50 Best Bakeries near Worthington

“Not only are the cookies fantastic, the customer service is as well. I ordered cookies from the Worthington location to be delivered for a birthday. Due to a snag in the ordering system, the order was canceled. I sent an email and in return received a phone call from Katie, the store’s shift leader. She called not once but 3 times to make sure the order was corrected—- and credited! Staff even added a dozen extra cookies! In addition, another employee,Ashley, took it upon herself to make sure the cookies were delivered asap. I also received an email from the company’s customer care representative later in the day to apologize. Top notch customer service. Thank you.“

“We used Mrs. Goodman's for our wedding cake last month. We gave them the inspiration pics posted below along with 2 photos of our wedding cake (the photos with the topper on it). We wanted the white roses from the one cake but the greenery from the other. We didn't get to see the cake until cake cutting due to my parents picking up for us. WE WERE BLOWN AWAY!! They did so so well. It looked so amazing and tasted even better. They were also very affordable. Michele helped us go through the process and she was very friendly, professional, and helpful. We give them 12/10. Please choose Mrs. Goodman's for your wedding cake or any sweet treat. They are such a joy to work with!“

“Love her cakes and creativity!“

“I love Kitties. I am so happy they are in our neighborhood. The coffee is excellent. They have matcha which is excellent and the baked goods are so incredibly delicious. The only problem is they are really really good. I will buy a delicious scone with the idea of sharing it and I ALWAYS eat the whole thing. It's like I can't stop it is so good. Everyone is nice and helpful and the food and beverages are spectacular.“

“Family owned and top notch every time! Always 10/10“

“This is the second birthday cake I've received via Fate Cake and they were both amazing. delicious cake and icing along with lovely decorations. couldn't ask for more.“

“Every item we bought was amazing! We spent $90 on our first trip because we wanted to try everything and not a single thing disappointed.“

“my dad brought this for our get together. Fantastic bakery desserts.“

“THE BEST BAKERY HOME MADE ITEMS“

“amazing service and amazing treats.“

“Great place!!! BUT REALLY MISS THEM OPENING AT 1 AM !! I’m sure a lot of people feel the same“

“Finally my son bought sourdough bread today. That is I want. I am so happy to find a nice backery . I really like it so much“

“Review for Crumbl Cookies in Hilliard

I recently ordered Crumbl Cookies for the entire faculty and staff at CAEC PreK-12, and I couldn’t be more impressed with the experience! From the moment I reached out, Misha at Crumbl became the perfect outsourced partner. She took the time to explain all the various dessert options and, in a thoughtful touch, took it upon herself to choose a diverse selection of cookies to cater to everyone’s tastes.

The cookies were not only a hit—they were an absolute standout! The quality was exceptional, with each cookie fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. Whether you like classic chocolate chip or something a bit more adventurous, Crumbl had the perfect option for everyone.

Misha’s customer service truly went above and beyond, making the whole process smooth and stress-free. It’s rare to find such dedication and care in service, and I’m grateful for how easy she made this experience.

I highly recommend Crumbl Cookies in Hilliard for any event, big or small. They nailed it!

Thank you again, Misha, and the team at Crumbl for making our faculty and staff feel appreciated and for delivering such an amazing treat!“

“Absolutely amazing southern biscuits!!!! So easy to make Just follow the directions provided My gluten eating family prefers Daddy-O biscuits to regular gluten biscuits Been coming back again and again for over a year“

“Not only are the cookies fantastic, the customer service is as well. I ordered cookies from the Worthington location to be delivered for a birthday. Due to a snag in the ordering system, the order was canceled. I sent an email and in return received a phone call from Katie, the store’s shift leader. She called not once but 3 times to make sure the order was corrected—- and credited! Staff even added a dozen extra cookies! In addition, another employee,Ashley, took it upon herself to make sure the cookies were delivered asap. I also received an email from the company’s customer care representative later in the day to apologize. Top notch customer service. Thank you.“

