9 Best Italian Restaurants near New Carlisle

Franco the Foodie Comfort Food • $
120 Jefferson St, New Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Buttery Herb Single Serving Baguette
Full Buttery Herb Garlic Baguette
Slice Baguette - Single Serving
Chicken Parmigiana & Spaghetti
Garlic Butter Baguette Loaf
Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
Buttery Herb Full Baguette
White Cheese Manicotti
Spring Mix Side Salad
Chicken Marsala

“Excellent food and service! The garlic bread is to die for! Amazing desserts too! All so tasty! Chef Franco personally came out and talked with our table and made sure we were all satisfied with our meal. Will definitely be back!“

4.8 Superb97 Reviews
Carmelas Pizzeria Pizza • $
2015 S Dayton-Lakeview Rd, New Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Exra Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza
Gluten Free Pizza
Jalapeno Poppers
Chicken Tenders
Onion Chips
Baked Penne
Italian Sub
Breadsticks

“AWESOME pizza, subs, and atmosphere!“

3.8 Good91 Reviews
Fazoli's Italian • $
8341 Old Troy Pike, Huber Heights - 7.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Dozen Signature Garlic Breadsticks with Large Dipping Sauce
12 Signature Garlic Breadsticks with Large Dipping Sauce
NY Style Cheesecake Made by the Cheesecake Factory Bakery
Cheesecake Factory Bakery Cinnamon Roll Cheesecake
The Cheesecake Factory Bakery Pumpkin Cheesecake
Fresh-Tossed Pasta and\u0026 Oven-Baked Meal
Fresh-Tossed Pasta and& Oven-Baked Meal
Mike's Hot Honey Pizza Baked Spaghetti
Penne Romano with Italian Sausage
Crispy Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad

“I called 30 minutes ahead to warn that we were bringing a group of 33 people. They told us to go ahead and come and they could not have done better. We ordered, were served, and out in an hour! AMAZING SERVICE!! Great staff and management.“

4.6 Superb185 Reviews
The Spicy Sicilian Italian • $$
9 S 1st St, Tipp City - 7.78 miles

“We ate Spicy Sicilian at miami county fair. the food was wonderful.“

5 Superb5 Reviews
Flying Pig Tavern Italian • $
136 North 1st Street, Fairborn - 7.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Large Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Large Big Mac Pizza
Small Taco Pizza
Large Taco Pizza
Large BBQ Piggy
Supreme Pizza
Veggie Pizza
Meat Lovers

“One of the best tavern pizzas you can find in the Dayton area, for real. Perfect crust, plenty of toppings, taste was on point! Joes Pizzeria in Riverside gets all the pizza fame in the area but to me this tastes better and I never thought I'd say that because Joe's is really good. Jen was our bartender and did a phenomenal job. We'll definitely be back for more. 🍕“

4.6 Superb75 Reviews
Classic Pizza Pizza • $
7129 Taylorsville Rd, Dayton - 6.7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Double Pepperoni Pizza
Chopped Sirloin Sub
The Classic Pizza
Banana Peppers
Three Toppings
Garlic Wedges
Potato Skins
Breadsticks
Hamwich Sub

“Every time I have been here (a lot), I have been impressed. The food is excellent & the service is great. I would & have recommended this place. My very favorite!!!“

4.4 Superb119 Reviews
Giovanni's Pizza • $
215 W Main St, Fairborn - 7.9 miles

Customers` Favorites

Caesar Salad with Basil Grilled Chicken Breast
Bowtie Pasta in Alfredo Sauce
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Meat Lover’S Pizza
Garlic Cheese Bread
Shrimp Scampi Pasta
Fettuccine Alfredo
Chicken Alfredo
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza and Salad

“My favorite pizza in Dayton!“

4.2 Good259 Reviews
Godfather's Pizza Pizza • $
4628 Brandt Pike, Huber Heights - 9.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Large Specialty Pizza on Golden Crust Big Chocolate Chip Cookie
Humble Pie Pizza and Garlic Bread with Cheese
Meat Lovers Pizza Added Cheese
Pepperoni and Mushrooms Pizza
Cinnamon Monkey Bread
Godfathers Taco Pizza
Classic Combo Pizza
Supreme Taco Pizza
Super Combo Pizza
Patty Melt Pizza

“Great stop at the Godfather’s Pizza in Huber Heights. Service was quick, the place was clean, and the pizza came out hot and tasted great.

They checked on us multiple times and kept the refills coming, which was appreciated and made the whole visit feel relaxed and easy.
One small odd thing - the cheese and bacon pizza had full bacon slices instead of crumbles, which was a little unexpected. Not a deal breaker, just different.

I ordered the cinnamon dessert pizza thinking we would share. That was a lie I told myself, its Fire!!

We paired this with a trip to the Air Force Museum and it made for a really nice outing on a cold day. Would definitely stop again.“

4.2 Good220 Reviews
A Slice of Heaven Pizzeria Pizza Delivery • $
17 N Xenia Dr, Enon - 6.15 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza

“My family loves this pizza. We did a pizza taste test with pizzas from other highly recommended pizza places in the area and my whole family agreed Slice of Heaven was hands down the best!“

4.1 Good45 Reviews

You May Also Like