected—- and credited! Staff even added a dozen extra cookies! In addition, another employee,Ashley, took it upon herself to make sure the cookies were delivered asap. I also received an email from the company’s customer care representative later in the day to apologize. Top notch customer service. Thank you.“

“You know you are loved when you come home from work and there is a Pattycake pink bakery box on the counter. A lemon cupcake ended the day in the most perfect way. Thank you for being AWESOME bakers! I love everything that I have had over the years.“

“And!!! It’s a nice convenient walk from downtown with your little one. My Roma literally walks me there for a treat. If you love your dog like I love mine this is the go to! The quality and ingredients are 💯“

“Love this place! I ordered several large trays for an event and had the warmest family experience. I really appreciate the dedication and feel happy to support this local business. I ordered Gharaiba, Basbousas, Choc. Baklava, and Beluriah baklava. All were a HUGE hit!“

“It is great it tastes good and the service is fast

Vegetarian options: All of them

Dietary restrictions: There is not many

Parking: It is great

Kid-friendliness: It is good

Wheelchair accessibility: You can fit a wheelchair in there“

“We hosted our wedding reception at Mozarts in their ballroom and could not be happier. They’re so helpful, accommodating, and the space is absolutely beautiful. Such a beautiful hidden gem in columbus. The all inclusive reception options and over the top service cannot be beat!“

“Not only are the cookies fantastic, the customer service is as well. I ordered cookies from the Worthington location to be delivered for a birthday. Due to a snag in the ordering system, the order was canceled. I sent an email and in return received a phone call from Katie, the store’s shift leader. She called not once but 3 times to make sure the order was corrected—- and credited! Staff even added a dozen extra cookies! In addition, another employee,Ashley, took it upon herself to make sure the cookies were delivered asap. I also received an email from the company’s customer care representative later in the day to apologize. Top notch customer service. Thank you.“

“The Poptarts Are The Best Thing Ever Made Fr They Are So Good! I haven’t never tasted anything like it til I tried them. I am waiting For them to open in Grandview So I get A Buckeye One (Buckeyes are my thing and never got to try that favor yet) But So Good“

“We used Mrs. Goodman's for our wedding cake last month. We gave them the inspiration pics posted below along with 2 photos of our wedding cake (the photos with the topper on it). We wanted the white roses from the one cake but the greenery from the other. We didn't get to see the cake until cake cutting due to my parents picking up for us. WE WERE BLOWN AWAY!! They did so so well. It looked so amazing and tasted even better. They were also very affordable. Michele helped us go through the process and she was very friendly, professional, and helpful. We give them 12/10. Please choose Mrs. Goodman's for your wedding cake or any sweet treat. They are such a joy to work with!“

“Three Bites is my favorite bakery in Columbus!“

“The food was quality, but could have more flavor. The service was friendly, but could have a bit more forwardness by welcoming you as you come in the door and asking if you have ever been there and offering assistance with how everything works, rather than the customer feeling confused and having to ask. The atmosphere is clean and seems well managed, it just needs to be a bit more polished. It is a bit pricey, however, in the correct demographics it will do well. If the flavors of the week were posted in the window with a large bold font, so it can be seen while driving by it would bring more traffic through their doors.“

“For my wife’s birthday this month I wanted to get her a cheesecake that wasn’t off the shelf. The cheese cake was amazing to the point my wife said it’s best she’s ever had. Will be going back.“

“Excellent pastry and awesome service!!!“

“love this place! the blueberry lemon loaf is amazing and the owners are so sweet here 🥰“

“Best cannolis we have ever had. And the lobster tail was amazing!“

“Challah rolls my all time favorite in this city“

“This bakery is a gem. Everything I’ve tried has been fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. The red velvet cupcakes and glaze cake donuts are great and there’s always a great variety to choose from. The staff is friendly and welcoming, which makes the whole experience even better.“

“It’s the best I’ve had in desserts“

“We were looking for a last minute cake for the 2 year old in our life. This bakery was recommended a while ago on a Facebook page so I thought we’d give it a try after looking at what they offered. The staff was amazing and made sure they asked if it was for a birthday. They put a chocolate ‘Happy Birthday’ candy on top and gave us candles, a cake cutter and matches. Really a thoughtful gift to help celebrate her birthday. She LOVED the chocolate cloud cake since it mixed her favorites both berries and chocolate. We can’t wait to go back and try the other yummy options.“

