34 Best Pizza Restaurants near Dover

“Clean, friendly and awesome!! THE BEST I'VE EVER HAD!“

“When I graduated from high school I moved to L.A. On a trip home I made sure I had two things to take back on my flight... 1) Trail bologna and 2) An unbaked Mary Zifer's pizza! When I got home I froze it and when I was feeling homesick I popped it in the oven and the smell brought me right back to Dover! 🍕“

“We only ever get take out so don't know how it is in the restaurant but it's in my top 3 for cheese pizza. Homemade pasta is also very good and the service at the back pick up has always been great. The cheese sticks are fantastic, I always eat more than I should.“

“I've been a fan of Pizza Hut since I was a kid. This location is always on top of it, and they always ensure my order is correct, hot, and delicious. Their delivery driver, Robert, is a staple there and has always been so kind when delivering my pizza or when I get carry out and happen to see him. My favorite pizza location by far.“

“We frequently order from here for events at Adventure Harley-Davidson and they always do a tremendous job.

Today, I accidentally placed an order that was meant for Saturday. By the time I realized and called, they were already making the order.

They were able to cancel it and place the order for the correct delivery date.

Great customer service!“

“If you’re looking for a place to get pizza in the Dover/New Philly area, this is the place to get. Great pizza!! Had a great experience from ordering the food to receiving it. The staff were super friendly and the pizza arrived hot and was delicious. Highly recommend and will be ordering again!“

“This was the best pizza I’ve ever had and I have traveled a lot I wish we had this restaurant back home in Texas“

“What makes this place special are the owners and staff. You can truly tell how much they care about every single table that walks in. The food is top tier phenomenal and the price point makes coming here affordable for the family for the quality you are receiving. I always recommend here to everyone we know. It’s a hr away but worth the drive every time.“

“Had the french bread pizza today Best i ever have eaten. I live 6 mile from a good pizza shop in sugarcreek but will continue to drive 13 mile for this pizza. Well worth it. Great people. Great pizza“

“the best crust on a pizza and cheese stick you'll ever have!“

“Food was quick, delicious, and unique. The sauce is flavorful with a delightfully crunchy thick crust, the ingredients seemed fresh, and the cheddar cheese really did make it. I'm so glad we didn't ask if they had mozzarella. Staff was nice, service was quick, and this is clearly a popular place, because they had a steady stream of customers while we waited for our pizza, and it wasn't too long before closing.“

“love the pizza. I need to start trying other things on the menu, but keep going back to the pizza. I would say one of my favorite places to order pizza 🍕😋“

“I’m a Jersey girl I’ve been living in Ohio for 10 years and the only place that I can get delicious pizza is Sbarro. My son and I always get the cheese New Yorker oh my gosh, it’s always so delicious.

Parking: It is located at a mall, so there is parking right near Marshalls and you go right into the entrance next to that door to then walk down to the Sbarro“

“The best pizza my family has ever had! We get it multiple times a month!“

“Incredible pizza small in small town America. These are the kind of places everyone needs to support and keep around for eternity.

After a long afternoon at the water park, this cheese bread and pepperoni pizza nearly brought me to tears of joy. Their dining area is nice and cozy and our server was fantastic.“

“Crossroads pizza is the BEST pizza place. Hands down, no doubt about it! I live in Alliance but I gladly make the trip to East Sparta for their delicious pizza.“

“The absolutely best pizza in Tuscarawas County. possibly in all of Ohio! It's a small family business. Buyers beware, their sausage packs a punch, so order accordingly. I love it, and everyone there is super friendly. Highly recommend if you're in the area.“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“What a great little gathering place! We needed a place, on short notice, for a celebration of life for our Grandmother and Pangrazio's came through in a big way! The staff were all amazing and the food was absolutely wonderful! Eating buffet style straight out of the kitchen was such a fitting meal to honor our Italian Grandmother. Great food, great atmosphere, and wonderful staff! Thank you Pangrazio's for everything!“

“Awesome food, scalloped potatoes with ham10/10 burgers 10/10, wings10/10 banana cake10/10 great food, great atmosphere, great service!“

“Picked up a pepperoni and cheese pizza at Maco's by Grandma Zifaro! Wow! Knocked our socks off. Delicious!!! Wow we didn't realize what we had been missing. Definitely our new go to for pizza. In our opinion the best in the area and we have tried many. Mini pepperoni, sauce, crust, absolutely awesome. Can't wait to try their other toppings.“

“Great people good food nice place to be“

“I can always count on hot and delicious food every time from Domino’s. Fast delivery. Best pizza shop around Gnadenhutten!!“

“Best Pizza in Ohio!!!!!!!“

“Called in and ordered deliver. Young woman on the phone was exceptionally nice and professional. Originally was told about 50 minutes for delivery, which was not a problem. Ended up showing up around 30 minutes! Delivery driver was very pleasant. Pizza was hot and delicious!“

“never hot and ready, manager doesn't seem to understand, or care that customer service will make or break a restaurant“

“We love getting pizza at this restaurant! The brick fired pizza is always amazing. I love their house Italian dressing as well and the appetizers are fantastic! The servers are always so friendly and awesome, but seem to be short staffed at times. It doesnt take away from their personal commitment to make your dinner awesome. My only downside to any dinner there is I only ever seem to get one napkin per dinner. Im not sure why! We always ask for extra and end up with one each. 😂 That definitely does not stop me from coming back though. Fantastic food, great staff, and amazing pizza! Take your family here!“

“We had a group meal here after a funeral that we attended. The restaurant was peaceful and there wasn't loud music playing blaring so we were able to hear each other speak. I don't think anyone else was dining in, either, so we basically had the entire place to ourselves. We had a few different kinds of pizzas- pepperoni, taco, everything, etc. Everyone enjoyed the variety of pizza options and had a pleasant time. ?“

“Wow! We're from the Cleveland area and I have to say this deluxe topper pizza is freaking amazing. It's probably a good thing it's not local for me. Seriously the best crust. Absolutely love it!The wings weren't a traditional hot Buffalo, more BBQ Buffalo-ey but very good.“

“There’s nothing I haven’t tried on the menus that I dislike. You will never leave hungry and the service and customer base is reason enough to give it a try. Excellent food, amazing service and everyone is a friend at Ricardo’s. Ricardo is about as good as it gets to his friends, customers and gives back to his community. Come give it a try. You’ll be back!“

“My buddy from Texas came into town and we went to the yard. Everything was great from the food to the drinks. The service was great too.“

“JNG is a great place with a lively environment. The food is phenomenal, drinks are yummy, and staff is sweet and fun. They do a great job at keeping everyone happy and safe, and handle the negative rif-raf well and accordingly. Keep up the great work over there! 🥰“

“We've tried several pizza places in New Philadelphia and have to say East of Chicago is the best we've had. When you order extra cheese, that's what you get. The toppings were fresh, and the pizza sauce was perfect...not overwhelming the taste of the other ingredients. Crust was delicious, too.“

“We ordered Philly Cheese steak papadia and buffalo wings and it was delish! Everything was cooked perfectly and hot on delivery. Delivery was faster than the time they said it would be. Thanks Papa John's. I didn't have to cook tonight. :)“