40 Best Italian Restaurants near Centerville

“Absolutely love this place! I stop in every chance I get. Everything I’ve had is delicious but my favorite is their pizza and homemade salad dressing! Highly recommend!“

“This ranks in the top tier of pizzas I have had, and I feel like the only think keeping me from giving it a 5 (I wish I could do 4.9) is the hot honey. I ordered the angry beekeepers w/extra hot honey, and the hot honey is too subtle to taste. I really wanted that sweet heat to come through, but it was invisible to the taste even ordering extra. That being said, the fresh Mozz, salami, and basil with the wood fire crust made for a sublime pizza experience. We're over the road, and we hunt for indie pizza shops, and this easily falls in the top 5 (not counting Chicago style pizzas in the ranking. That's a pizza to itself). The server at carry out was very pleasant, and checked the pizza before giving it to me, and that was a nice extra touch. Overall, Old Scratch is no joke. Experts in the pizza game. Among a highly competitive market, they stand above most. I can't wait to eat here again.“

“First time here and food and service were excellent. I was also excited because they had no music which I consider noise pollution when I am trying to have a conversation with a friend. The server told us this was because they forgot to turn it on. PLEASE, keep it off. It was wonderful. I go to a restaurant to enjoy food and conversation, not to listen to a concert.“

“Came for the Happy Hour in the bar area. Steve greeted us quickly and was the perfect happy hour host. The martini’s were superb, and he provided useful info on the food (burger temp). We live in Beavercreek and plan to drive back down regularly… management can thank Steve!“

“What can I not say about this place. After growing up in Centerville, I now live in Columbus. I almost always go to Marion’s when I am in town and get a pizza to go. Crust and toppings are still the same as they were 30 years ago. This particular location was closest to my home, and I still have great memories of playing The Simpsons and Street Fighter while waiting for the pizza to come. Just had some this past week and it was still great. Still can’t find anything in Columbus that comes close.“

“Absolutely amazing pizza that is always up to my high standards. I get my delivery orders hot fresh and delivered with purpose and I like that so I tip well because the pizza guy runs around and puts a lot of wear and tear to get me my pizza and I appreciate that so I try to show them I appreciation through sufficient and appreciative tips cuz he comes rain or shine snow or sleet and I can stay at home nice and warm while he risks his life delivering in adverse conditions“

“Best Italian cuisine in town!“

“It has wonderful Service. really it’s an amazing place to eat! I love it“

“just had a sausage and onion pizza and it was sooo good! Such a cozy little restaurant with friendly service!“

“I used to come to Fazoli's as a kid with my parents, their garlic breadsticks and pasta are just as good as my nostalgia remembered, I wish there was a Cincinnati location. And big thanks to Tina for making our dining experience very positive!“

“Best pizza ? ever Best Italian food ever“

“Good Food & decent prices 💰💰“

“Mist recent last week Chicken parmigiana, just sooooooo excellent and chicken melt in your mouth!! Husband ordered their Meats Pizza. So very good. We split our courses and still had enough to take home for next day lunch!! Staff very personable and attentive. Can not say enough of their excellent quality and presentation of their most delicious food. Tried their variety of meals, all superb!!“

“Always love their food and service ❤️❤️“

“Edi Mae approved ✅ Only complaint is the cashier was very rude and acted like we were stupid because we had questions. Can’t remember her name but she had short blonde hair.“

“I am 1st generation Italian...I LOVE THEIR FOOD!!“

“This was my 1st time here and I already am planning my next visit! I loved our waitress Jamie! She was amazing! 5 stars meal! We got the Mo special and it was DELICIOUS! 🤤 so happy to support a local restaurant!“

“I was born and raised in Italy, I was also a waitress there and served many pizzas. Troni is by far the closest to authentic Italian pizzas in the entire area. Absolutely delicious and well priced. Our family has always enjoyed it as well as the service.“

“best pizza in town hands down.“

“This location is absolutely horrible like the workers hate their job so bad they are always rude. The manager was so rude with me. He didn’t care that. I said I would leave a negative review. He made them charge me for a large bowl when I got a small bowl just because I wanted a little more noodles. I’ve been going to this location for over 10 years literally when they first opened only reason I came back cause I start working somewhere that was close to them again now I drive the extra 20 minutes to the Miamisburg location where I’m always treated like a valuable customer Stroop location would never give me sugar from the back for my lemonade, claiming they didn’t have any, but the Miamisburg location gives me a small container of sugar every time with no problem I hate this location and I will never return“

“They’re giving back to their community in a tremendous way. That’s honorable and worthy of recognition.“

“We hardly ever go out to eat, but wow was this experience incredible!

We had a back room with plenty of table space to not be on top of each other!

Our server, Roo, was phenomenal, she went over the top on service! She was kind, patient, didn't rush us, and was even wonderful with the kids!

Thankful to have had a great experience at Olive garden on father's day!

Great food, great service, plenty of parking, quite atmosphere, and friendly staff!

