16 Best American Restaurants in Middletown

“Good food but relatively small selection. Place is very unassuming, located in a mostly run down shopping center but the restaurant itself is vibrant and inviting. Service was great from the second we walked in. Corah, the server was genuinely amazing. Burgers were very good, fries were great! Pasta good but a bit overpriced. Will return for sure.“

“Tried the meadows for the first time tonight and loved our experience. The staff and owners were extremely kind, our food was delicious, it came out relatively quickly and was very hot. We loved the crab Rangoon and the Mongolian beef. We noticed they are closing temporarily on 3/22. We will definitely be coming back when it re-opens. It was great!“

“Great food, super service, friendly and very helpful staff. Love it !“

“Mockingbird's catered our event at the Windamere in September of 2023. Their food was fantastic, reasonably priced, and generous portions. The staff and their service were so good. We intend to use them again this year. You should too!!!!“

“Been a few years since I’ve stopped in and it’s just as good as I remember. Their Tuesday special (chicken on top of Greek pasta) was amazing, and always have to get their baklava for later- even though their floyeres is my personal favorite when they have it for holidays.“

“I had the opportunity to try Turkeys R us and really enjoyed the food. The mac and cheese, greens and smoked wings were delicious. The services was great and the staff was very friendly. I would recommend my friends and family try Turkeys R us. Amazing food and the prices are practical.“

“Food and Service excellent!!! The peanut butter burger is the Best burger I have ever had! Sounds weird but delicious!!“

“I love coming to the Madison Inn, it’s always a great time. Asia is my favorite bartender she great at what she does. She is the best part of the experience because she is entertaining and funny. It’s a very clean updated bar. If you’re hungry Mike will make you something delicious.“

“We appreciate the flexibility and great atmosphere Willie’s provides to our APA Family.“

“If you guys haven't stopped in lately please revisit. they are under new ownership and is and the owner MJ cooks great food. Try the grilled menu or fish! way better than fried. They are doing a lot to make the place nice inside and outside. They haven't changed the sign but it is not the same place. Clean food honestly cooked.“

“Hot and ready very good customer service food soo good“

“On Monday, June 3rd. The Middletown’s Police Chief along with others from the FOPA held a friendly competition. They had nominated 9 local restaurants in our “Best Burger in Middletown” showdown. Middletown’s own “Swire Inn” took home the WIN!!! They had entered the Swire Inn Burger. Harmonizing with goodness & singing to our souls. This burger was inviting & tantalizing. With a mouth-watering juicy look that stole the show. Cooked to perfection and topped with freshness by Chef Jason Kauffman. We want to thank The Swire Inn and all of our nominees for their continued support to our community and Middletown’s Police Department.“

“really Fun BAR,good BARTENDERS AND A GOOD HAPPY HOUR“

“Jess and Val were amazing! They made sure I was taken care of, even when I said they didn't need to! The drinks are amazing, food was tasty, but I came for the customer service and it's 1000% here!!! I'll be back guys! Thanks sooo much!!“

“Change your hours you close to early through the week“

“We have always had great service at this Buffalo Wild Wings in Middletown! Last night was no different. Our waitress was attentive and pleasant!“