50 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Middletown

“We highly enjoy ordering pepperoni rolls from here. They are top-notch, and when it's the daily special, incredibly worth the money. Even on regular days, you get enough food for the value - which is hard to find. Thank you for the consistency and great value!“

“Their pizza is spectacular… when judging Youngstown pizza you gotta put them up there with the other 2 spots .. Definitely a hidden gem and now my go to spot. 😋“

“First time & can't believe it took me this long , I'm not big on pizza but when I crave it I try & find the best & I think I don't have to look or go far now 6 mins 😁 sauce tab but sweet ,But 👍🏼 deliciosio“

“BEST PIZZA EVER, NO ONE COMPARES TO THEM. GREAT PEOPLE THAT OWN IT. SASUAGE SANDWICH SO GOOD AND ALSO YOU CAN BUY BREAD AND ROLLS TO GO. I ALWAYS GET LIGHT ON THE SAUCE ON PIZZA. AND ANOTHER GREAT PIZZA IS THW WHITE PIZZA WITH MILD PEPPER RINGS AND SAUSAGE. BEEN GOIMG THERE FOR OVER 10 YEARS. IF U ARE AROUND THERE STOP IN AMD PLACE AN ORDER TO GO THERE IS NO SEATING INSIDE HOWEVER THAT DIDNT STOP US FEOM EATING THAT WHITE PIZZA ON THE CAR RIDE HOME.“

“THE BEST BLT anywhere!! Lots of thick bacon, lettuce and tomatoes on focaccia bread. I said what I said. If I lived closer, I could stop here almost daily.“

“Best pizza in town!✅😃😃😃👍🏼💕“

“Always delicious. Enjoy it every time we order. Highly recommend Poland Cornersburg.“

“I want to say that I am a certified gluten-free practitioner. I have ben gluten-free for over 20 years. I have tried many gluten-free pizzas over the years. I can honestly say it was the best gluten free pizza I have ever eaten. The pizza crust was phenomenal. I highly recommend this 5 star gluten free pizza. Try it you won’t be disappointed.“

“My bowling team were always treated with courtesy and respect. And delicious food.“

“First time here with a group over 10 people. Staff was excellent handling our large group. Orders were accurate, and the quality of the food was very good. Everyone was happy with their choices. Drinks replenished quickly. Overall, it was a great place for a family dinner.“

“The pizza here is Delicious! A great staple to the Youngstown area! I ordered the vegetable and pineapple pizza, and my family devoured both! Pepperoni rolls are fantastic! Little Milly's is where you want to go if you love really good, authentic pizza! Thanks for the love you put in your food 😁“

“Oh so good. Thick style, a lil sweet sauce smothered in cheese. Spinning bowl salad to start n share bc so big, and some homemade nut kolachi to finish. Q rapid service, quite delightful when the owner came out w fried dough in sugar, complementary. ❤️🖤🤍 YSU.“

“Delicious food, awesome owners and staff!“

“First of all, welcome to historic and homey! This place is our go to for some awesome pizza!!! They have a great selection of food and beers. The atmosphere, side conversations, and of course on the bartenders, MAGGIE, are absolutely something to experience. One app recommendation would be the hot pepper cheese balls! Also the pizza sauce is made with green peppers, so be prepared for flavor. This place is ALSO from 1945. So stop, love it, come back.“

“I grew up in the 70’s and 80’s, and I have been searching for a pizza shop that tastes like the Ole Days. The ones who used to make their own pizza sauce, and the crust was so good, that it made you crave more. I was told about Westgate in Boardman, so I gave it a try today. From the time I walked in, to the time I left, the gals working were very friendly and polite, and was very helpful with suggestions of things I would like to try out. Everything on the menu looked amazing. I went with a pizza with pepperoni, and 6 BBQ wings. I suffered on the way home to Leetonia, windows mostly up due to a rainy day, so got plenty of the smells of the pizza and wings on the commute. Once home, I was finally able to dig into. Words can’t describe how good the food was. The pizza was delicious just like the Ole Days, from the crust to the topping of cheese and fresh pepperoni. The wings were just as delicious. The sauce of both were spot on. The cheese on the pizza wasn’t heavy nor light, a perfect balance between the crust and sauce. So if you’re looking for a great place for pizza, subs, and wings. I’ll say the hardest part about eating here is not taking a nap afterwards, small joke. Very filling and definitely worth the drive and price. Thank you for the great experience. My #1 go to pizza shop now.“

“Best pickle pizza in town!“

“Every single time the manager at the Pizza Joe's in East Palestine messes up on your order by 100% if his own fault“

“Everything was delicious that we brought home last night! We grabbed a couple assorted slices, pepperoni roll, and large house salad which is always loaded with toppings and cheese! We don’t order out much, as we enjoy cooking at home and also to save some money, but it was definitely a treat and worth every penny! Thank you for offering another great pizza choice in Struthers!“

“Tried their pizza for the first time today. AMAZING. Best pizza in Boardman.“

“Our lil one had a birthday.. Everyone made her feel special.. We played until passed close.. Thank you to the Manager and all the employees that allowed her and her daddy to play just a lil longer.. It truly means the world to me! We will be back, absolutely because of the was we were treated! Like family! Thank you so much Everyone!

Kid-friendliness: Absolutely!!

