Bexley Pizza Plus

$$ • Pizza

2651 E Main St, Columbus
(614) 237-3305


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Bexley Pizza Plus

We had good pizza in the past from Bexley Pizza Plus. We just picked up our request of a vegetarian pizza large. Terrible! We asked for crispy and not even that. The vegetables were not even cooked...raw. Paid $26 cold cash and is not the money. They must be new employees....It will be a long time before we go back!!!!!.

Yep, this is your "go to place" for your pizza appetite !!! THIER pepperoni pizza and cheese pizza are what a good pizza should be in my honest opinion; Fresh, non-greasy, Flavorful, chewy center with a crisp crust, YUM and just the right amount of sauce, I can't count how many times I have order pizza here in C-bus that you can barely tell it is even on it.., and it's a regular pizza, no specialty pizza. I am new to the area and so happy to have found this place:))

The ultimate is what pepperoni and mushroom pizza dreams are made of!! Very good pizza that is clearly made with high-quality ingredients. Made in the style of many traditional Columbus area pizza shops with a thin and crispy crust. However, the crust is much more fluffy and lighter on the inside than others. Very good and I can't wait to come back

More Reviews(81)


Monday 12 - 9PM
Tuesday 12 - 9PM
Wednesday 12 - 9PM
Thursday 12 - 9PM
Friday 12 - 10PM
Saturday 12 - 10PM
Sunday 12 - 9PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.