Well done!“

“Delicious homemade sauces 😍“

“Decor is cool inside. Food was very good, maybe a bit pricey for some items but overall good. *NOTE* They have a Negroni cocktail hour from 4:30-6:30 IF YOU SIT AT THE BAR. It was our first time there so we ordered a couple at the table and found out later sitting at the table does not count. The waitress was going to try and give us the drinks for that rate but it didn’t happen. I wouldn’t have ordered the $25 appetizer knowing the drinks were that much. Lessons learned I guess. I would go again, but just be more cautious on what I order is all ☺️“

“Simply the Best! Food, service and atmosphere is always top notch.“

“Just good food and great service! ❤️“

“I was driving by and saw the Little Caesars sign and thought that would be a good treat for my drive home after a long day.

Shout out to Rachel who offered to make me a fresh pizza 15 mins before close. I work in a service industry. There is a lot of bad customer service these days but she was polite and friendly and accommodating.

Good pizza with a smile, can't beat that! Made my 1.5 hr drive home that much better.“

“Ok so we’ve dined at Old Scratch Troy location about 6 times since it’s opened. Waited a bit to give them time to really get in their groove. While I do recommend the place. Pizza is good, staff is nice (especially Amanda at the bar) and shareables are tasty. That said I would like to see the food’s taste be a little more consistent. My favorite dish is the fire roasted cauliflower but sadly it hasn’t been prepared the same way twice with the last two times it was barely seasoned at all once it was almost raw. Hopefully as training continues they will fix that issue.“

“The Absolute best Italian Deli in Ohio. The most delicious Sandwiches and Salads ever. Along with Amazing entries, and delectable pastries and desserts. Ownership and staff that treat you like family make Disalvo's Deli a Kettering landmark and my favorite place to eat when I'm in town!! My highest recommendation!“

“Detroit style pizza, nuff said. This place has made me second guess whether I love NY style or Detroit style. Getting a four corners can feed four people. The slices are huge amd fairly priced.
Also, the crew is always on point and friendly.“

“We had lunch on Saturday and as usual all of our meals were delicious! Our server Karugu was fantastic!! Friendly, efficient, quick to refill our drinks with a great smile! We started off with pretzel bites, hot and delicious! Started off with cups of gumbo, perfect on a cold rainy day! Great soup loaded with shrimp, chicken and sausage. Then the 4 of us had deluxe pizza, a tuna melt, chicken quesadilla and the Italian sub. Everything was great. The pizza crust was crispy and light. Perfect!“

“Today's food was great. My order was taken and served in a timely manner. After that, service became very lacking. I sat at the bar and was the only patron dining in. Another person came in, sat beside me and was ignored for a long amount of time. With the bar in close sight and plain view from the kitchen/prep area, it still took both of us calling to that area to get someone's attention. I was not brought my bill at any point of the duration of my visit, and had to ask for it, again with lack of attention from the prep area. Charging a fee for credit/debt transactions may seem needed, but it is not acceptable or fair. Because of that, although it's not fair to the servers, I am subtracting that fee amount from my tip with any place doing this now. It's within your control to opt for those charges. $3.49 is also an excessive and unfair price for a fountain drink when other establishment charge up to a dollar less ... and especially when yours is a self service station.“

“Come with family, come on a date, or come by yourself the food is so good! I have tries mamy pasta dishes and I am happy to say I have loved them all. The Drunken Shrimp is my favorite pasta dish that has a nice kick and tons of flavor. The Linguine Bolognese is so good, the Shrimp Scampi is light and tasty, and even the classic Spaghetti and Meatballs is good. I have not personally had the pizza but my mom raves about it. She customizes her pizza each time or orders the special and has never been disappointed with what she gets. She also recommends the espresso martinis. Great food, lovely place, great service and a must try for the area. I promise you won't be disappointed and order the choclate mousse for dessert.“

“I ordered Popcorn Chicken however it wasn't until I got home it was replaced with a small amount of grilled chicken...nobody told me they ran out of Popcorn Chicken otherwise I wouldn't of ordered. I did call store and was offered a $5 credit on next order however the meal cost more than that and I rarely eat pizza 🤷 so I would of preferred a refund or replacement. Pizza was ok but most got thrown in trash so waste of money. Brownies were a bit hard but if warmed up they were ok.“

“I've lived in the Dayton area for 34 years and never tried gioninos until last week. I've since ordered it 3 times and have been extremely happy with all 3 purchases. This is the best pizza I've found in Dayton. The option to add basil is a game changer. Anything with red sauce should have basil on it, period. No other pizzeria that I know of offers it. You've got a new loyal customer!“

“Food was so good we forgot to take a picture before we devoured it! One guy running the place and he was great, smiling and polite. Food was fresh, nice and crispy crust, zero flop! If you watch barstool pizza you know what I mean! Sauces are really good too! I had the 11” thin crust with garlic sauce, pepperoni, ground beef, onions, mushrooms and olives for 10 bucks. Cant beat it, great value!“

“I’ve decided Jet’s pizza is the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life! Love it! Outstanding!“

“Ordered delivery which they said would be an hour. Called one and a half hours later to enquire about order. Without hesitation they checked, said it was on the way and that it would now be discounted. Love the customer service with giving a discount without having to ask.“

“Yummy Hawaiian pizza style I’ll buy more soon“

“The Turin trio was awesome. Huge portions, free soar dough bread(2) with butter spread. Good prices for what you get. Cool interior with an actual trolley car inside. Very nice staff also. Highly recommend this place.“