50 Best Bakeries near New Albany

“These Greek pastries are not only delicious but are artfully created. Cia has developed some amazing items using quality ingredients and making unbelievable desserts.We have tried many of her delicacies but our favorite is Melomakarona. She prepares them plain or dipped. They just melt in your mouth!Her packaging of items for gifts is super. She takes great care in the presentation.Donnajean deSilva“

“Great pastries and coffee and atmosphere“

“This is the second birthday cake I've received via Fate Cake and they were both amazing. delicious cake and icing along with lovely decorations. couldn't ask for more.“

“THE BEST BAKERY HOME MADE ITEMS“

“They had one gluten free chocolate cupcake left. I got to pick the topping and they were able to do the peanut butter one. It was AMAZING! Did not taste GF at all. 10/10 recommend!“

“Great place!!! BUT REALLY MISS THEM OPENING AT 1 AM !! I’m sure a lot of people feel the same“

“It is great it tastes good and the service is fast

Vegetarian options: All of them

Dietary restrictions: There is not many

Parking: It is great

Kid-friendliness: It is good

Wheelchair accessibility: You can fit a wheelchair in there“

“The food was quality, but could have more flavor. The service was friendly, but could have a bit more forwardness by welcoming you as you come in the door and asking if you have ever been there and offering assistance with how everything works, rather than the customer feeling confused and having to ask. The atmosphere is clean and seems well managed, it just needs to be a bit more polished. It is a bit pricey, however, in the correct demographics it will do well. If the flavors of the week were posted in the window with a large bold font, so it can be seen while driving by it would bring more traffic through their doors.“

“For my wife’s birthday this month I wanted to get her a cheesecake that wasn’t off the shelf. The cheese cake was amazing to the point my wife said it’s best she’s ever had. Will be going back.“

“I actually fell upon this bakery on Etsy and didn't realize they were only 20 mins from me. I ordered a box with 7 goodies every single one was phenomenal. Can't wait to go in person!“

“So far I've had a banana cream pie and peach pie, as well as a chicken pot pie.
Both desert pies were excellent. Instead of the typical coin slices of bananas you typically see in a banana cream, this had long, thick slices of banana, ensuring plenty of just the right amount of ripeness. The cream was light, fluffy and flavorful.
The peach pie was loaded with ripe, but not mushy, peaches in a filling that was sweet, but not overwhelming. The crust was crisp and flakes with no hint of a soggy bottom.
The chicken pot pie had plenty of nice chunks of chicken and plenty of vegetables in a thick, but not pasty, gravy.
The only issue I had was that the bake time for the pot pie was insufficient for my oven. While the top crust was a little browned, the bottom and sides crust was just raw dough.
I did buy another pot pie and will try to adjust my baking time to see.if I can get it right.
Service was wonderful. Both times that I've been in, the employees were pleasant and friendly.
I will definitely be trying out their other pies in the future.“

“Excellent pastry and awesome service!!!“

“Challah rolls my all time favorite in this city“

“I had a great experience with Resch Bakery! I ordered a 1/2 sheet cake, and it turned out perfect. The cake was fresh, soft, and tasted really good—not too sweet, just right. The design looked beautiful and exactly how I wanted it. The staff were friendly and helpful when I placed my order. Everything went smoothly, and I was very happy with the result.“

“We asked Lori to make our cake for our wedding. She was very helpful and our cake turned out just as we envisioned. She arrived on time for the wedding, and the cake tasted wonderful. It received many compliments from our guests as well. Thanks, Lori!“

“Great food. Don’t miss out. Trust me, you really want to eat here. I’m a pretty harsh critic and I LOVED it. Will be back soon. If carbs didn’t make people fat, I would eat here at least once a week.“

“Un trabajo hermoso muchas gracias todos mis invitados les encantó el pastel de los 15 lo recomiendo muchísimo y muy delicioso gracias otra vez que Dios la Bendiga“

“Her bakery is simply outstanding! I have been ordering for several years, and every time, the cakes and pastries are a showstopper at our parties. The quality, taste, and presentation are always top-notch. Beyond the delicious treats, the customer service is exceptional—friendly, professional, and always reliable. Highly recommend for anyone looking“

“Awesome! We'll done Eban's!“

“I have tried an assortment of items from this bakery and they are all excellent! I would order every single one again. I have had their cinnamon bread, pepper and parmesan bread, pepperoni roll, pumpkin muffin, and fruit bar and can't wait to try more. The service is friendly and kind and informative. Great experience all around, every time!“

“I placed a mid sized corporate order. It was the 3 tiered bundtlette towers. So many combinations to choose from. The team really help me with the messages and decorative ribbon. Customer service was 2nd to none and the cakes always amaze!“

