Cathy's: Gourmet Ice Cream Sandwiches

At $10, this is rather pricey as far as ice cream sandwiches go. In far more expensive California for example, there are two stores, CREAM in the Bay Area and Diddy Riese in Los Angeles, that also offer gourmet ice cream paired with freshly baked cookies, but charge one-half or one-third the price, respectively. Still, the cookies were large and so was the serving of ice cream inside them. You can mix and match cookies, with the net result being something soooo big in your hands...read full review

Good evening, I patronized your location in downtown Cleveland today around 6pm. The only flavor available that wasn’t frozen solid was strawberry so I was told to come back in 1 hour. That was an option for me as I had already made the trip to come there. So I opted for strawberry for 2 ice cream sandwiches. There were 2 young ladies working the counter (one had brown hair with a facial mole and one had black hair: both were young so I should have known not to expect 5-star...read full review

Cathy's is so tasty! The flavors vary everytime I visit and there are staples. When I happen to be in the area, I always visit. The cookies are always fresh and the ice cream is always delicious. The workers are so friendly and they give me great recommendations when i ask. The arcade is breathtaking and such an amazing backdrop to this establishment. I can wait to go back.