29 Best Ice Cream Shops near New Albany

Johnson's Real Ice Cream, New Albany Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $$
160 W Main St, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Death by Chocolate Sundae
Choco Pretzel Trap
Shakes and Cones
Black Raspberry
Lemon Cha Cha
Single Scoop
1 Dip Cone

“We had a wonderful experience. The staff was amazing and the quality of the ice cream was exceptional. We will definitely return!“

4.6 Superb140 Reviews
Whit's Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
220 Market St Suite B, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Whit's New York Chocolate Chip Cheesecake Ice Cream

“Whit's in New Albany, OH is my favorite Whit's for frozen custard & Pies. I go there often and enjoy the friendliness of the owner & the staff. The freezer's are always filled with so many varieties. It's hard to make a choice. I buy several of my favorites & take them to my family, out of town - who are not lucky enough to live close to a Whit's. I still don't know if they are excited to see me or the Whit's custard :-) but we all enjoy it. Family I'll be bringing some to you soon!“

4.1 Good80 Reviews
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill Fast Food • $
9940 Johnstown Rd, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

1 3 lb Double with Cheese Burger 7 Meal Deal
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Blizzard Treat
1 2 lb Cheese Grill Burger Combo
Original Cheeseburger
Side of Onion Rings
Ice Cream Sandwich
Chili Cheese Dog
Crispy Chicken
Ice Cream Cake
Chicken Strip

“I love this Dairy Queen.It's one of my favorites in New Albany.\nThe employees are great.The store is always clean.The parking lot's always cleaned.The bathrooms are always clean.The food is always good prepared properly.
I only have good things to say about this.Dairy queen I would recommend it to anybody who's looking for good ice cream or good food.“

3.4 Good262 Reviews
Coppa Gelato Ice Cream Shop • $
925 N State St, Westerville - 7.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate and Amaretto
Gelato and Macarons
Scoop of Gelato
Gelato Flight
Waffle Cones
Bourbon Pecan
Strawberry
Affogato

“The best gelato I have had! Great atmosphere and always so friendly.“

4.9 Superb92 Reviews
The Dairy Hut Ice Cream Shop • $
42 S Main St, Pataskala - 8.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pineapple Upside Down Sundae
Turtle Brownie Sundae
Strawberry Shortcake
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Strawberry Sundae
Hot Fudge Sundae
Buckeye Sundae
Turtle Sundae
Butterscotch
Cookie Dough

“A great time, as always!!“

4.7 Superb135 Reviews
Johnson's Real Ice Cream Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
2728 E Main St, Columbus - 10.58 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buckeye Sundae Ice Cream
Butter Pecan Ice Cream
Strawberry Cheesecake
Bubble Gum Ice Cream
Strawberry Ice Cream
Strawberry Shortcake
Iced Sugar Cookies
Tuna Salad Platter
Chicken Salad
Birthday Cake

“We had a wonderful experience. The staff was amazing and the quality of the ice cream was exceptional. We will definitely return!“

4.5 Superb126 Reviews
Whit's Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
46 N State St, Westerville - 7.24 miles

Customers` Favorites

Kids Ice Cream Sundae
Quart Frozen Custard
Strawberry Shortcake
Chocolate Ice Cream
Custard Sandwich
Cookies N Cream
Banana Split
Whitties

“We were staying in Columbus for a few days and I happened upon this little gem. Had a lemon whittie on Wednesday afternoon, another one on Thursday evening and a s’mores whittie Friday morning for breakfast. I have no regrets. If I’m ever in this area again I will most definitely swing by for the best ice cream sandwiches I’ve ever enjoyed! Top notch!“

4.7 Superb64 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $$
101 Mill St Ste 108, Gahanna - 5.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Peanut Butter Cup Perfection
Apple Pie a La Cold Stone
Birthday Cake Remix
OH Fudge

“Cold Stone Creamery is one of my favorite ice cream places. The ice cream tastes fresh, creamy, and full of flavor. What makes it special is that you can customize your order with different mix-ins like candy, cookies, fruit, and chocolate,“

4.5 Superb125 Reviews
Graeter's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $$
425 Beecher Rd, Gahanna - 3.82 miles

Customers` Favorites

Graeter's Classic Ice Cream Scooper
Black Cherry Chocolate Chip Pint
Cookie Monster Sundae
Major League Sundae
Black Raspberry
Waffle Cones
1870 Tower
Strawberry
Pints

“Love the ice cream it was good“

4.7 Superb61 Reviews
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
200 Granville St, Gahanna - 5.52 miles

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Italian Ice with Vanilla Ice Cream
Shaved Ice
Custard
Apple

“Rita ice cream lover for more than 20 years“

4.5 Superb59 Reviews
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
520 S State St Ste A, Westerville - 6.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Vanilla Custard
Root Beer Float
Cotton Candy
Swedish Fish
Italian Ice
Mango Ice

