11 Best Bakeries in Westerville

“Great place!!! BUT REALLY MISS THEM OPENING AT 1 AM !! I’m sure a lot of people feel the same“

“So far I've had a banana cream pie and peach pie, as well as a chicken pot pie.
Both desert pies were excellent. Instead of the typical coin slices of bananas you typically see in a banana cream, this had long, thick slices of banana, ensuring plenty of just the right amount of ripeness. The cream was light, fluffy and flavorful.
The peach pie was loaded with ripe, but not mushy, peaches in a filling that was sweet, but not overwhelming. The crust was crisp and flakes with no hint of a soggy bottom.
The chicken pot pie had plenty of nice chunks of chicken and plenty of vegetables in a thick, but not pasty, gravy.
The only issue I had was that the bake time for the pot pie was insufficient for my oven. While the top crust was a little browned, the bottom and sides crust was just raw dough.
I did buy another pot pie and will try to adjust my baking time to see.if I can get it right.
Service was wonderful. Both times that I've been in, the employees were pleasant and friendly.
I will definitely be trying out their other pies in the future.“

“The food was quality, but could have more flavor. The service was friendly, but could have a bit more forwardness by welcoming you as you come in the door and asking if you have ever been there and offering assistance with how everything works, rather than the customer feeling confused and having to ask. The atmosphere is clean and seems well managed, it just needs to be a bit more polished. It is a bit pricey, however, in the correct demographics it will do well. If the flavors of the week were posted in the window with a large bold font, so it can be seen while driving by it would bring more traffic through their doors.“

“The BEST pierogies we've ever had! They are so big and the price you pay for them is very reasonable for the size. Paired with the garlic dill sour cream - chefs kiss. Liz is so kind, sweet, and humble & it feels so homey when you walk in and see her husband and children working as a team with her. I eye her insta page weekly to see what kind of goodies shes cookin up.“

“Highest quality coffee in Columbus,“

“We were so impressed with our eggless mixed fruit cake! Before the wedding, I asked if we could do a tasting, and she went above and beyond by custom-making a cake with two different flavors for us to try before we made our final decision.

The wedding cake was absolutely amazing. It was incredibly moist, fresh, and full of delicious fruit flavor. Everyone at our wedding loved it and could not stop talking about how wonderful it was. She truly delivered, and the cake exceeded our expectations. We are so grateful and would highly recommend this bakery!“

“I usually come to this location a few times a year. Always love the bread and have gotten good service. But today I went in and Joy helped me and was truly just amazing. So kind, great energy, and I just left feeling really GOOD. It really made me want to come back more often because I walked in and she treated me like family.

Today I got a pepperoni roll and some of the scones/cinnamon rolls. All incredible! I got to try a sample of the cheese/garlic bread and will absolutely get a loaf of that next time. Very good!“

“Hired last minute and it was incredible! Will definitely be hiring again :)“

“Sue at Le Gateau is absolutely phenomenal at making and designing wedding cakes. She incorporated our style and suggestions into the design and it was more beautiful than I could have ever imagined. She is a true professional who takes pride in her work, understands the importance of quality and ensures that every last detail is perfect and delicious. I am so thankful that my friend, who hired Sue for her wedding, recommended her business to us. For our wedding cake, it served 230 people (4 tiers) with Italian cream cake with strawberry filling, orange cake with chocolate ganache filling, and chocolate cake with raspberry filling covered in iced buttercream frosting...might I add, all made from SCRATCH. We received so many compliments from our guests about how excellent our cake was!“

“I needed a last-minute gluten-free cake at the end of the day, and I was not disappointed! The employee behind the counter was extremely friendly and efficient. She iced the cake in five minutes.

I chose the lemon raspberry gluten-free cake… DELICIOUS. Everyone at the party loved it and commented that you would never guess it’s gluten-free. The cake was beautiful, the flavors were so bright, and the icing was deceivingly light and very tasty.
I will definitely be coming back for my next gluten-free cake!“

“Great experience with Maddie. Highly recommend this place. 10/10“