38 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Richmond

“The food was delicious. 10 out of 10. Give the cashier a raise. Lily was the best.“

“AJs has the best lunches n friendly people. Not only do you get a full lunch you get a great service and get to meet the friendly staff there. You guys are awesome 😎 and you rock!“

“Had a long drive after a soccer game and had hungry kids. We arrived just minutes before closing and Thomas was happy to make us a pizza and feed my kiddos. Not many restaurants or should I say restaurant employees would be so kind and willing to wait on us. Thank you Thomas and New Richmond Papa Johns. We will be back with a promise to get there earlier.“

“I love their new York styled pizza.“

“If you guys haven’t tried this Grammas locations Alfredo sauce, you HAVE to! This is the only location that has Alfredo. It’s absolutely amazing! We actually get it in our pizza instead of pizza sauce, and OMG. Just try it! 10 out of 10 highly recommend!“

“We got a variety of pizzas to go - for picky adults & pickier kids - all were amazing! We would have loved to dine in but had to grab & go.“

“Very welcome, took the family here for our daughters 4th birthday our server (Max) went above and beyond for our family. For the first time being here was very nice.“

“Pizza is great and people that work there are so nice. My kids love this place.“

“This Superior pizza parlor is the best thing in the area. It Is the only restaurant in the area but that does not say the pizza is not very good it's great. Ordered 8 pizza for an event at a wedding rehearsal. All the guests raved about the pizza they devoured it with much relish.“

“Delish and quick. It's always been busy when I've gone but the online ordering worked pretty good so it was grab and go once you got thru the line. Detroit style is a great change of pace from essentially everything other pizza place and punches well above its weight class in the cost/taste department.“

“delicious pizza done perfectly even with special instructions“

“Way to step up the game for not only your pizza, (best in town) but pricing, and very helpful and knowledgeable staff . Ryan was amazing when explaining deals and specials, as well as, what my options are with the best deals on toppings and even accomodated us with plates napkins silverware for our company tonight for this evenings fire very big bone fire. So way to go grandmas and the family keep up the keeping and I'll keep on eating!!! God bless love and lite, your pizza is in our bellies tonight“

“great staff prices are reasonable food is good fast clean and friendly Everytime“

“Great pizza! Everytime we're in town we order from the one on Sutton. Never disappointed. Very friendly and accommodating.“

“my husband and I have been wanting to try goodfellows for a while and today was the day and we absolutely loved the pizza we got pepperoni and cheese and it was some of the best ever ...Erin was our server and she was so sweet and helpful we didn't have much money we couldn't give her a bigger tip the place was nice and clean food was amazing we live in Anderson township we will be back. it's going to be our place for pizza drinks thanks for a wonderful dinner“

“Amazing service definitely recommend! Staff and pizza were amazing!!!“

“I decided to give them another try: my food was great. To the young lady with the long dark hair, I love your accent and your kindness. Keep up the great work ethics and you will definitely make it in life.“

“Jackson was our waiter. He was very pleasant and did a great job. Friendly service and the food was delicious.“

“Seating for large groups to gather!“

“Ive been eating Grammas all my life.I moved to Anderson and was bummed there wasnt one here. Low and behold they put one here. Been eating here since it opened. Always had the best of service and the food is always great.Thanks to the crew and management for always making us feel top prority and serving us the great food that you do. Will always be a loyal customer. Merry Christmas and happy new year guys, wish all of you the best.“

“I just ordered the new bacon cheese burger pizza. I added onion to it. It was my first time ordering it. IT WAS ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!!!!!!! One of the best pizzas I have ever ordered. I hope this will stay on the menu. Looking forward to ordering it again. GREAT JOB EVERYONE!!!!!!!! So delicious !!!!!!!“

“Love their pizza. I much rather wait 10mins. while I'm already out for than wait an hour for someone to bring it to my house.“