“Amazing peanut butter and marshmallow flavours“

4.4 Superb62 Reviews
Whit's Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
551 W Coshocton St, Johnstown - 7.48 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buckeye Blast Whitser
Chili Cheese

“Whit's recently catered my daughter's 5th birthday party. I appreciated their kindness and professionalism and the ways they went above and beyond to make the party very special. The treats were delicious (as always) and loved by everyone!“

4.4 Superb56 Reviews
Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams Ice Cream Shop • $$
3998 Gramercy St, Columbus - 5.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Banana Cream Pudding DF Pint
Dark Chocolate Truffle
Brambleberry Crisp Pint
Fresh Waffle Cone
Gooey Butter Cake
Frozen Yogurt
Sheet Cake
Sorbet

“I've always been a fan of Jeni's but I have never gone to this location because of the long lines. I went the other day and had an amazing time! Thank you to young lady Nesrin for the help in trying out the recent new flavors and I look forward to coming back for more treats. I recommend trying out the limited Hibiscus Chili Punch for a kick!“

4.3 Superb91 Reviews
Graeter's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $$
1 N State St, Westerville - 7.21 miles

Customers` Favorites

Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip Pint
Black Raspberry Chip
Boldly Bearcat Pint
Waffle Cones
Mocha Chip

“Great experience! Friendly service and good recommendations! Will return!“

4.3 Superb70 Reviews
Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery Bakery • $
1249 N Hamilton Rd, Gahanna - 3.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Single Chocolate Caramel Drum Cupcake
White Chocolate Cake with Raspberry
Strawberry Champagne Cupcake
Peanut Butter Cup Cupcake
Boston Cream Pie Cupcake
Peanut Butter Cupcake
Pupcake Treat for Dogs
Strawberry Shortcake
Strawberry Cupcakes
Lemon Drop Cupcake

“They had one gluten free chocolate cupcake left. I got to pick the topping and they were able to do the peanut butter one. It was AMAZING! Did not taste GF at all. 10/10 recommend!“

4.9 Superb136 Reviews
Nutcracker Family Restaurant Family • $
63 E Broad St, Pataskala - 8.98 miles

Customers` Favorites

Eggs over Easy Baby Reds and Wheat Toast
Scrambled Eggs Bacon and Baby Reds
Deep Fried Corn on the Cob
Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
Grilled Cinnamon Roll
Old Fashioned Diner
Coconut Cream Pie
Beef and Noodles
Grilled Cheese
Meatloaf Stack

“The husband and I had a great time! Will definitely be back. We had breakfast and I had a milkshake. All was very good. I’ve enjoyed this place when I was a teenager, now coming back a married adult is pretty neat 😀“

4.7 Superb287 Reviews
Antojitos de mi tierra LLC Ice Cream Shop • $
5137 E Main St, Whitehall - 9.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tostilocos
Esquites

“Cute little latin place to get ice cream and tropical fruts like rambutan, manguitos verdes, nance, chirimolla, cirguela verde and more.You can find ice cream flavors like mango, mamey, pistacho, maracuya, strawberry, gancito, horchata and more flavors.This is place is not big, it has only 4 tables but it's a hidden gem.“

4.4 Superb33 Reviews
La Michoacana es Tocumbo Ice Cream Shop • $
4741 E Main St, Whitehall - 8.3 miles

“I visit my family in Columbus Ohio and live in Boston. And every time I arrive, I cannot come without eating several mangonadas. I want to tell you that if you want to try something good, visit this place. Everything is delicious, but especially the famous mangonada. It's my favorite, I love that mango flavor and I haven't been able to find a flavor like it. And in fact I had the opportunity to meet the very kind owner of the place. I told her how much I liked mangonadas and I asked her to sell me some plastic containers so I could bring fried mangonadas to Boston. And it arrived in excellent condition. He gave me a good and fair price. Thank you!“

4.3 Superb38 Reviews
Graeter's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $$
147 Easton Town Ctr, Columbus - 6.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Turtle Sundae

“I always loved Graeter’s ice cream �“

4.3 Superb28 Reviews
20

Crumbl

Crumbl Dessert • $$
2863 Taylor Rd Ext, Reynoldsburg - 9.89 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie
Lemon Bar Cookie
Crumbl Cookies
Key Lime Pie
Mini 12-Pack
Crumbl Water
Lemon Tart
Party Box
Single
4-Pack

“Amazing! Pre ordered and showed up a little early, the store was busy and still managed to welcome us in, inform us of a slight wait and all with smiling faces! Still took them less time than I was quoted and everything was delicious and packaged nice!!“

4.6 Superb363 Reviews
Whit's Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
121 S Stygler Rd, Gahanna - 6.18 miles

Customers` Favorites

Butterscotch Pecan Sundae w Whipped Cream
Custard in a Waffle Cone
Gahanna Turtle Sundae
Hot Fudge Sundae
Sea Salt Caramel
Cheesecake Bites
Blue Raspberry
Caramel Apple
Banana Split
Mud Pie

