6 Best Italian Restaurants in Lancaster

“Consistently delicious pizza!“

“We were out to celebrate a special occasion and decided to make a dinner reservation at Alfonso's. So very happy we did! Love the vibes of a pastime meshed with the revamping they have going on! Background music was fun...Fly Me to the Moon, 4 Seasons, The Supremes! Waitress was fabulous! I had a Whiskey Sour, hubby a "Smoked" Old Fashioned. Then we started off with Stuffed Mushrooms...amazing! For our entrees, I went with the Chicken Marsala & he had the Chicken Parmesan. Both were so yummy! Everything was presented & displayed so well too! We ordered our desserts to go...Cheesecake & Bread Pudding, which we enjoyed later on at home. As with everything else we enjoyed earlier, the flavors were delicious! Thank you chef(s) & staff for making this a memory to cherish! We look forward to returning once again!“

“Love the food and love the atmosphere, but service needs work. Need to improve server attentiveness for in store diners and get on the food delivery platforms already. Takeout provides the same risk of food quality concerns. Abandoning an entire segment of customers seems like a mistake.“

“Came across this gem! Everything was delicious! Definitely will be coming back.“

“Got 2 awesome pizza from Whitehall Massey's on Wednesday! Perfectly baked and excellent!“

“Me and my girlfriend went here when we were spending the day together and it was legitimately the best food ever we've had in Lancaster ever. The ambience is amazing, the server (Jen) and the chef (Jeanie) were absolutely amazing everything is just 5 stars. The chicken parm, spicy lamb gyro, spinach feta dip, salad and soups were absolutely amazing! 10/10 can't wait to come back!“