50 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Middletown

“We had a wonderful experience here. Jill and Dev were shorthanded with lots of orders. They made our food with lots of care as quickly as they could. Jill was gracious and pleasant and our food was hot, fresh and tasty. We will absolutely be back!“

“BEST PIZZA EVER, NO ONE COMPARES TO THEM. GREAT PEOPLE THAT OWN IT. SASUAGE SANDWICH SO GOOD AND ALSO YOU CAN BUY BREAD AND ROLLS TO GO. I ALWAYS GET LIGHT ON THE SAUCE ON PIZZA. AND ANOTHER GREAT PIZZA IS THW WHITE PIZZA WITH MILD PEPPER RINGS AND SAUSAGE. BEEN GOIMG THERE FOR OVER 10 YEARS. IF U ARE AROUND THERE STOP IN AMD PLACE AN ORDER TO GO THERE IS NO SEATING INSIDE HOWEVER THAT DIDNT STOP US FEOM EATING THAT WHITE PIZZA ON THE CAR RIDE HOME.“

“Their pizza is spectacular… when judging Youngstown pizza you gotta put them up there with the other 2 spots .. Definitely a hidden gem and now my go to spot. 😋“

“Always delicious. Enjoy it every time we order. Highly recommend Poland Cornersburg.“

“THE BEST BLT anywhere!! Lots of thick bacon, lettuce and tomatoes on focaccia bread. I said what I said. If I lived closer, I could stop here almost daily.“

“Delicious food, awesome owners and staff!“

“I want to say that I am a certified gluten-free practitioner. I have ben gluten-free for over 20 years. I have tried many gluten-free pizzas over the years. I can honestly say it was the best gluten free pizza I have ever eaten. The pizza crust was phenomenal. I highly recommend this 5 star gluten free pizza. Try it you won’t be disappointed.“

“We absolutely love Brier Hill Pizza. We were on a mission to try a bunch of local pizza places. Then we got to Brier Hill and we just... stopped. We don't think anything will top this pizza for us, so why try? The owners are soooo kind and it just makes the whole experience one we want to keep repeating.“

“What an amazing selection! Worth the trip if you can get here!“

“Really tasty, yet super cheap pizza is available here!!!!!!! Its pretty dang good, and 5 bucks for this whole pizza is a deal you just can't beat. Its definitely not the highest quality pizza, but for 5 dollars you honestly cannot complain. The service was really quick and speedy, definitely a great pizza shop!!!!“

“Oh so good. Thick style, a lil sweet sauce smothered in cheese. Spinning bowl salad to start n share bc so big, and some homemade nut kolachi to finish. Q rapid service, quite delightful when the owner came out w fried dough in sugar, complementary. ❤️🖤🤍 YSU.“

“Best pizza in Ohio. Crust is great, sauce is great, sausage is great, peppers are great. Super friendly staff. Great overall experience. I will get their pizza every time I am in the area“

“stopped in to get a spinach roll best I've ever ate!!“

“Had the fish dinner with pierogi and mac and cheese. Also got a pizza to go. The fish and Mac and cheese were excellent (best fish I’ve had in a long time). Pierogi was good, onions could have been cooked a little longer. Pizza was excellent as always.“

“Every single time the manager at the Pizza Joe's in East Palestine messes up on your order by 100% if his own fault“

“Best pizza in town!✅😃😃😃👍🏼💕“

“Best pickle pizza in town!“

“I grew up in the 70’s and 80’s, and I have been searching for a pizza shop that tastes like the Ole Days. The ones who used to make their own pizza sauce, and the crust was so good, that it made you crave more. I was told about Westgate in Boardman, so I gave it a try today. From the time I walked in, to the time I left, the gals working were very friendly and polite, and was very helpful with suggestions of things I would like to try out. Everything on the menu looked amazing. I went with a pizza with pepperoni, and 6 BBQ wings. I suffered on the way home to Leetonia, windows mostly up due to a rainy day, so got plenty of the smells of the pizza and wings on the commute. Once home, I was finally able to dig into. Words can’t describe how good the food was. The pizza was delicious just like the Ole Days, from the crust to the topping of cheese and fresh pepperoni. The wings were just as delicious. The sauce of both were spot on. The cheese on the pizza wasn’t heavy nor light, a perfect balance between the crust and sauce. So if you’re looking for a great place for pizza, subs, and wings. I’ll say the hardest part about eating here is not taking a nap afterwards, small joke. Very filling and definitely worth the drive and price. Thank you for the great experience. My #1 go to pizza shop now.“

“My bowling team were always treated with courtesy and respect. And delicious food.“

“Always a great experience! Whether we’re grabbing takeout or eating at the bar on the Bruno side, it’s always enjoyable. The service is consistently great and everyone is so friendly.

We usually stick with our tried-and-true NY-style cheese pizza, but we stopped in yesterday for a quick lunch and noticed the gentleman next to us had a slice that looked unreal, unlike anything I’d ever seen. He couldn’t stop raving about it, so we decided to try it too.

We went with the Detroit-style pizza with pepperoni and hot honey, and it was absolutely amazing. The crunchy crust with the soft, fluffy inside was the perfect balance. And the pepperoni with the hot honey… seriously drool-worthy. I can’t stop thinking about it. I may have to order a whole pizza today!