“Delicious! Cookie dough is my favorite. The best deal is the grab and go quart. Highly recommend!“

4.1 Good94 Reviews
Crumbl – Cookies & Desserts Bakery • $$
4034 Morse Crossing, Columbus - 6.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

Blueberry Muffin Cookie Churro Cookie Chocolate Cookies and Cream Chocolate Chip
Chocolate Chip Cookies Double Chocolate Chip Cookies
Strawberry Cheesecake Cookies
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cookie
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Lemon Blackberry Cookie
Peanut Butter Cookies
Banana Pudding Cookie
Classic Sugar Cookie
Milk Chocolate Chip

“It is great it tastes good and the service is fast

Vegetarian options: All of them

Dietary restrictions: There is not many

Parking: It is great

Kid-friendliness: It is good

Wheelchair accessibility: You can fit a wheelchair in there“

4.6 Superb216 Reviews
23

Crumbl

Crumbl Bakery • $$
6326 E Dublin Granville Rd, Westerville - 2.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cotton Candy Sugar Cookie
Chocolate Crunch Cookie
Oatmeal- Iced and Warm
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Milk Chocolate Cookie
Milk Chocolate Chip
6 Pack of Cookies
Apple Pie Cookie
Cornbread Cookie
Churro Cookie

“The food was quality, but could have more flavor. The service was friendly, but could have a bit more forwardness by welcoming you as you come in the door and asking if you have ever been there and offering assistance with how everything works, rather than the customer feeling confused and having to ask. The atmosphere is clean and seems well managed, it just needs to be a bit more polished. It is a bit pricey, however, in the correct demographics it will do well. If the flavors of the week were posted in the window with a large bold font, so it can be seen while driving by it would bring more traffic through their doors.“

4.6 Superb205 Reviews
Graeter's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $$
2282 E Main St, Bexley - 10.96 miles

Customers` Favorites

Shop Our Flavors Online & in-Store
Double Scoop Waffle Cone
Ice Cream Cones Dishes
Medium Milkshake 20oz
Strawberry Shortcake
Chocolate Chip
Turtle Sundae
Brownie Sundae
Cotton Candy
Butter Pecan

“Grater’s is an amazing family hangout spot with handmade awesome ice cream, gluten free options and Kosher nonetheless, how could you ask for a more amazing experience“

4 Good78 Reviews
Dulce Vida Ice Cream Factory Ice Cream Shop • $$
6146 Cleveland Ave, Columbus - 7.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ferrero Rocher in Hand-Dipped Cone
Mango and Passionfruit Sorbet
Elote Loco Papa's Con Tocino
Strawberry Ice Cream
Cheetos Con Queso
Mango Ice Cream
Ice Cream Cone
Walking Taco
Banana Split
Paletas

“Best I have ever had. And, I'm 75. The Mocha is awesome. Will be going there again and again. My friend had Coffee and Coconut and she said it's better than anything she's ever had at Graeters!“

4 Good127 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $$
762 N State St, Westerville - 7.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake Remix

“It's been a little while since I have been in but my husband got me the most delicious ice cream cake for my birthday here. Unlike DQ that is all ice cream with the fudge and cookie in the middle, Coldstone cakes have actual cake and ice cream. Mine also had a delicious ganache-like frosting. Would def get one again.“

3.5 Good18 Reviews
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill Ice Cream Shop • $
364 Granville St, Gahanna - 5.36 miles

Customers` Favorites

Double Original Cheeseburger 1 3 lb Signature Stackburger
Choco Brownie Extreme Blizzard Treat
Standard Celebration Cake - DQ Cake
Single Two Cheese Deluxe 1 6 lb
Chilli Dog Fries Cheeseburger
Oreo Cookies Blizzard Treat
Butterfinger Blizzard Treat
Chicken Strips Kids' Meal
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Side of Onion Rings

“Quick drive through service. great food, friendly employees.“

3.8 Good93 Reviews
Culver’s American • $
1912 OH-256, Reynoldsburg - 9.45 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Culver’S Deluxe Cheeseburger and Fries
Strawberry Cheesecake Sundae
Single Butterburger Cheese
Double Butter Burger Combo
Pretzel Burger and Fries
Wisconsin Cheese Curds
Double Butter Burger
Chocolate Ice Cream
Cheeseburger Combo
Crinkle Cut Fries

“We LOVE Culver’s!!! Food is hot & delicious every time!! Butter burgers are so good! Fries & cheese curds are awesome and the custard is creamy & hits the spot! Excellent customer service and clean atmosphere! My favorite fast food restaurant!“

4.1 Good277 Reviews
Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
750 N State St, Westerville - 7.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Medium Frozen Yogurt
Small Frozen Yogurt
Large Frozen Yogurt
Açaí Na Tigela

“Awesome service, great tasting yogurt as always! Thank you!“

3.3 Good69 Reviews

You May Also Like