8 Best American Restaurants near New Albany

Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern American • $
180 Market St, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings and Pepperoni Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Double Stacked Quesadilla
Baja Fish Tacos Plate
Double Nickel Salad
Rusty Bucket Wings
The Cuban Sandwich
Sweet Potato Fries
Deep-Fried Pickles
Soy Glazed Salmon

“We love this restaurant. The fried pickles are sooooo good.“

4.4 Superb209 Reviews
Elliot's Wood Fired Kitchen & Tap American • $$
266 E Main St, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Chicken Ranch Pizza
Fried Cheese Ravioli
Tex Mex Salad Bowl
French Onion Soup
Mr Pickle Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Fried Pickles
Cheese Pizza
Shrimp Tacos

“Great meatballs!!!! Love the pizza.“

4.4 Superb193 Reviews
The Goat New Albany American • $
7148 Town Market Ln E, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Sweet Potato Fries
Blue Cheese Burger
Nashvegas Burger
Hot Chicken Dip
The Goat Burrito
Brussels Sprouts
Side House Salad
Farmhouse Tots
Hen House Tacos

“We had a great time. Beautiful location, excellent coffee, seriously delicious food, friendly staff. We’re here from Wheeling,WV, but will DEFINITELY make the trip back!“

4.3 Superb252 Reviews
Firebirds Wood Fired Grill American • $$
6036 N Hamilton Rd, New Albany

“We always love Firebirds! Tonight we had to wait for a bit for our party of 8 even though we had a RSVP. This isn’t normal, and the manager comped some items for us to make up for it. We really appreciated that gesture! The food was amazing as always, the seasonal hot chocolate cinnamon roll was so yummy. I almost always get the filet and it’s cooked perfectly with the right amount of seasonings to enhance the flavor of the steak every time. Ethan was our server tonight and he was kind and very attentive! He made sure to get the littles’ food out ASAP which was great. Great dinner and great service on a busy Saturday night!“

4.4 Superb92 Reviews
Hudson 29 Kitchen + Drink Bar • $$$
260 Market St D, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Stuffed House Baked Butter Rolls
Pineapple Upside Down Cake Doughnuts
Cheese Stuffed Butter Rolls
Slow Roasted Prime Rib
Hudson 29 Cheeseburger
Sticky Toffee Pudding
Chicken Pappardelle
Wood Grilled Salmon
Pan Seared Scallops
Rigatoni Bolognese

“Lunch was yummy, service excellent. It was my first time there, but I’ll surely be back.“

4.2 Good611 Reviews
Roosters Chicken Wings • $
5511 New Albany Rd W, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Fried Chicken Sandwich
Onion Feathers
Boneless Wings
Dumpster Fries
Fried Pickles
Chicken Wings
Curly Fries
Dressing
Burger
Nachos

“08/15/2025 - First time visiting this Roosters with family and friends. It was very busy and the wait was about 30 minutes. I ordered their seasonal Blue Margarita that was very savory. I also ordered my favorite pizza of theirs which is the Buffalo Chicken Pizza which is always delicious. Great service from the hosts and our server. Nice size outdoor patio that you may also dine at (weather permitting). Standard franchise Roosters decor. Spacious parking with tight parking (usually in the evening). Decent prices. Enjoy.“

4.2 Good172 Reviews
City Barbeque Barbecue • $
6280 E Dublin Granville Rd, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Tenders and Fresh Cut Fries Smoked Turkey Sandwich and Hush Puppies
Nashville Hot Chicken and Fresh Cut Fries
Chipotle BBQ Sandwich and Beef Breasket
Pulled Chicken Brisket Plate
Beef Brisket Sandwich Pack
Baked Beans with Brisket
Baker's Dozen Cornbread
Green Beans with Bacon
Sandwich Pack Brisket
Pulled Pork and Ribs

“Came in for a late lunch and was blown away by the service. I had never been before and was given several samples to try to help make a decision on sides. Service was quick, food came out immediately, tasted great, and was well worth the price for the quality. Would definitely be back, especially to this location!“

4.2 Good141 Reviews
Bob Evans Family • $
5205 New Albany Rd, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Sausage and Eggs and Hash Browns
Double Cheese Pot Roast Dip
Reese's Peanut Butter Pie
The Everything Breakfast
Sausage Gravy & Biscuits
Golden Brown Home Fries
Steak & Eggs Benedict
Grilled Chicken Breast
Honey Butter Chicken
Gravy and Biscuits

“Dine-in service is consistently good this year, and the meals are perfectly cooked. On our last visit, there was no wait during peak lunch hours, and the waitress was fantastic: got our orders as soon as we sat, checked on us, brought drink refills before we were empty just because the food was coming, and had the plates out as soon as they were ready. We ordered breakfast, and everything was tasty.“

3.4 Good131 Reviews

You May Also Like