Such a great locally owned place.“

“excellent pizza ! drove by for months and finally tried it! now we get it atleast once a week! give it a try!!!“

“Love everything about this place, including the record store. Kudos!“

“Best pizza in all Ohio. The owner and his family there are very friendly.“

“Been a fan of their pizza since I was a kid. Love the food. Under new ownership and Matt is still holding up the reputation.“

“Great staff and always gets my order on point! Thank you for always being great! The delivery drivers are some hard workers and get it done!! 🙏 big thanks to the cooks for making the best pizza around! Top 3 domino's location in my opinion and I've been to many states and I only order from domino's! 💪“

“Usually friendly service, I'm not sure if the waitress was having an off day but I sat for 15 minutes before I was even asked if I was waiting on anyone or wanted a drink. I ordered an appetizer and it took 20 minutes. 3 couples who came in after me have already been served. I told her I wanted to order and she disappeared. I asked on the status of my appetizer when she reappeared and she said that takes 10 minutes. I said okay, it was at least 15 minutes ago. So far I've been here at least 35 minutes and have just ordered my pizza at 2:08pm. My pizza didn't arrive until 2:32 . The food is good but the service certainly doesn't match. I think in the future we will frequent another location.“

“Food was good, food was hot, not overpriced“

“Great pizza! Sauce was very good and the pizza baked perfectly. Only downfall was the size of the pies. We're a family of 4 (two which are teens) and we had just enough ordering 2 pies. My fault was not asking the size. Also note, to get in to the pizza pickup spot, go to the bar entrance, ring the bell and when the door opens, go into the kitchen located on the left just as you walk in.“

“i don't give many 5 star reviews but the fun pass is a hit for my high energy son. I still feel like taking out the animatronics was unnecessary. Also, the trampoline is nice but you need to figure out a way to add a skywalk with a ball pit attached. If you could add diet code red mountain dew or regular to your soda machines you might see us everyday 😅👍🏾“

“food is always delicious. Great prices and a large menu selection. highly recommend.“

“I loved everything about this place. It's been a long time since I've been so completely satisfied with a pizza place experience, and everything about this one was so incredibly perfect. We ordered the spinach Italiano and I highly recommend it. The entire pizza was cooked golden brown yet not over or under done, just absolute perfection. This place really hit the spot.“

“I ordered a Philly beef sandwich & my son got the grilled chicken sandwich, they were big & delicious! They gave more than enough fries & onion rings too! Our waitress was very kind & attentive. We needed takeout containers because we couldn't that much food!! Very reasonably priced even if you're on a budget.“

“I came in as a Door Dasher and the staff was very nice and generous to me. They even gave me a free slice of pizza they have at the front counter. This location deserves more business than it's getting..Thank you to the owner and his staff for having a very welcoming environment 😁“

“I order my food the lady was in a rush and kept interrupting me and they forgot part of my order did not know I told it was delivered so had to go back out to pick up dinner for my daughter told them and they wanted to charge me a delivery fee again for their mess will never eat here again“

“We received a care package from my sister. The pizza is great! Super light and great flavor. What a nice surprise! Spicy mother cluckha oh yeah!“

“Hands down the best thing I’ve ever eaten“

“This is our go to Friday dinner. The service and employees are friendly and phenomenal. This is probably my favorite crust in the area. The Cocoas in Poland is by far my favorite and will not go to any of the others. Had Boardman before and it was burnt.“

“This place is great, highly recommend!!“

“was there the other day and forgot to post. Wonderful flavors and great service!“

“Hard-working people! Gets very busy at times like the weekends but they keep up with it if they have enough on staff. The regular workers that have been there longer do a great job but if the new ones are there by themselves without the regular workers, it's a nightmare and the food sucks.“

“Thank you for hosting our wedding reception! The food was amazing! The space was lovely and your staff were pros! So accommodating, flexible and had great ideas! Thank you for helping to decorate, serve our guests and tear down! I highly recommend this restaurant and staff for your large party needs♥️“

“We love Papa GeGe’s and the staff AND the food. The food is AMAZING. We love that it’s a BYOB. I think the veal Parmesan is the best I have ever had. I ordered it twice. The soup is amazing. We really enjoyed the cannoli. Beast Italian food around, hands down!!!“

“Been getting our wings n pizza here for a long long time and never had a bad pizza or wings....BUT today 5/10/20...mothers day I felt like pizza n wings..this is 1st time I was dissatisfied...spinach on pizza was not rinsed well was very bitter n still soggy...couldn't find the salami...not sure why it happened.“

“Seems new and improved! It had been a while since our last visit. The young man working drove through was clean cut, polite, & professional. The food was excellent and the prices are affordable. Thanks for being a quick and convenient place to pick up dinner in Poland!“

“Fast delievery and friendly drivers“

“The food was amazing along with the service, the wait time was very little and you had plenty to do as you waited. I would recommend the gyro with fries. Would go back. The price to food proportion was also amazing. I would come back for a filling good meal.“

“We have been coming here for a number of years and have never had anything that was not delicious. The salad is fresh, the dressing is so good it requires bread to dunk in and eat.. The vodka sauce was something I tried last time we ate there and it was so good, it made my eyes roll. For such a small space there is always room enough to have a quiet meal and enjoy the best dining around.“

“Had the pleasure of stopping in to deliver a package yesterday... the smell of great Italian food alone was enough to make me happy, but Brandi was kind enough to send me on my travels with a fresh slice with pepperoni... food while we're out on the road is greatly appreciated by myself and my fellow drivers... it's even better when the food is absolutely DELICIOUS!!! My only regret is that I don't live a bit closer lol... my fingers are crossed to get that route again soon... pretty sure I'll be ordering a whole pie next time! Thanks again, Brandi & Jay“

“Its best to order it fresh if not it like chewing cardboard and old alright 😅? I know from experience it was that old but we still ate it for 6 bucks so get the extra tasty pepperoni ones for 1 buck more is definitely worth the price and fresh is best . Oh they don't pick up the phone to order n need a card to order online no cash on delivery sorry 😐“