18 Best Pizza Restaurants in Findlay

“We drove over an hour to Findlay just to try your calzone and go to Dietschs for ice cream It didn't disappoint. It was delicious 😋 thank you !“

“pizza is very good if you like deep dish. also the hot honey chunks are amazing!“

“I would like to make a shoutout to Tom Gierke for being a great delivery driver! He’s so friendly, thanks us for the tip, and tells us to be safe and have a great evening. Of the two times I have gotten Jac n Do’s delivered it has been him and if I could guarantee it’d be him everytime I’d up his tip from us! He’s great! :)“

“Thanks Logan for hooking us up with a cookie pizza! It was amazing! 10/10“

“best stuffed breadsticks you ever had in your life!!! My family and I are feeling incredibly grateful for the generosity of Dean Smith. His heartfelt donation of all the food for Dane's funeral and the Disc Golf benefit means more than words can express. You truly are a legendary person, Dean! Thank you for being you. Superheroes wear capes you just wear yours backwards and cover it with flour lol i love you dean you are the best!“

“best service and food highly recommend“

“Brad was hands down the best! We so appreciate him! We drove from Lima just for some tasty pizza and the pepperoni rolls and he was top notch! Such a great employee! Can’t wait to come back.“

“We went to the Findlay location to meet friends. We moved out of town 3 years ago and wanted to catch up. I cannot remember the server’s name, but she was amazing! Our party of 15 turned into 25 and she never skipped a beat or made us feel like a hassle. As a previous bartender and server I understand the stress we put her through. Not to forget the kitchen! Our food was FAST and hot!! Thank you Beer Barrel and staff!!“

“The pizza and the food is delicious. But when I came into the store to order. It was very, very hot but it has plenty of fan in there are at least 7 to 8 fans. I wonder why the AC system is not working. You should care about your employees as you do your customers. It been broke for few months . Findlay ohio..please FIX IT“

“Pepperoni and banana peppers well done. The best pizza in town.“

“Amazing food!! Subs are sooo yummy! Generous portions!! The best in Findlay Ohio!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️“

“This is my family's favorite all you can eat pizza place. They have many options of pizza already to be picked from. If you to not see what you like you can also request a specialty pizza and they will have it made in 10 minutes and brought to your table. Our favorite specialty pizzas are, Baked Potato Pizza, BLT Pizza, Mac n Cheese Pizza and White pizza! When you are all pizza'd out, you can choose from 4 different kinds of dessert pizza. The place is phenomenal and the best all you can eat pizza restaurant!“

“Friendly people with quality, delicious food.“

“Been picking up pizza here for awhile now. Everyone is always pleasant. Pizzas are really good and not greasy and done super fast. Orders are right. Very good food value
Inside is bright, clean and modern . Sort of seems like how restaurants used to be and now it passes for exceptional because so many places aren't any of these things. Good job Tiffin Ave Dominos!!“

“Rodney Nelson and his staff are feiendly and the bar has a nice, welcoming, atmosphere. Patrons are always friendly, too. I run sound for bands there quite frequently and local bands are really enjoyed there and Rodney supports live music. A great place to unwind and hangout!“

“There’s something eternally satisfying about a slice of pizza done right, and this place nails it. The toppings are plentiful and fresh, each bite bursting with flavor that reminds you why pizza is a universal comfort food. The crust, sauce, cheese—everything tastes fresh and lovingly crafted. It's the kind of pizza that you think about long after the meal is over.

But what really sets this place apart is the customer service. I screwed up my order—my mistake, plain and simple. They could have easily shrugged it off, but instead, they went out of their way to accommodate me, turning what could have been a frustrating experience into a memorable one. That kind of service is rare and it makes a lasting impression.

They didn’t just fix my order; they made a customer for life. In a world where good service is becoming increasingly hard to find, this place stands out. I’m already looking forward to my next visit, eager to dive into another pie with those delicious, fresh toppings. This isn’t just a pizza place—it’s a reminder that a little extra effort can turn a good meal into a great experience.“

“Good pizza, toppings were a little skimpy. The employee had a great attitude. One pepperoncini pepper per pizza, inflation hits again.

Parking: A better location in town, or two stores would help. The lighted signage needs attention on the front of the building.“

“🤤 I'm not all too sure what the users who submit negative reviews God-honestly expect when it comes to the quality of service they receive from any business under the operation of human beings. What do they even 'believe' realistically takes place when ever there's an error or some mistake made on the restaurant's end? Like they just had a fully equipped staff ready to go? Like they just fair & Square failed miserably with zero excuse, or even like just deliberately causing orders to complete behind schedule? Like the manager says "WAIT!! you forgot something" to the deliver driver just headed out n turns around like "What?" "What do you mean what ?" "You yelled out that I forgot something" Yeah, you did, your supposed to stand right there & count out loud 590 seconds .. uh .. twice. When your done with that then go ahead & head out. But .. Please ... if you wouldn't mind, walk backwards. One more quick suggestion.. when you collect their payment & hand them the order don't just instantly return to the vehicle to make it back here... I want you stick around & stare at their front door n' do the one thing... yeahhh all 590 of em.. out loud... Oh yeah then start it down from the top 589 ... 588 ... 587...take a break... breath .. 586.. Let's stay unfocused tonight guys!! Were gonna get alot of orders & I want them ALL to have something screwed up check your tickets make sure if they ordered stuff crust with pepperoni ... That means make it a medium thin crust with double black olives & a side of icing. " Like NO Human does NOT do anything that another human wouldn't do. No ones guilty. No one's at fault. If anyone is then I declare that individual as my own self ONLY. I am the ONLY human with flaws & other than me, everyones perfect & I owe them all an explanation.“