“Crumbl… Perimeter loop. I thank you all so much for your kind Efficient service… Everyone is always so helpful. I often run in to grab large orders for my different accounts and everyone is always so welcoming. I have been to numerous locations Nationwide and it seems as if you all go above and beyond every time without fail thank you thank you thank you.“

“You know you are loved when you come home from work and there is a Pattycake pink bakery box on the counter. A lemon cupcake ended the day in the most perfect way. Thank you for being AWESOME bakers! I love everything that I have had over the years.“

“Love this place! I ordered several large trays for an event and had the warmest family experience. I really appreciate the dedication and feel happy to support this local business. I ordered Gharaiba, Basbousas, Choc. Baklava, and Beluriah baklava. All were a HUGE hit!“

“Great place! The best macarons around Columbus, an amazing choice of French delicacy, and, above all, the most welcoming and delightful owner! Always a pleasure to pass by!“

“Enjoyed the cupcake. Good flavor on the sweet side. Not huge cupcake but felt priced right. Unfortunately, was there late on a Saturday so selection was limited, which I guess shows how popular this place is. Very nice and comfortable interior with incredible customer service. Would really have liked a larger drink menu. Would have enjoyed sitting down with a cup of coffee.“

“It is great it tastes good and the service is fast

Vegetarian options: All of them

Dietary restrictions: There is not many

Parking: It is great

Kid-friendliness: It is good

Wheelchair accessibility: You can fit a wheelchair in there“

“Best place in town. great service always!!“

“We hosted our wedding reception at Mozarts in their ballroom and could not be happier. They’re so helpful, accommodating, and the space is absolutely beautiful. Such a beautiful hidden gem in columbus. The all inclusive reception options and over the top service cannot be beat!“

“The Poptarts Are The Best Thing Ever Made Fr They Are So Good! I haven’t never tasted anything like it til I tried them. I am waiting For them to open in Grandview So I get A Buckeye One (Buckeyes are my thing and never got to try that favor yet) But So Good“

“Three Bites is my favorite bakery in Columbus!“

“Best cannolis we have ever had. And the lobster tail was amazing!“

“Beehive continues its legacy as a high-quality local business! I have to say that everything from here is amazing and they always deliver on those classic food traditions during the seasons/holidays!“

“For my wife’s birthday this month I wanted to get her a cheesecake that wasn’t off the shelf. The cheese cake was amazing to the point my wife said it’s best she’s ever had. Will be going back.“

“I actually fell upon this bakery on Etsy and didn't realize they were only 20 mins from me. I ordered a box with 7 goodies every single one was phenomenal. Can't wait to go in person!“

“So far I've had a banana cream pie and peach pie, as well as a chicken pot pie.
Both desert pies were excellent. Instead of the typical coin slices of bananas you typically see in a banana cream, this had long, thick slices of banana, ensuring plenty of just the right amount of ripeness. The cream was light, fluffy and flavorful.
The peach pie was loaded with ripe, but not mushy, peaches in a filling that was sweet, but not overwhelming. The crust was crisp and flakes with no hint of a soggy bottom.
The chicken pot pie had plenty of nice chunks of chicken and plenty of vegetables in a thick, but not pasty, gravy.
The only issue I had was that the bake time for the pot pie was insufficient for my oven. While the top crust was a little browned, the bottom and sides crust was just raw dough.
I did buy another pot pie and will try to adjust my baking time to see.if I can get it right.
Service was wonderful. Both times that I've been in, the employees were pleasant and friendly.
I will definitely be trying out their other pies in the future.“

“Fantastic experience. Best tea experience in Columbus.“

“Excellent pastry and awesome service!!!“

“It’s the best I’ve had in desserts“

“I always come here and the cookies are always amazing but today they were overcooked and dry. But other than today they are always so good and i 100% recommend!!“

“Challah rolls my all time favorite in this city“

“We were looking for a last minute cake for the 2 year old in our life. This bakery was recommended a while ago on a Facebook page so I thought we’d give it a try after looking at what they offered. The staff was amazing and made sure they asked if it was for a birthday. They put a chocolate ‘Happy Birthday’ candy on top and gave us candles, a cake cutter and matches. Really a thoughtful gift to help celebrate her birthday. She LOVED the chocolate cloud cake since it mixed her favorites both berries and chocolate. We can’t wait to go back and try the other yummy options.“

“🎉🍓 Celebrating another year of life with something sweet!