“This cake was absolutely phenomenal! Down to the flavor which was perfectly balanced, the texture was incredibly moist and fluffy, Every bite was a pure delight, I mean every little element was so perfect. however this bakery is a true gem! I’ll personally will be back very soon And not to mention the service was great ! !👏👏“

“Venden los panes mas deliciosos que he encontrado en Columbus Ohio“

“I absolutely love those pretzels they have the best pretzels for the best price is the only reason I didn’t get five stars is because they said that they were open until 10 and then they closed at 8:30 when I got there so I was very unpleased with that because if I would’ve known that I would have gotten the pretzels before we went shopping. We got done at 8:30 and they were closed when it clearly says open until 10pm“

“Born and raised in the Schenectady county, I grew up LOVING Freigofers! For the love of me I can’t remember the name of my favorite cinnamon rolls they made. I believe they had a cinnamon/ sugar crumble maybe like pecan or something crushed up with it on the top! Does anybody remember the name of those cinnamon rolls? Or a recipe? I crave them monthly.“

“**Best Tres Leches Cake in Columbus!**

My wife and I were so excited to find La Campiña, and wow, we haven’t had Tres Leches this good in ages! A neighbor recommended it to us, and they were spot on! The owner is super friendly and welcoming, and the prices are really reasonable too. I honestly wish more people knew about this hidden gem. From now on, this is our go-to spot for birthday cakes and any special event. Oh, and the freshly baked bread? Absolutely amazing“

“Absolutely what I was hoping for and knew I’d get once I FINALLY got the cake I’ve been drooling over for three years! Kennetha made my 40 birthday that much sweeter with an amazing chocolate ganache cake. 🤤 thank you!“

“Hired last minute and it was incredible! Will definitely be hiring again :)“

“Kitties is my favorite coffee shop in Columbus. Great quality coffee, nice outdoor seating and the best cinnamon rolls in town. My daughter loves their milk steamers. Right next to Gramercy bookstore which makes for a perfect afternoon.“

“Highest quality coffee in Columbus,“

“Cake Craft moved across 161 the the northern edge of the big shopping center. The owner told me the owner of their old location won't let her post a sign there, and the old address is still in Apple Maps. If you're looking for it, go across 161 to the far Northwest side of the big shopping center.“

“Very tasty and cute cupcakes for my baby shower that coworkers surprised me with! If I need anything in the future I’ll order here“

“Sue at Le Gateau is absolutely phenomenal at making and designing wedding cakes. She incorporated our style and suggestions into the design and it was more beautiful than I could have ever imagined. She is a true professional who takes pride in her work, understands the importance of quality and ensures that every last detail is perfect and delicious. I am so thankful that my friend, who hired Sue for her wedding, recommended her business to us. For our wedding cake, it served 230 people (4 tiers) with Italian cream cake with strawberry filling, orange cake with chocolate ganache filling, and chocolate cake with raspberry filling covered in iced buttercream frosting...might I add, all made from SCRATCH. We received so many compliments from our guests about how excellent our cake was!“

“reviews are correct, if your product is ready they will usually load you early, there is some parking but if you park on street you risk a ticket NO PARKING signs everywhere nice polite people quick load! been here a few times usually a good experience“

“Amazing! Pre ordered and showed up a little early, the store was busy and still managed to welcome us in, inform us of a slight wait and all with smiling faces! Still took them less time than I was quoted and everything was delicious and packaged nice!!“

“I have been a long time lover of Cheryl’s cookies as my mom introduced me to them when she helped Cheryl start her first company. My mom was in banking ironically her name is also Cheryl! When I found out she started a new company, I was ecstatic to try her cookies! And let me tell you, Cheryl has completely outdone herself!“

“We received these at my office for Christmas this year! Cannot say enough great things about your brownies and such! Every single one was so good, it is hard to pick a favorite, so I won’t!! We enjoyed them all and will order more for us and others!!“

“This is a lovely bakery. I buy their Bundt cake’s for the residents birthday’s, and they love them! This is a must try!“

“I went to Paris Baguette in Easton for the first time this morning! I wanted a pastry of some kind. I had a hard time making up my mind because they had a very nice selection of awesome-looking pastries. Finally, I settled on the Bombolone which is an Italian doughnut. It was THE VERY BEST doughnut I have ever had! Very freshly baked, slightly crisp on the outside, coated with chocolate frosting on the outside and plenty of some kind of delicious chocolate filling on the inside! It's pricey, but we're talking about very high quality baked goods. And, by the way, it was a very pleasant atmosphere! I definitely will be going back!“

“A great Auntie Anne’s at the first floor of Easton Town center. They usually serve some samples. I like their pleasant pretzel smell spreading over the room. Service is friendly and not slow. Pretzel nuggets are always delicious with or without hotdogs. Smoothies are great too.“

“Nice place and great store to shop“

“Great experience with Maddie. Highly recommend this place. 10/10“