16 Best Ice Cream Shops near Pickerington

“EXCELLENT quality ice cream at this modern, clean, and brand-new location in village Pickerington! About 30 flavors to choose from that cycle in and out regularly, with seasonal offerings. Nice rooftop patio and outdoor seating to watch the traffic and shenanigans of Pickerington residents. A perfect place to put an ice cream shop, too, only wish there was more parking available in the small lot (about 6 spaces).“

“Best ice cream!!! Very nice shop. Very clean.“

“Cold Stone Creamery is the best ice cream place 😋! They're the only place that I can buy a dipped sprinkled waffle bowl 🙂! Their ice cream consistency is unmatched and their customer service is wonderful. Employees who regularly see me remember what I like to order. I visit twice a month after I pick up my prescriptions at my pharmacy.“

“great place to eat some froyo! very clean!“

“Quick drive through service. great food, friendly employees.“

“A great time, as always!!“

“The husband and I had a great time! Will definitely be back. We had breakfast and I had a milkshake. All was very good. I’ve enjoyed this place when I was a teenager, now coming back a married adult is pretty neat 😀“

“Very clean place and the person at front was really nice and attentive.. she said hi really fast. I was here before and I loved it as well. Always super nice! ahmaly was the girl at front I think I spelled her name wrong but super nice girl 🩷“

“Quick and easy experience when I walked into the store. I had a quick question and the girl working was helpful to answer my question. I placed my order and received my order maybe 2 minutes - so very quick! The only downside is I felt like the store was dirty - it was more the front area that felt dirtier. The floors were pretty gross - could have been from just the day but highly doubtful all that mess was made in a day. The back looked pretty messy as well but the worker appeared to be the only one there - so that very much could have played a factor if she’s trying to do everything herself.“

“Rita ice cream lover for more than 20 years“

“I stopped by Johnson’s Ice Cream about 8 minutes before closing, and normally I avoid going into places that late. I really wanted to grab ice cream for myself, my nephew, and my brother, so I decided to go in anyway. Madi F, Charlotte, and Darren were in the middle of closing up, so I asked if it would be a problem if I ordered. Without hesitation, all three of them said no.

I ordered three small scoops, and they were incredibly kind the entire time. They even told me I was the easiest customer they’d had walk in during the last 10 minutes before closing, which I thought was so sweet. Charlotte reassured me by saying, “We’re still open, so no worries,” even though I kept apologizing more than I needed to. They stayed calm, friendly, and welcoming throughout the whole interaction.

Honestly, my first visit to this location wasn’t great, and I had decided I wouldn’t come back. The only reason I stopped in was because it was the only place open with cinnamon ice cream. But after this experience, I will absolutely be returning.

Darren (who I understand is a lead), Charlotte, and Madi F completely changed my impression of this location. If someone higher up sees this, please recognize them they made a lasting impact. I was planning to go to the Pickerington location instead, but because of this team, I’ll be coming back here.

Thank you again to Charlotte, Madi F, and Darren for being so kind and professional.

Oh yeah, the ice cream was delicious as always! The facility was also very clean too.“

“Cute little latin place to get ice cream and tropical fruts like rambutan, manguitos verdes, nance, chirimolla, cirguela verde and more.You can find ice cream flavors like mango, mamey, pistacho, maracuya, strawberry, gancito, horchata and more flavors.This is place is not big, it has only 4 tables but it's a hidden gem.“

“Best frozen custard around! Great staff too!“

“Went on 04/18 - actually just left. I have a tree nut allergy and asked for a snickers whitsard. After sitting down to wait for our ice cream a girl came up and said they were out of snickers in the back they use for allergens. They brought me a list of candies they could use with ingredients lists and then when I got my icecream they brought extra candies and were kind the entire time. This is a severe anaphylactic allergy so I often have anxiety about it but these girls were awesome I’ve never encountered staff that take my allergy so seriously. Idk give them a raise or something all of them were great. Thank u.“

“I visit my family in Columbus Ohio and live in Boston. And every time I arrive, I cannot come without eating several mangonadas. I want to tell you that if you want to try something good, visit this place. Everything is delicious, but especially the famous mangonada. It's my favorite, I love that mango flavor and I haven't been able to find a flavor like it. And in fact I had the opportunity to meet the very kind owner of the place. I told her how much I liked mangonadas and I asked her to sell me some plastic containers so I could bring fried mangonadas to Boston. And it arrived in excellent condition. He gave me a good and fair price. Thank you!“

“Delicious! Cookie dough is my favorite. The best deal is the grab and go quart. Highly recommend!“