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes!“

“stopped in to get a spinach roll best I've ever ate!!“

“Food was good, food was hot, not overpriced“

“Great pizza and service. The owner is super nice. They have really good crust and gluten free options. Definitely will order again!“

“Been a fan of their pizza since I was a kid. Love the food. Under new ownership and Matt is still holding up the reputation.“

“What an amazing selection! Worth the trip if you can get here!“

“Oh so good. Thick style, a lil sweet sauce smothered in cheese. Spinning bowl salad to start n share bc so big, and some homemade nut kolachi to finish. Q rapid service, quite delightful when the owner came out w fried dough in sugar, complementary. ❤️🖤🤍 YSU.“

“Love everything about this place, including the record store. Kudos!“

“Best pizza in all Ohio. The owner and his family there are very friendly.“

“Best pizza in Ohio. Crust is great, sauce is great, sausage is great, peppers are great. Super friendly staff. Great overall experience. I will get their pizza every time I am in the area“

“always delicious consistency for years“

“we had a large party tonight and the staff was awesome and the food was so good. it was the first time being there also“

“The food is delicious!. The establishment was clean and service was great! Their sauce is to die for:.Much better then some of your more expensive Restaurants. We will be back soon! P.S. You should advertise that your under new ownership!?“

“Usually friendly service, I'm not sure if the waitress was having an off day but I sat for 15 minutes before I was even asked if I was waiting on anyone or wanted a drink. I ordered an appetizer and it took 20 minutes. 3 couples who came in after me have already been served. I told her I wanted to order and she disappeared. I asked on the status of my appetizer when she reappeared and she said that takes 10 minutes. I said okay, it was at least 15 minutes ago. So far I've been here at least 35 minutes and have just ordered my pizza at 2:08pm. My pizza didn't arrive until 2:32 . The food is good but the service certainly doesn't match. I think in the future we will frequent another location.“

“I loved everything about this place. It's been a long time since I've been so completely satisfied with a pizza place experience, and everything about this one was so incredibly perfect. We ordered the spinach Italiano and I highly recommend it. The entire pizza was cooked golden brown yet not over or under done, just absolute perfection. This place really hit the spot.“

“One of, if not the best pizzas I have had in a long time. The delivery team member was prompt, attentive to the delivery instructions, and courteous. Great experience, so give them a try. This pizza is Candy approved, 5 out of 5 stars would recommend.“

“We received a care package from my sister. The pizza is great! Super light and great flavor. What a nice surprise! Spicy mother cluckha oh yeah!“

“Friendly staff and tastey food“

“This is the East coast, eastern Midwest version of MOD Pizza. They serve made to order personal pizzas. You get exactly what you want on your pizza, and yes, they do have pineapple. Excellent pizza at a good price, ready in under 5 minutes. The only thing they could improve would be to add a little garlic to their sauce! My wife and I will definable be going back (regularly).“

“I ordered a Philly beef sandwich & my son got the grilled chicken sandwich, they were big & delicious! They gave more than enough fries & onion rings too! Our waitress was very kind & attentive. We needed takeout containers because we couldn't that much food!! Very reasonably priced even if you're on a budget.“

“The food is always amazing. It's always fresh, and the wait is never long unless you have a big order. This business is a family run establishment, and everyone you come in contact with is so amazing. My favorite meal it the spicy chicken Tika over rice (Comes with a salad), my next is the lamb gyro (extra sauce) lol, and last but not least the chicken wing dings and the nuggets are really really good. They have a wider menu variety, and everything is top tier 😋“

“This is one extremely clean & beautiful Pizza Hut located in Columbiana. We also had an exceptional waiter who was quick, efficient & friendly. We loved the specials that they offer for dinner. 2 fountain drinks, 1 medium pizza & bread sticks for $20. I opted to spend a few more dollars for the modest salad bar. Oh, and I ordered the brownies as well. Turned out to be a fast dinner that allowed us to relax the rest of the evening at home.

Parking: Parking is right outside the building

Kid-friendliness: Great place to take the family & it’s extremely clean restaurant“

“was there the other day and forgot to post. Wonderful flavors and great service!“

“We ordered 2 pizzas tonight, everyone was saying how good they were, and going back for another slice! We will be back!“

“Been getting our wings n pizza here for a long long time and never had a bad pizza or wings....BUT today 5/10/20...mothers day I felt like pizza n wings..this is 1st time I was dissatisfied...spinach on pizza was not rinsed well was very bitter n still soggy...couldn't find the salami...not sure why it happened.“

“We love Papa GeGe’s and the staff AND the food. The food is AMAZING. We love that it’s a BYOB. I think the veal Parmesan is the best I have ever had. I ordered it twice. The soup is amazing. We really enjoyed the cannoli. Beast Italian food around, hands down!!!“

“I would say get there early 4ish...food & service was wonderful...more than we could eat...extra food for daughter who worked late...our server Davidson was awesome,attentive, took very good care of us...Mgr walked over & asked how things were...everything was perfect...highly recommend...I had peppers in oil, salad, eggplant w/spaghetti...hubby had salad,pork chops w/baked potato & cheese cake...“

“Game night, so We had to give their garlic stuffed crust a try.5 STARS! WTG! Fantastic!! Don't change a thing.There was plenty enough cheese in the crust & on top, & the flavor was excellent!But, I always have to take a pizza home & doctor it up. We throw some pieces into the toaster oven & cook it till the top & bottom gets extra toasty & crunchy brown! Then I added a layer of our home made HOT tomato peppers on top.BTW,,, The sale introduction price made this pizza worth it. I would never buy one at full price.“

“This place is great, highly recommend!!“

“Fast delievery and friendly drivers“