“Amazing homemade pies. I went big and got 3 because who doesn’t need 3 whole pies?! The French meat pie is everything you want it to be. Had it for dinner twice with 4 people so it goes a long way. The chess pie was delicious and I loved adding fresh fruit to it. The crusts on both are amazing. The next up is the cinnamon apple pie which I froze and will reheat!
Owner was super friendly and welcomed us in her home. We will definitely be back for more!

Edit: I came back for more. The chicken pot pie is amazing. Loved everything about it. The blueberry pie is phenomenal. I feel like really good blueberry desserts are hard to find and this one might be my favorite so far! I would upload a photo, but all the pies disappear so fast…“

“Drive 25 min out of my way to get my order because it was the only Crumbl that had the Dubai cookie. After receiving my order, once I got back to my car, I realized one cookie in my order was without icing. It’s the second time this has happened. I don’t submit the order so when they showed me the box I assumed it was all correct. Regardless how does an employee see the non icing cookie and realize it’s not right? The other cookies were fine. But good grief, get your orders correct.“

“These folks are wonderful!!! I ordered Bundtinis for our family Easter celebration. Only problem is that I ordered them for a week earlier then I should have so when I went to pick them up I did not have an order. The manager was so kind and put together an assortment for me. I know they are going to be delicious!!!! Thank you so much!!!“

“Great food. Don’t miss out. Trust me, you really want to eat here. I’m a pretty harsh critic and I LOVED it. Will be back soon. If carbs didn’t make people fat, I would eat here at least once a week.“

“1/2 the cookies disappeared by my hubby and child before I could get home!! Delicious! Snafu with the mail on our last order and upon finding out the amazing owner promptly sent a new order. Highly recommend company and product!!“

“Her bakery is simply outstanding! I have been ordering for several years, and every time, the cakes and pastries are a showstopper at our parties. The quality, taste, and presentation are always top-notch. Beyond the delicious treats, the customer service is exceptional—friendly, professional, and always reliable. Highly recommend for anyone looking“

“they're kind and always quick. I've been coming here for years to get my fresh strawberry cake and I won't go anywhere else!! ❤️“

“Un trabajo hermoso muchas gracias todos mis invitados les encantó el pastel de los 15 lo recomiendo muchísimo y muy delicioso gracias otra vez que Dios la Bendiga“

“Kitties is my favorite coffee shop in Columbus. Great quality coffee, nice outdoor seating and the best cinnamon rolls in town. My daughter loves their milk steamers. Right next to Gramercy bookstore which makes for a perfect afternoon.“

“The egg sandwich is truly amazing. Perfect!!!“

“Beautiful / tasty cakes and cupcakes and friendly service!“

“Just had a delicious and beautifully decorated cake from the Goodie Shop! We loved it!“

“Awesome! We'll done Eban's!“

“I have been here many times. The customer service is the best! This is my only local store now that Happy Hostess is sold and no longer a baking store. I sure hope Cake Craft stays around for a long time. I would like it to carry the 5lb. bags of confectioners sugar. I also LOVED the Happy Hostess chocolate supply. Clasen's is a favorite! And the decorations-colors of sugars, and jimmies. Special original jimmies combinations were great.“

“Always super clean and smells really good in there! All their stuff is cheap and they give you a lot, plus you can ask for samples!! They also have a free table for anyone affected by the whole snap benefits thing!! All the employees are always super nice and I'd definitely recommend coming here.“

“Great customer service. Very friendly. Cake was reasonably priced and looks absolutely amazing!!!“

“My favorite place in Columbus. I haven't been here in 25 years, but if you love their products this is THE place to shop. Yes, check the expiration dates, but the oldest dates are the cheapest. I've found Goldfish Crackers to still be good after expiration, so those are what I always bought.

And just today I found out that there are stores in San Antonio and Houston, but they're both over two hours away from my home. But next road trip I've got new destinations 😁“