38 Best American Restaurants near Buckeye Lake

“We visited today for the first time. It was absolutely amazing from the walk in to the walk out! Not only the food but the hospitality. I highly recommend this little place! We will definitely be back. Thank you for amazing service!!“

“We had set meals today. Steak was well delivered, prawn bisque perfectly done and choc lava cake with ice cream ok. They’ve been very generous with the portion.“

“Great food!! Amazing service!! Best atmosphere that I have had in a restaurant. Highly recommend, right now they are only open until 1:30, so go for breakfast or lunch.“

“wonderful food, great atmosphere and kind staff! haddock and onion petals are the way to go! all the food looks yummy!“

“I’ve lived on the lake for over 20 years and still visit every week! My husband and I LOVE the Island House and always have amazing customer service! We also bring our kids and they have the best time!“

“The fish and chips are amazing! The restaurant is cute and will remind you of Cape Cod. The staff is friendly and very attentive. I can’t wait to return and try something new.“

“What an amazing first time here! Laid back bar and restaurant. Kinda reminds me of a 50s style bar. Unfortunately no TVs. But have a good jukebox and lots of things to check out on the walls. Had the benji burger and it was fire. I give this place a 5 ⭐️ Oh and the beer 💯“

“The best !! Highly recommended !!“

“I stayed at the DoubleTree which is attached to the restaurant. I did carry-out. I got the meatloaf griller with Parmesan herb fries and brussel sprouts. They were all very delicious. I topped off my meal with a piece of their carrot cake. The carrot cake had caramel drizzle and whipped cream with a candied pecan on top. It was very rich! I spent $34 on the meal.The restaurant itself is a bar style set up with a few booths.There is a Starbucks attached to the hotel as well.“

“The quality of the food has went down. As if no one cares about the name anymore.“

“We've been coming here since they first moved downtown! the food is always fresh and hot! we try to come at least once a week and tell all our family and friends about them!“

“Great service awesome foot“

“Me and my daughter went to dinner tonight at 1922 and had a FABULOUS experience! Our waitress Emma, was hands down the main reason. Great service, great food, and super cute decor. Will be coming back, requesting Emma’s table of course :)“

“great spot! great beer and good food. Joe in the kitchen is the man!!! literally you can taste the difference when hes on the line. Chris on the pizza station makes a slappin pie too! love this place. show these boys some love !!! they deserve it“

“Great food,welcoming atmosphere and lovely servers!“

“Hebron locals came to visit during lunch time. Customer service was great and recommended the combo. Each items was so good! My 9 year old daughter got the Alex sandwich and loved it! Can't believe weve never been. Definitely will be going back!!“

“Love it!“

“Loved everything about the place!“

“This is the hidden gem for comfort food. Whether it's breakfast, lunch, or dinner they have what you're craving.

The atmosphere is a pub vibe which includes and outdoor patio.

I've eaten there several times and I can tell you it's all good.

My go to dishes are their chicken wings and thin crust pizzas.

The wait staff treats you like family and you leave with a smile. Give it a try, you won't be sorry.“

“A great place with good food and good people. I try to swing through anytime I'm in the area for work. The staff and locals all make you feel like one of them. Highly recommend!“

“Everyone knows the food is awesome here, but what is even better is the outstanding customer service! I didn't get the very nice lady's name, but I think she's one of the managers. She couldn't have been more help and it's service like her's that makes a customer come back over and over. She was working on 12/26 @ around 3:45pm. Whoever owns the place better keep her around....“

“Just stopped this evening and picked up a meat lovers pizza on way home from work , it was perfect you guys get it right every time. Thank you!“

“My filet was so tasty but slightly past MR. My husband had the big ribeye and said it was juicy and full of flavor. We both enjoyed our salads as well as the bread. Our onions were good but the sauce was lacking in flavor. We had the fire roasted corn which could have been roasted a little longer. I enjoy that roasted flavor. Our server was wonderful.“

