50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Carroll

“First time there, recommended by the young man who worked on our furnace this past week. Will definitely be back for more. Delish!!!!“

“Awesome place everyone did excellent job in makin sure r party enjoyed themself u all r awesome????“

“Best pizza in the entire WORLD“

“I love their Pizza Subs the best in town. There brownies are slammin too!“

“This is quite possibly the best meatball sub I have ever had! The flavors were bold, the extra cheese delivered. And the meatballs were well seasoned, tender and very tasty. The only reason I’m giving this restaurant a four is because my order through Uber eats only came with the sandwich not the cake or my beverage. But I can definitely look past that and will be ordering again for my next cheat meal.“

“Very good pizza! Friendly, clean, and quick service. We highly recommend!“

“Great pizza and wings! Highly recommend!“

“Mod Pizza on Hill Road in Pickerington is a great place to eat, it is wonderful to get what you order the way you order it with a friendly staff. You are greeted when you enter the restaurant and when you leave. A very enjoyable staff and eating out experience.“

“Love the pizza it really good“

“We ordered a monster sub and the meatballs with cheese yesterday about 730pm. We were next door for pool league, she told me 25 min for a sub and meatballs, I figured they were backed up for 25 min, I set timer and walked down 2 min before it went off, food was on rack, it obviously was sitting there for some time as the sub meat was COLD. My husband was so upset lol. The meatballs were the size of spaghettiO’s meatballs. The taste was there but the toddler size meatballs were shameful. We’ve gotten these a few times before and never ever were they this tiny To charge $9’for 6 of these is sinful lol Def turned off for awhile , be back at a much later date I sent a message last night before writing this. It’s still unanswered“

“Good food Good service Pizza was awesome!! I would highly recommend!!“

“My boyfriend and I went up over the weekend and they were packed! We had to wait for them to clean a table but we didn’t mind. Food came out so fast we couldn’t believe it since they were so busy. We will definitely be back! Sad it took us so long to find this hidden gem.“

“Nene and Ezekiel were awesome with the service they provided! It was a miscommunication of my order and they were so polite and respectful. I was amazed . They even gave me the pizza that I didn’t order for free ! I thank you guys for being so patient and respectful. The little things go so far. I’ll be back soon. And again thank you guys“

“Pizza was great, however the service wasn't the best. I wouldn't say the service was bad but it definitely didn't stand out to me and wasn't memorable which is the only way I give 5 stars for service. Same with atmosphere.“

“Always a great experience. Love they have my favorite salad dressing (honey french) and quality salad ingredients. Fantastic pizzas with a crispy crust thats chewy inside. Real chunks of bacon and cupping pepperoni. Staff is consistently amazing. Highly recommend.“

“We have eaten at a few others and you are up there with the best . Certainly much better than Lewis Center.“

“delivery in NC coast awesome pizza grew up with Massey pizza“

“My husband and I have eaten take out here several times. The food is fantastic!! Great pizza, Stromboli, pasta dishes. We used to live in Brooklyn, Ny, and Il Forno’s food is as good as the best pizza place that we ever ate at in NY. Il Forno is the best pizza in town by far!“

“sweetest owners and workers. food and boba drinks were amazing!“

“Great service & great pizza!“

“We just moved to the neighborhood.. a Saturday night.. we call you deliver to us.. awesome pizza we definitely be ordering again!“

“We moved into the area. I was looking for a great pizza place. We don't like too many chain pizza places. But I can tell you that we absolutely love this locations, pizzas and sandwiches. We got there close to closing. And treated us like we were their first customers“

“Best pizza around“

“Stopped in after a track meet with my track team as we stopped to grab some things for the road back to Cleveland. The welcome from the owner was amazing and hospitality by Howard and other workers made us feel welcomed. Also the food was good pizza very delicious. Would recommend and would stop again. Thank you for the service.“

“Took my family to the e Restaurant and all the staff was very friendly. They made sure the food was out as soon as it was ready and our drinks were always filled. Love love love Cristy's East!!!“

“We had such a fantastic evening here! Food was great! Service was great! We’ll be back soon!“

“Extremely funny waitress Christiana. You can't train her personality. Very pleasing and enjoyable. Will visit again.“

“Came to Ohio (Dayton) over the weekend to attend a celebration of life service on Saturday and stayed in Baltimore at my sister & brother-in-law's place and was craving some good Ohio pizza. Pizza in Myrtle Beach (where I live) isn't the best, so my hopes were high and boy, did y'all knock it out of the park. Great cook, flavor and balance of sauce to toppings. Was quite pleased and will definitely order again when in town! Was a bit pricy for a medium, but would have been less if I drove the mile to pick up than have delivered :) Thanks for a great product!“