“Vegetarian options: Do not get any meat products if vegetarian

Dietary restrictions: Vegan, dairy, and other generic restrictions

Parking: Pickup, Curbside, Special Accessible Parking, normal parking

Kid-friendliness: Kid choices in menu and desserts“

“We ordered delivery on a Friday night through the app and were amazed at how fast it arrived.... Definitely the fastest pizza delivery ever. The food was super hot and David, the driver was so friendly. We will definitely order here next time. Great job! Keep up the good work!“

“It's 9:30 your crew is killing it. This combination of people work great together. Don't spilt them up. When it's busy the communication between them is incredible. They had 8-10 customers when I came in to the store and really had the energy turned up. Fun to watch.“

“I go to the Ohio Pike Domino's for the great carry out deals they send to the Domino's Rewards members. I can't make a large pizza at home for the price they charge on the cart out specials. The pizzas are better than Sam's club or Costco pizzas since you can top them like you want, for about the same price.“

“Order the new Papadias and the crust over done and dry. They need to brushed with butter maybe to help the ends of the crust from drying out. I think the ones I got were over done.“

“Had a great experience this evening. I had the steak hoagie and waffle fries. I have Celiac and have to be strictly Gluten Free. And I was getting ready to explain it to the waitress she informed me she also has Celiac and ensured me I was safe. A great feeling that I don't get often eating out. Will be back for sure“

“This place can be hit or miss but then again it's Papa John's staff is always friendly though when the pizzas made good it's a really good but when it's bad it can be bad. I will still continue to go to this location because it's so close to the house!“

“This is truly the best Papa John's around! Marc and the team at Clough are friendly and so helpful. We had a large order for my autistic daughters birthday party, its her favorite pizza place (we have to order at least once or twice a week) and the amazing team went above and beyond for her! They even gave her a card!! Made her birthday so special! Thank you all SO much“

“I ordered a custom pizza with half pepperoni and half margarita. They have different sauces on them and I thought it was awesome that someone from the restaurant called to make sure I knew that those sauces might bleed into each other when they go through the oven. Clearly that's not something that they can control but they just wanted to make sure I was aware because they're two different flavors. The fact that they went out of their way to let me know meant a lot. Some places won't even let you customize a pizza with two different sauces on each half because of this. I used to work at a pizza place so I knew what I was getting into when I ordered it. And I'm glad they allowed me to have it the way I wanted it. It was absolutely amazing! That thin crust is so refreshing. It's kind of dangerous because you don't fill up and feel miserable as you're eating it like you do with most thicker crusts. You can eat a lot more of their pizza because of how light it feels. But gosh it's good! Actually I'm kind of craving it now that I'm talking about it. Haha.“

“Not only is our pizzas cooks perfectly, I gave them a 20% tip in cash and you would’ve thought the world stopped. The general manager came out to the parking lot and told me I’m welcome anytime so not only your pizza good but their customer service is absolutely out of this world.“

“Nice guys nice customer service It's my 4th time and the pizza is great“

“Since their re opening the pizza etc is pretty good.I definitely recommend it.“

“Jackie was the only one working when I arrived and had my order fresh and ready to go. Was very polite and did not forget my sauces. Food was perfect and I know for a fact that Jackie made it considering she was the only one working. Thanks to Jackie I was able to get my food! 😁“

“My first time experience, I got the mushroom Swiss burger and I am absolutely thrilled!!! Tastes so amazing and made by the kindest people, definitely will be eating here again!!“

“Ordered online and I noticed it wasn't updating the progress as it usually did. When it got close to my pick up time I drove the 5 min up the road to get them. When I went in I understood what was happening. There were 3 people working as hard as they could and the orders were just rolling in. They greeted me and let me know what was going on so I just sat down to wait. The employee apologized but seriously they were working hard.... and all the orders were multiple pizzas. So when mine came up I thanked them and left a tip and told them I understood and I could see they were working hard. The pizzas were exactly what we ordered and hot and delicious. I'll be back again. Thanks again to the staff members working hard to keep up tonight.“