“Good food. Good service. Resonably priced. Waiter was very good at his job. Took our drink order as soon as we were seated. Checked on us during our meal to make sure our meals were made to order. No problems at all except for my wife's dessert that wasn't no one's fault. She can't eat nuts right now because of some dental problems. No allergies to peanuts. She still ate the dessert and doing fine. Meals were both great. She had steak, mashed potatoes and green beans. I had the grilled cheese cheeseburger with squash. Very good ! Alexander did a great job.“

“Just had lunch there and it was fast service and delicious. The atmosphere was welcoming and the decor was adorable.“

“let me tell you if you have not been to Nanas & Papas you are missing out on good home cooked food. Wendy and Rose got it going on! THANK YOU ladys for yet another delicious meal.
October 2025 add sweet Jazzmyn to the list i love this place well worth you time coffee is Piping HOT“

“Best customer service ever. while there tonight, we had Ricky as our server, at first he seemed a little nervous with us, I'm not sure if he's new to the job, or had a not so good table before us, but he eventually warmed up to us, started joking with us, kept up on refills, checked in multiple times with us. towards the end of our meal, he asked if we wanted anything else, jokingly i said "a winning lottery ticket" as its very common to say when asked that. Ricky says "hold on a minute" grabs his wallet from his pocket, and hands me a winning scratch off lottery ticket. This is the first time ever with a long history of dining out that I have seen this happen. Ricky you are THE MAN, and if this review actually gets read by your management team, you deserve a raise!“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ A Hidden Gem by the Water! Beach House Pub is hands-down one of the best spots I’ve been to in a long time. The atmosphere is the perfect blend of laid-back beach vibes and cozy neighborhood charm. The staff is incredibly friendly and attentive — they make you feel like a regular from the moment you walk in. The food? Outstanding. I had the fish tacos and they were fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. Great selection of craft beers and cocktails too — the kind of menu that keeps you coming back to try something new each time. Whether you’re looking to unwind after a long day or meet up with friends for a casual night out, Beach House Pub nails it. Highly recommend it to anyone in the area — this place is a must-visit“

“As a member of the Guernsey Valley Old Car Club, I visited the restaurant today and enjoyed my meal. My only complaint was that the music, (I grew up in a musical family), was too loud for us to have much of a conversation during our visit. I will still definitely come back again.“

“One negative I have is when a customer orders something and it’s not done and when you say something to the employee they just the eyes they should make it right who wants to eat cold food“

“Always have a positive customer service experience and delicious meal here! The staff is friendly and helpful. I have been helped by Jennifer many times and she always make the effort to treat customers with kindness and a positive attitude. Great food, great value, great atmosphere.“

“My family absolutely loves Texas Roadhouse in Newark. The kids were so excited to go there tonight. My daughter and I both always order the 6oz and 8oz sirloin and my little one orders the bites. We were very disappointed to find out after our order came out that they were completely out of A1. We always eat A1 with our steak. My steak had zero seasoning. Yes I could have sent it back but for personal reasons that is not an option for me. The manager happen to come around as I was boxing up all our steak and was very apologetic and said that their shipment must have not arrived. I totally understand that things are delayed but we would have ordered something else if we had known.“

“Had a Great time tonite! August 8th 2025! Band North to Nashville was awesome. Our server Grace was fantastic! Food was good !“

“Emmerson our server was fantastic! You all should clone her!“

“Bob Evans has a vibe, doesn't matter which one you walk into they all have the same vibe. Kind of like a cracker barrel but more after church on Sunday. Cracker barrel is Bob Evans cousin that shoots dice but doesn't tell anybody, you know what I mean?

Rolls over biscuits. This is something that has ruined many a dinner conversation, but it has to be said. Also, the wildfire chicken salad is amazing highly recommend it. Building your own omelette and having a side of pancakes with it is something that reminds you what it's all about and when your kids ask for your leftovers you know you did a good job.“

“Thank you for treating us on Veterans day Good service & good food“

“just wanted to thank you ladies for the awesome Job that you do. thank you for the suggestions on the food it was definitely filling. thank you for a wonderful experience I know I had a great time and my brother, the same. thank you“