“Good very good food ppl nice“

“The worker was super friendly. Pizza and breadsticks were very good. Will definitely eat there again.“

“This is really a takeout or delivery business only in Pickerington Ohio. Everyone has their own favorite type of pizza taste. Strangely enough my favorite pizza is just to the east of the capital of Iceland. My destiny United States is MOD Pizza which is similar with a thinner crust and high quality fresh ingredients with a very friendly staff. But if I'm looking at what we consider we regularly find as pizza then Romeo's Pizza certainly is my favorite by far. The combination of crust taste and thickness as well as the overall flavor profile simply hits me as much more desirable than the other types I have tasted. Since this is decidedly a bit different the best thing to do is try it out and see what you think because you're still going to enjoy a meal and you might find something that you want to come back to often.“

“I had been looking for a great pizza place since moving back to Ohio 11 years ago. I had settled on Marcos because when they 1st opened, it was wonderful. I guess they’ve become complacent, or they have so much turnover, that they can’t provide good service anymore. I don’t know what has happened to this place. I have stopped patronizing the restaurant because of messed up orders, pizza boxes stuck to the toppings, and just a general lack of attention to detail. The app is way too unreliable, and you miss out on half of your rewards. When I did order, it was always for delivery. I’m my wife’s caregiver, and we don’t go out much anymore.“

“Easily the most personable experience I’ve had with their customer service. Food was even better & restaurant environment was superb! Will definitely be back often & will tell my family and friends about this restaurant & their excellent & kind customer service!“

“My family orders creno's often the food never disappoints especially the cheesy garlic flatbread.. however the reason I decided to post a review today is my delivery driver.... I didn't actually get his name but I felt that people should know this driver in particular is the most kind patient understanding man... At the very last minute I realized my mistake that I didn't have correct change and I know delivery drivers do not carry it.. so I ran to the gas station next to my house got a few necessities and broke my $100 bill so that I had proper change and tip to give to my driver... He called while I was at the gas station I explained what I was doing and he was nothing but kind he sat on my porch patiently waiting for me to return was not mean or grumpy he even thanked me for being nice... It's a sad day when somebody has to thank you for being a decent human but I digress I just wanted to say Creno's has great food and excellent service“

“Awesome experience tonight all around for a special night with our girls! Tracy and Michelle made things extra special. Service, food and all around environment was great! Thank you“

“Consistently delicious pizza!“

“Great subs and the cristys classic is awesome.“

“Came across this gem! Everything was delicious! Definitely will be coming back.“

“we have been going to Tiberos pizza for years, and have always loved it so much, we went this evening, and I was so disappointed in the service, they have a new young girl and she dropped my pizza and I had to wait almost a hour for it to be remade, I still got charged for it, our service was horrible, I have never been to any restaurant who didn't give u a free meal or a discount on their mistake, and especially waiting a hour, I don't know if we will be back.“

“First time visiting here tonight. Great vibe and the food was AMAZING Will definitely be back“

“1 of the Best pizzas I've ever eatin 👍👍!!!“

“I had Chicken Alfredo Carbonara & a Caesar side salad & it was fantastic. Bridget, our waitress, was very kind & attentive. We’ll be back soon!“

“Always a good time! Great outdoor Patio!“

“The pizza is exceptionally good the hot honey pepperoni pizza is very good. We will be ordering it quite often.“

“Stopped in for a quick bite to eat and was pleased to find a generous Happy Hour for apps and beers. We split a Philly and Italian subs. Oh my, the bread used for the sub is insane. Best bread I've had in a long time. I'll be back just to try this again. I've also heard they use the same bakery for their burger buns and I'm excited to try that as well. Overall, everything was delicious! Deep fried mushrooms, jalapeño poppers, and both subs. Excited to come back.“

“I have celiac disease and have hard a time finding food that isn’t contaminated, especially pizza. The staff reassured me that they checked with kitchen multiple times to make sure nothing was being contaminated. It was by far the most delicious gluten free pizza I’ve had so far !“

“Best pizza ever!!“

“I've been ordering online and I have to say that the service has been wonderful and the delivery time much better as well as the quality of food. ..“

“We came here to see Waterloo5 band last night and had the most amazing time. A lot of reviews have said it was too loud but we loved every minute of the band. I love the atmosphere here along with the cozy seating arrangements they have. Things I wish they had: Drink specials when a band is there. An absolute must would be beer buckets. I spent too much time going to the bar to get a beer. The bartenders were slammed and did an absolutely AMAZING job considering the crowd. Overall a super cool place that I cannot wait for warmer weather so the roll up doors can be open.“

“Easily the most personable experience I’ve had with their customer service. Food was even better & restaurant environment was superb! Will definitely be back often & will tell my family and friends about this restaurant & their excellent & kind customer service!“