Today we blew out the candles with a delicious strawberry birthday cake from Paris Baguette, and it was simply perfect. 🎂✨
The sponge cake was incredibly soft, the cream was light, and the fresh strawberries gave it that perfect balance between sweet and refreshing. Every bite tasted like a celebration.

If you're looking for a beautiful, elegant, and truly delicious cake for a birthday, this was definitely a great choice. 💕

Cheers to another year filled with special moments, laughter, and great desserts! 🥳🍰“

“Placed a last minute order online, her online system glitched and wasn’t meant to allow anymore orders to come through. Being a business owner myself I understand technology is great when it wants to work haha. She was still able to accommodate my pie which I was beyond grateful for. Can’t wait to give this pie a try I just know it is going to be fantastic!“

“I highly recommend the Cupcakery. I did extensive research (tastings!), received many quotes and decided on them based on their great flavor. I could not have asked for better people to work with planning a covid wedding. I am thankful for their flexibility and support. The cake and cupcakes the day of tasted SO GOOD! The lighted display was worth every penny. I am beyond happy with my choice!!! Thank you thank you thank you!!! Cant wait for my anniversary cake!“

“Had to take my sweet baby to visit Miss Mimi today since she turns 5 on Tuesday. As always, we were greeted enthusiastically by name and Miss Mimi made her day extra special! Bumbles is such a special place for my youngest and they have the best chocolate chip cookies!“

“These folks are wonderful!!! I ordered Bundtinis for our family Easter celebration. Only problem is that I ordered them for a week earlier then I should have so when I went to pick them up I did not have an order. The manager was so kind and put together an assortment for me. I know they are going to be delicious!!!! Thank you so much!!!“

“Great food. Don’t miss out. Trust me, you really want to eat here. I’m a pretty harsh critic and I LOVED it. Will be back soon. If carbs didn’t make people fat, I would eat here at least once a week.“

“they're kind and always quick. I've been coming here for years to get my fresh strawberry cake and I won't go anywhere else!! ❤️“

“What a wonderful place!!!!! I am celiac, and being have to have this level of delicious baking that dos not crumble into a million pieces, or taste like cardboard is basically like winning the lottery. It is all so good, this is highly recommended if you are gluten free/celiac. I wish I had one closer to Canada where I am from. Cant wait to come back and taste more goodies one day.“

“I'd been looking forward to visiting this very specialized pierogi 🥟 place for a long time, and was so happy to finally be able to on a trip our family went on. Never any way for us to be able to try all the wonderful rotating flavors, and unfortunately missed a couple of the specialized flavors for her birthday week, but was thankful for what I could try. All amazing 😍. Very well combined ingredients, obviously created with love and devotion. Not to mention the fact that they are near well the size of the average palm of your hand. Well worth everything. And Lizz is just a sweet as the title. 🙂 If pierogi 🥟 are one of your favorite things in the world, then never miss this Sweet Columbus Ohio gem!“

“Kitties is my favorite coffee shop in Columbus. Great quality coffee, nice outdoor seating and the best cinnamon rolls in town. My daughter loves their milk steamers. Right next to Gramercy bookstore which makes for a perfect afternoon.“

“Un trabajo hermoso muchas gracias todos mis invitados les encantó el pastel de los 15 lo recomiendo muchísimo y muy delicioso gracias otra vez que Dios la Bendiga“

“We order our king cake from here every year, and our family loves the different fillings and the delicious flavors! More than worth the 40-minute round trip drive. Looking forward to trying more baked goods the next time we make it back :)“

“Beautiful / tasty cakes and cupcakes and friendly service!“

“I have order numerous times from them, and the cookies are so fresh and amazing taste. I keep order them. even after 2 months they still have that fresh taste. Very addictive you can't just have one. I am due to order more from them that is how delicious they are. I highly reccommend this place if you need cookies ordered.“