Pizza Restaurants near Edgerton

Route 6 Pizza Barn Pizza • $
404 W Vine St, Edgerton

Customers` Favorites

Fried Shrimp
Meat Pizza

“I got the cauliflower gluten free pizza and it was amazing. So much better than the regular gluten free pizza. Thank you! best gluten free pizza that I have found 😋“

4.8 Superb22 Reviews
Hot Stuff Pizza Pizza • $
314 W Vine St, Edgerton
0 Na0 Reviews
Elmo's Pizza & Subs Pizza • $
107 E Main St, Montpelier - 11.92 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Wing
Pizza
Poke

“I called this fine establishment today to order food for me and my family of 5 including me.When I called up and order my massive order well it seemed like it was for me, the gentleman over the phone said it would only be done in 15-to-20 mins. I was astonished I have called many different pizza buildings and their wait time is at least 20-to-30 minutes for a simple order. But when this gentleman told me that I asked for his name and challenged the young man. His name was chance and I said to chance “if he could get this order done in the time frame he just told me I would leave an amazing review for the kid.” And he did, the food was amazing and I’m definitely coming back for more. I just wanted to give a shout-out to the kid because he definitely deserves it here.“

4.3 Superb38 Reviews
Wyse Guys Pizzeria Pizza • $
315 W Main St, Montpelier - 11.89 miles

Customers` Favorites

Boneless Chicken Chunks
Toasted Sub w Chips
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Bread
Cheesy Bread

“Our first visit to Wyse Guys, and we really enjoyed it. The pizza is very good, and the low price was a pleasant surprise. I might have gone with a 5 overall, but I thought the crust could have a little more flavor, and I like a bit chewier texture. I did like that the crust was fairly thin and light, and both sauce and cheese had great flavor. We have only lived in the area for a couple of years, but have tried most of the pizza places. Wyse Guys is quite possibly the best pizza in Williams County! We will definitely be back.“

4.4 Superb25 Reviews
Edon Pizza Pizza • $$
100 E Indiana St, Edon - 7.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Butter
Black Olives
Garlic Bread
Sauce
Pizza

“The subs are absolutely my favorite! The bread is always fresh and awesome, they use quality meat, and the toppings are also fresh and you can easily tell them to leave off the ones that you don’t like. I have encountered some not so friendly staff occasionally, but for the most part the staff try to accommodate your preferences. The pizzas are hit and miss. Sometimes they are outstanding, and sometimes the toppings are scarce and disappointing. Pasta is offered as well. The Alfredo is so rich and fulfilling, that what seems like a small portion for the price is not accurate (you also receive some tempting breadsticks with the pasta). Overall, this little hole in the wall pizza shop is a must try and get enough for your whole family!“

4.4 Superb24 Reviews
Tano's Pizza Pizza • $
111 N Jonesville St, Montpelier - 11.88 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tano's Breadsticks
Hawaiian
Pizza
Taco
V-6

“Did not rate the atmosphere since I did not go in but food was excellent. I got 2 subs with a coupon that made it less than $16. I enjoy supporting local businesses. Only reason I left a 4 star rating is when I ordered delivery i did call after waiting the approximate quoted time to check on my delivery and the person that was taking orders had marked it as a pickup order but did correct it and send a delivery driver out but did have to wait longer for the food but would like to try it again.“

3.5 Good25 Reviews

You May Also Like