Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
“SO GOOD! First time visiting and I loved it. The store itself is very cute with great parking but also good accessibility from the rest of New Albany if you wanted to have a long walk with your ice cream! The employees were super friendly and helpful and I was grateful to get to sample a couple flavors because their menu is packed with options! I opted for the Buckeye flavor this time and it was delicious - creamy and the perfect peanut butter/chocolate balance without being too rich. the sugar cone was good too- nice and crispy with a good vanilla taste and not just from the cheap box you can find at the grocery (though I don't dislike those). I was only supposed to get one scoop but I definitely got a little extra. Excited to go back and try other flavors!“
“First time at Whits and I was not disappointed! Delicious and such a cute shop in a great location. I got asked to describe it and said it was like a cross between Orange Leaf and Dairy Queen but with better custard and stand by it. So many fun topping options and their own creations and the custard is perfectly creamy, thick and flavorful. I did their take on a mixed custard with toppings and loved it! Perfectly blended and toppings well distributed throughout so you didn't end on a bunch of plain custard. The sizes are also big - the small was about the size of a medium blizzard at DQ for reference.On top of great product, being uptown New Albany, having very easy parking and so close to walking trails is perfect and really makes it all the more enjoyable experience! Will definitely be making a return trip!“
“Clean and friendly Dairy Queen in New Albany. Safe and enjoyable for the kids. Our food was brought to our table. I don't know if they always do this, but I appreciate the extra hands. The drive through is usually great and today we are indoors. We've had several positive experiences at this location!Kid-friendliness: Staff was incredibly patient and kind with my children. The booths and tables seat children well. I see 3 high chairs, clean and ready for use and easy to access.“
“We came here for Frozen Custard - which was incredible. But we left talking about the Coney Dog! It was a first for us and we loved it. Dawn and Judy were fantastic. They explained the menu, gave us samples and helped us make our choices. Highly recommend Whit's Frozen Custard of Johnstown!!!“