17 Best Ice Cream Shops near New Middletown

“Sitting in their drive-thru for 30 minutes really brings out the joy in you. Plus when they steady interrupt as you order is the cherry on top of the half melted sunday.. I miss the 90something year olds who used to work there in the 90s. The had zero problems. Yay teenagers!“

“We were visiting from AZ and were excited to see a Handel’s here. The service here was outstanding. We were able to sample various flavors before buying the 4 scoop sampler. It was the perfect amount of ice cream for both of us. I highly recommend this place if you are looking for the best ice cream.“

“Hello,

Fantastic ice cream but this location seems to have considerably less toppings in the ice cream than other locations. I got rocky mocha blast the other day and there was like 3 cookie doughs in the pint :( .

Thank you,
James“

“Your milkshakes are SO good! Thank you for all the goodies 🍦“

“Best ice cream. If you like blizzards, you will love a hurricane from Handel's. And this location specifically does not skimp out on ice cream or toppings! Area can been a little sketchy but I'll risk it for a brownie hurricane any day.“

“This is hands down the best ice cream we have EVER had! We will definitely be back....a lot!“

“We got subs there today. They were delicious. The ice cream was delicious. We love to place a friend and I we went two hours to see an Eagles nest on Lipply rd. We stopped going and we stopped coming back. And we shall be back when we come back over.“

“This place has some amazing ice cream thats not quite ice cream😂 our youth group absolutely loves this place but we never get done with small group on Wednesday in time to go there cause it closes at 9 on Wednesday 😢
one thing hey Could do is make it so that is closes at 10 every night. That would be greatly appreciated by so many!“

“I got the delicious abomination of a grape sundae complete with marshmallow and extra whipped cream. I don't usually care much for ice cream, much less finish it, but I ate every drop and would've eaten another. Handel's has been a popular stop since I was a child and even as an adult who has lived abroad, I still keep coming back!“

“What an amazing selection! Worth the trip if you can get here!“

“I told my husband how fast, friendly, and accurate the drive-thru is. Exceptionally so. We bypass the closer ones because they aren't as consistent. He decided to go there to see. He said now he gets why I keep raving about this location. This is our preferred weekly ice cream destination, and yes, I mean over Handels as well. Great work, Boardman!“

“Visited for their Valentine’s Day dinner event this evening. Super cute idea! Wonderful setting and service. Colleen an awesome job serving everyone and the rest of the staff was great keeping up with being extra busy 💗“

“Quick drive through service. great food, friendly employees.“

“Food and service were excellent, and I get that corporate sales want to put a samwhich in a box to make it look prestigious but as an on-the-go style food is the most unpractical thing on this planet in the modern world. Corporations really need to start atleast half wrapping the burgers that they put in these boxes so that they are edible without sitting down at a table.“

“We went here after dinner from the restaurant next door . My Hubby doesn't like yogurt so I mixed a variety of flavors and one topping with hot fudge . We took it home so he could have his ice cream . lol It was so yummy , especially liked the orange , with the chocolate and coffee . I had the mint chocolate chips with it ; I made a wonderful choice . It was the first time I have been here and it won't be the last ! lol The Mom and daughter team are great and very friendly ! THANK YOU ! Oh they also have Hot Cocoa Bombs to buy there ! ❤️❤️❤️❤️“

“I haven’t been to a DQ for a while. Came in for their chicken strips. These were really good, better than I remembered. The best part was the staff. These were the friendliest group of people I’ve run across in a really long time. Thank you DQ!!“